Transition State Mimetics of the Plasmodium Export Element Are Potent Inhibitors of Plasmepsin V from P. falciparum and P. vivax

Following erythrocyte invasion, malaria parasites export a catalogue of remodeling proteins into the infected cell that enable parasite development in the human host. Export is dependent on the activity of the aspartyl protease, plasmepsin V (PMV), which cleaves proteins within the Plasmodium export element (PEXEL; RxL↓xE/Q/D) in the parasite’s endoplasmic reticulum. Here, we generated transition state mimetics of the native PEXEL substrate that potently inhibit PMV isolated from Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax. Through optimization, we identified that the activity of the mimetics was completely dependent on the presence of P₁ Leu and P₃ Arg. Treatment of P. falciparum-infected erythrocytes with a set of optimized mimetics impaired PEXEL processing and killed the parasites. The striking effect of the compounds provides a clearer understanding of the accessibility of the PMV active site and reaffirms the enzyme as an attractive target for the design of future antimalarials

Identification of putative phosphosites and parasite kinase involved in modification of PfRh4 cytoplasmic tail.

<p>(A) <i>In vitro</i> kinase assays of wildtype and putative phosphosite mutations in PfRh4 cytoplasmic domains. The amino acid sequence of the PfRh4 cytoplasmic tail is shown with serines and tyrosines highlighted with the residue number. Each potential phosphosite on the PfRh4 tail was individually mutated to alanine. The all 4 lane has mutations in S1667A, S1674A, Y1680A and Y1684A and the all 5 lane has S1652A, S1667A, S1674A, Y1680A and Y1684A putative kinase sites mutated. The phosphorylation signal was quantitated and adjusted for protein loading. The loading-adjusted mutant phosphorylation signals were divided by the wildtype and plotted as a percentage of the wildtype signal (Y-axis). Autoradiograph of proteins after incubation in the <i>in vitro</i> phosphorylation assay and Coomassie gel from which protein loading was quantitated are shown in lower panels. Lane labels (X-axis) denote residues mutated to alanine. Mean percentage of wildtype phosphorylation +1 standard error of the mean are displayed. Data was averaged from four experiments performed on separate days. (B) Dosage-response curve for PfRh4 tail phosphorylation by merozoite lysate in the presence of increasing concentrations of the CK2 inhibitor TBB. PfRh4 tail phosphorylation was quantitated after incubation in <i>in vitro</i> phosphorylation assay with TBB. The phosphorylation signal for each condition was adjusted to reflect the average amount of protein loaded across each condition, determined by densitometry of the Coomassie brilliant blue stained gel. Y-axis represents loading-adjusted phosphorylation signal as a percentage of phosphorylation in the presence of DMSO (control). Autoradiograph of wildtype GST-fused PfRh4 proteins after incubation in the <i>in vitro</i> phosphorylation assay. X-axis indicates the TBB concentration with which the phosphorylation assay was incubated or DMSO. (C) <i>In vitro</i> kinase assays of PfRh and EBL cytoplasmic tails. The phosphorylation signal was quantitated and adjusted for protein loading. Autoradiograph of proteins after incubation in the <i>in vitro</i> phosphorylation assay and Coomassie brilliant blue stained gel from which protein loading was quantitated are shown. Data was averaged from four experiments performed on separate days (right panel) and standard error of the mean is shown. The following sites were mutated: EBA140 (S1159A, S1168A, T1173A), EBA175 (T1466A, mut A) and (S1489A, mut B) and in combination (mut A and B), EBA181 (S1528A, S1553A, S1557A, T1564A), PfRh2a (S3128A) and PfRh2b (S3233).</p

Specific amino acid residues in the cytoplasmic domain are essential for PfRh4 function.

<p>(A) Localization of PfRh4 and PfRh2 in Rh4-WT tail, RH4-AMA1tail, Rh4-mut4tail and RH4-mut5tail lines as detected using anti-PfRh4 monoclonal and anti-PfRh2 polyclonal antibodies. Parasite nuclei were stained with DAPI. (B) Expression of PfRh4 and PfRh2 in W2mefΔ175 and all transgenic lines as detected by anti-PfRh4 and anti-PfRh2 antibody. All transgenic lines migrated as a slightly larger doublet compared to PfRh4 in W2mefΔ175, consistent with the addition of the hexa-histidine tag at the C-terminus of the protein. (C) Growth assays of transgenic lines with four and five mutations at serine and tyrosine amino acid residues in the PfRh4 cytoplasmic tail. (D) Growth assays of single mutations in the PfRh4 cytoplasmic tail. (E) Growth assays of double mutations in the PfRh4 cytoplasmic tail. In all three panels, parasitaemia was measured in neuraminidase-treated, and untreated erythrocytes after every 48 hours incubation (labelled as cycles). The parasite lines used in this experiment are displayed on the X-axis. The y-axis represents parasitaemia of neuraminidase-treated erythrocytes as a percentage of parasitaemia of the same line grown on untreated erythrocytes. Error bars represent +1 standard error of the mean. Assay performed three times on separate days, each in triplicate.</p

