Mean--field electrodynamics: Critical analysis of various analytical approaches to the mean electromotive force

There are various analytical approaches to the mean electromotive force $\cal E =$ crucial in mean--field electrodynamics, with $\vec{u}$ and $\vec{b}$ being velocity and magnetic field fluctuations. In most cases the traditional approach, restricted to the second--order correlation approximation, has been used. Its validity is only guaranteed for a range of conditions, which is narrow in view of many applications, e.g., in astrophysics. With the intention to have a wider range of applicability other approaches have been proposed which make use of the so--called $\tau$--approximation, reducing correlations of third order in $\vec{u}$ and $\vec{b}$ to such of second order. After explaining some basic features of the traditional approach a critical analysis of the approaches of that kind is given. It is shown that they lead in some cases to results which are in clear conflict with those of the traditional approach. It is argued that this indicates shortcomings of the $\tau$--approaches and poses serious restrictions to their applicability. These shortcomings do not result from the basic assumption of the $\tau$--approximation. Instead, they seem to originate in some simplifications made in order to derive $\cal E$ without really solving the equations governing $\vec{u}$ and $\vec{b}$. A starting point for a new approach is described which avoids the conflict.Comment: 32 pages, no figures; accepted by Geophys. Astrophys. Fluid Dynam. A quenching formula for \alpha and a section on comparisons with numerical simulations added; references amended; changes in presentation and languag

Fanning out of the ff-mode in presence of nonuniform magnetic fields

We show that in the presence of a harmonically varying magnetic field the fundamental or $f$-mode in a stratified layer is altered in such a way that it fans out in the diagnostic $k\omega$ diagram, but with mode power also within the fan. In our simulations, the surface is defined by a temperature and density jump in a piecewise isothermal layer. Unlike our previous work (Singh et al. 2014) where a uniform magnetic field was considered, we employ here a nonuniform magnetic field together with hydromagnetic turbulence at length scales much smaller than those of the magnetic fields. The expansion of the $f$-mode is stronger for fields confined to the layer below the surface. In some of those cases, the $k\omega$ diagram also reveals a new class of low frequency vertical stripes at multiples of twice the horizontal wavenumber of the background magnetic field. We argue that the study of the $f$-mode expansion might be a new and sensitive tool to determining subsurface magnetic fields with longitudinal periodicity.Comment: 6 pages, 4 figures, submitted to Astrophysical Journal Letter

Properties of pp- and ff-modes in hydromagnetic turbulence

With the ultimate aim of using the fundamental or $f$-mode to study helioseismic aspects of turbulence-generated magnetic flux concentrations, we use randomly forced hydromagnetic simulations of a piecewise isothermal layer in two dimensions with reflecting boundaries at top and bottom. We compute numerically diagnostic wavenumber-frequency diagrams of the vertical velocity at the interface between the denser gas below and the less dense gas above. For an Alfv\'en-to-sound speed ratio of about 0.1, a 5% frequency increase of the $f$-mode can be measured when $k_xH_{\rm p}=3$-$4$, where $k_x$ is the horizontal wavenumber and $H_{\rm p}$ is the pressure scale height at the surface. Since the solar radius is about 2000 times larger than $H_{\rm p}$, the corresponding spherical harmonic degree would be 6000-8000. For weaker fields, a $k_x$-dependent frequency decrease by the turbulent motions becomes dominant. For vertical magnetic fields, the frequency is enhanced for $k_xH_{\rm p}\approx4$, but decreased relative to its nonmagnetic value for $k_xH_{\rm p}\approx9$.Comment: 17 pages, 22 figures, Version accepted in MNRA

Scalable communication for high-order stencil computations using CUDA-aware MPI

Modern compute nodes in high-performance computing provide a tremendous level of parallelism and processing power. However, as arithmetic performance has been observed to increase at a faster rate relative to memory and network bandwidths, optimizing data movement has become critical for achieving strong scaling in many communication-heavy applications. This performance gap has been further accentuated with the introduction of graphics processing units, which can provide by multiple factors higher throughput in data-parallel tasks than central processing units. In this work, we explore the computational aspects of iterative stencil loops and implement a generic communication scheme using CUDA-aware MPI, which we use to accelerate magnetohydrodynamics simulations based on high-order finite differences and third-order Runge-Kutta integration. We put particular focus on improving intra-node locality of workloads. In comparison to a theoretical performance model, our implementation exhibits strong scaling from one to $64$ devices at $50\%$--$87\%$ efficiency in sixth-order stencil computations when the problem domain consists of $256^3$--$1024^3$ cells.Comment: 17 pages, 15 figure

Interaction of large- and small-scale dynamos in isotropic turbulent flows from GPU-accelerated simulations

Magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) dynamos emerge in many different astrophysical situations where turbulence is present, but the interaction between large-scale (LSD) and small-scale dynamos (SSD) is not fully understood. We performed a systematic study of turbulent dynamos driven by isotropic forcing in isothermal MHD with magnetic Prandtl number of unity, focusing on the exponential growth stage. Both helical and non-helical forcing was employed to separate the effects of LSD and SSD in a periodic domain. Reynolds numbers (Rm) up to $\approx 250$ were examined and multiple resolutions used for convergence checks. We ran our simulations with the Astaroth code, designed to accelerate 3D stencil computations on graphics processing units (GPUs) and to employ multiple GPUs with peer-to-peer communication. We observed a speedup of $\approx 35$ in single-node performance compared to the widely used multi-CPU MHD solver Pencil Code. We estimated the growth rates both from the averaged magnetic fields and their power spectra. At low Rm, LSD growth dominates, but at high Rm SSD appears to dominate in both helically and non-helically forced cases. Pure SSD growth rates follow a logarithmic scaling as a function of Rm. Probability density functions of the magnetic field from the growth stage exhibit SSD behaviour in helically forced cases even at intermediate Rm. We estimated mean-field turbulence transport coefficients using closures like the second-order correlation approximation (SOCA). They yield growth rates similar to the directly measured ones and provide evidence of $\alpha$ quenching. Our results are consistent with the SSD inhibiting the growth of the LSD at moderate Rm, while the dynamo growth is enhanced at higher Rm.Comment: 22 pages, 23 figures, 2 tables, Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journa

Nonlinear magnetic diffusivity and alpha tensors in helical turbulence

The effect of a dynamo-generated mean magnetic field of Beltrami type on the mean electromotive force is studied. In the absence of the mean magnetic field the turbulence is assumed to be homogeneous and isotropic, but it becomes inhomogeneous and anisotropic with this field. Using the testfield method the dependence of the alpha and turbulent diffusivity tensors on the magnetic Reynolds number Rm is determined for magnetic fields that have reached approximate equipartition with the velocity field. The tensor components are characterized by a pseudoscalar alpha and a scalar turbulent magnetic diffusivity etat. Increasing Rm from 2 to 600 reduces etat by a factor ~5, suggesting that the quenching of etat is, in contrast to the 2-dimensional case, only weakly dependent on Rm. Over the same range of Rm, however, alpha is reduced by a factor ~14, which can qualitatively be explained by a corresponding increase of a magnetic contribution to the alpha effect with opposite sign. The level of fluctuations of alpha and etat is only 10% and 20% of the respective kinematic reference values.Comment: 4 pages, 3 figs, ApJL (accepted version