PMV conservation and expression.

<p>(A) Structure and size of PMVHA proteins used in this study. Catalytic dyad residues DTG/DSG are shown including Asp to Ala mutations* in red. TM, transmembrane domain. (B) Immunoblot of infected erythrocytes with α-HA antibodies shows expression of PMVHA proteins in <i>P. falciparum</i>. Sizes indicate that the signal peptides were removed (PfPMVHA, 69.1 kDa; PvPMVHA, 60.9 kDa). (C) Immunoblotting of infected erythrocytes with rabbit α-PfPMV antibodies (Rα-PfPMV) validates they are specific for PfPMV. Endogenous PfPMV is the lower band (lanes 1, 3, 4, 5), and the larger band corresponds to 3× HA-tagged PfPMV (lanes 2, 4). Aldolase is a loading control in (B) and (C) and shows slight overloading of some lanes compared to others. (D, Top) Immunofluorescence micrographs show rabbit α-PfPMV antibodies (Rα-PfPMV, green) label PfPMV in the ER. Colocalizations were performed with mouse α-PfPMV antibodies (Mα-PfPMV, red), shown previously to label PMV in the ER <a href="http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001897#pbio.1001897-Klemba1" target="_blank">[16]</a>. (Middle) α-HA antibodies (red) label PfPMVHA (Top) and PvPMVHA (Bottom) in the parasite ER. (Bottom) α-HA antibodies (red) label PvPMVHA in the ER, as shown by clocalization with ERC (green). (E) Immunopurified PfPMVHA and PvPMVHA cleave KAHRP peptides containing the PEXEL sequence RTLAQ but not peptides containing point mutations R>K, L>I, or RL>A. Pf and Pv PMVmutHA proteins with catalytic D>A mutations did not cleave the KAHRP RTLAQ peptide. (F) Overexpression of PfPMVmutHA from episomes in <i>P. falciparum</i> 3D7 impairs growth relative to expression of a similar episomal construct encoding a mini PfEMP1HA reporter (miniVarHA). Parasites expressing episomes were selected on 5 nM WR99210 (WR). Two starting inocula were used in triplicate wells, and parasitaemia was determined at 72 h. *<i>p</i><.0001 (<i>t</i> test). Data are mean ± SEM from duplicate experiments.</p

PMV inhibition impairs protein export, PfEMP1 display, and cytoadherence.

<p>(A) (Top) Immunofluorescent micrographs show Hyp8-GFP is exported and localizes within puncta in the infected erythrocyte. (Middle) Hyp8-HA localizes within SBP1-containing MCs. (Right) Immunoelectron microscopy shows Hyp8-HA localization at MCs. Scale bar is 100 nm. (B) Maximum intensity projection micrographs showing export of Hyp8-GFP to MCs and secretion of EXP2 to the parasitophorous vacuole membrane following treatment with DMSO or 916 (50 µM). Puncta of nonexported GFP within the parasite and vacuole is shown (arrows). (C) GFP intensity in MCs (outside EXP2 signal) and within the parasite and parasitophorous vacuole (inside EXP2 signal) was quantified following drug treatment (see <a href="http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001897#s4" target="_blank">Materials and Methods</a>) and is presented as a ratio: exported = ratio outside/inside EXP2. The number of infected cells counted (<i>n</i>) is shown. (D) GFP within the parasite and parasitophorous vacuole (inside EXP2 signal) was quantified across treatments and is presented as a ratio: nonexported = ratio inside/outside EXP2. (E) EXP2 intensity in the parasitophorous vacuole membrane (red) was quantified across treatments and is presented as average (threshold) signal. (F) The number of GFP-positive MCs per infected erythrocyte was quantified across treatments. Error bars represent the mean ±SEM, and <i>p</i> values were determined by ANOVA in (C–F). (G) Surface-exposed PfEMP1 (VAR2CSA) on infected erythrocytes was measured following inhibitor treatment by FACS using monoclonal human PAM1.4 serum <a href="http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001897#pbio.1001897-Barfod1" target="_blank">[30]</a>. Geometric mean fluorescence of >100,000 cells per condition are shown relative to no treatment. Parasites received inhibitor at 15 µM for 23 h (15 µM) or 50 µM for 12 h followed by a reduction to 15 µM for 11 h (50>15 µM). Shown is a single representative of duplicate experiments. Raw FACS data are presented in <a href="http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001897#pbio.1001897.s007" target="_blank">Figure S7</a>. (H) Adhesion of infected red blood cells (iRBCs) to chondroitin sulfate A (CSA) under static conditions. Adherent iRBCs were counted in ten 0.28 mm² fields of view per sample from triplicate samples and are shown as number of iRBCs per mm². Shown is a single representative of duplicate experiments. Data represent mean ±SEM. 95% confidence intervals are shown (grey dashed lines). 916 significantly reduced adhesion to CSA <i>p</i><.0001.</p

WEHI-916 is lethal to <i>P. falciparum</i> 3D7.

<p>(A) Dose-response curves of <i>P. falciparum</i> 3D7 in the presence of 916, 024, or 025. EC₅₀ values are shown. (B) Parasitemia measured at 72 h (<i>y</i>-axis) following drug treatment at rings (30 min postinvasion) and replacement of the medium with inhibitor-free medium (wash-out) at the time intervals shown (<i>x</i>-axis). (C) Parasitemia at 72 h (<i>y</i>-axis) after replacement of inhibitor-free medium with media containing compounds at the intervals shown (<i>x</i>-axis). Parasitemia was determined by FACS in (A–C) and is relative to DMSO treatment in (B) and (C). Concentrations are as follows: 916, 024, 025 (15 µM); CQ, chloroquine (150 ng/ml); ART, artemisinin (100 ng/ml). Error bars in (A–C) are mean ±SEM from duplicate experiments. (D) Light micrographs of Giemsa-stained parasites 16 and 32 h after drug treatment at early rings (15 µM). 916-treated parasites failed to develop into trophozoites and did not recover. Ring parasites treated with E-64 (10 µM) <a href="http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001897#pbio.1001897-terKuile1" target="_blank">[22]</a> contained swollen food vacuoles (arrow) due to inhibition of proteases involved in hemoglobin degradation; however, treatment with DMSO, 916, 024, or 025 did not cause swelling. Swelling was quantified using 500 infected cells per condition in duplicate. Scale bar is 6 µm.</p

WEHI-916 blocks PEXEL cleavage in <i>P. falciparum</i>.

<p>(A) Immunoblotting with α-GFP antibodies shows dose-dependent inhibition of PEXEL cleavage of PfEMP3-GFP in parasites after 5 h 916 treatment at the indicated concentrations. Uncleaved protein (black arrow), PEXEL-cleaved protein (blue arrow), and degraded chimera in food vacuole (GFP only) are labeled. PfEMP3-GFP R>A PEXEL mutant is shown as a size control. (B) Immunoblot shows time-dependent inhibition of PEXEL cleavage in parasites. HSP70 is a loading control in (A) and (B) and densitometry of the uncleaved band in each lane is shown below the blots in (A) and (B). (C) Immunoblot shows 916 treatment (20 and 50 µM for 5 h) causes accumulation of uncleaved PfEMP3-GFP and KAHRP-GFP (black arrow), but 024 and 025 have no effect. R>A PEXEL mutant size controls are shown. Signal peptide-cleaved species of KAHRP-GFP, but not PfEMP3-GFP, can be seen (red arrow). (D) Immunoblotting shows no defect (black arrow indicates the predicted size of uncleaved protein; ∼30 kDa) in signal peptide cleavage (red arrow; 27 kDa) of SERA5s-GFP, which lacks a PEXEL, following treatment with 916, 024, or 025 (20 µM for 5 h). Aldolase was a loading control in (C) and (D). (E) ³⁵S-Methionine/Cysteine labeling of PfEMP3-GFP in parasites reveals the rapid rate of translation, ER import, and N-terminal processing in <i>P. falciparum</i>. Uncleaved (black arrow), signal peptide-cleaved (red arrow), PEXEL-cleaved (blue arrow), and GFP-only (food vacuole) species are shown. Densitometry of each band per lane (colored traces) is shown. Uncleaved (Un, black), signal peptide-cleaved (SP, red), and PEXEL-cleaved (PEX, blue) bands are shown as percentage of total intensity per lane. Signal peptide-cleaved PfEMP3-GFP can be seen (red arrow, trace). (F) The experiment in (E) was performed after 916 treatment (20 µM for 5 h). Uncleaved protein was most abundant. Note low intensity of bands indicated by red and blue arrows and delay in their appearance compared to (E). (G) Densitometry showing the ratio of PEXEL-cleaved to -uncleaved PfEMP3-GFP with or without 916 treatment (determined using 15 min lanes in (E) and (F)).</p

A PEXEL-mimetic inhibitor of PMV.

<p>(A) Nomenclature for each residue in the PEXEL substrate (circles) and each pocket of the PMV active site (semicircles) with respect to the cleavage site (arrow). (B) Compound structures in this study include PMV inhibitor WEHI-916 and control analogs WEHI-024 and WEHI-025. (C) Structural model of PfPMV bound to WEHI-916. Residues forming the S₃ site, Try177, Glu179, and Glu215, form interactions with the guanidine side chain of WEHI-916. The Leu side chain of WEHI-916 packs tightly against the side-chain groups of Ile116, Tyr177, and Val227 in the S₁ site. The statine hydroxyl forms hydrogen bonds with the two catalytic aspartate residues Asp118 and Asp365. (D) Inhibition of PfPMV and PvPMV by WEHI-916 (blue) and weak activities of WEHI-024 (red) and WEHI-025 (brown). The grey box summarizes compound activity against BACE-1 and Cathepsin D (CathD) and lack of toxicity against human HEpG2 cells and Human Foreskin Fibroblasts (HFF).</p

PMV knockdown or overexpression modulates sensitivity to WEHI-916.

<p>(A) Immunoblot with Rα-PfPMV antibodies shows successful integration of the PMVHA-<i>glmS</i> or -M9 plasmid (M9 is an inactive <i>glmS</i> riboswitch control). The upper band (α-PfPMV blot) in lane 1 (denoted by *) is nonspecific. The same blot is shown below, probed with α-HA antibodies. HSP70 is a loading control. (B) Knockdown of PMV in <i>P. falciparum</i> NF54 following 5 mM GlcN treatment. (Left) 0 h GlcN treatment of trophozoites causes no knockdown. (Center) The 24 h GlcN treatment of trophozoites causes ∼80% knockdown of PMV in subsequent rings compared to “−GlcN.” (Right) 48 h GlcN treatment of trophozoites causes ∼90% knockdown of PMV in subsequent trophozoites compared to “−GlcN.” A small degree of knockdown is seen for M9, indicating GlcN has a minor effect. (C) PMV knockdown by GlcN has no significant effect on parasite growth rate (<i>p</i> = .6250). Trophozoites were treated with 0 mM or 5 mM GlcN and parasitaemia determined 48 h later by flow cytometry. Data are % growth “+GlcN” relative to “−GlcN,” and data are mean ±SEM of a representative of duplicate experiments. (D) PEXEL processing of PfEMP3-GFP in <i>P. falciparum</i> parasites expressing PMVHA-<i>glmS</i> is reduced more by 916 treatment when PMV is knocked down [+GlcN (5 mM for 48 h prior to addition of 916)]. Densitometry shows the ratio of uncleaved to PEXEL-cleaved protein in each lane beneath the blot. Note that PfEMP3-GFP expression is lower in “+GlcN” parasites despite relatively similar HSP70 levels. (E) Dose-response curves of <i>P. falciparum</i> expressing PMVHA-<i>glmS</i> shows parasites have enhanced sensitivity to 916 following PMV knockdown (3.3-fold decrease in EC₅₀). Parasitemia was determined 72 h after addition of 916 to ring parasites with or without PMV knockdown (knockdown ring parasites were obtained by adding 6 mM GlcN to trophozoites for 24 h). GlcN and 916 were maintained in the culture medium throughout. (F) Dose-response curves of <i>P. falciparum</i> overexpressing PvPMVHA or a mini PfEMP1HA reporter (miniVarHA) in the presence of 5 nM WR99210 show parasites have increased resistance to 916 when PMV is overexpressed (1.9-fold increase in EC₅₀).</p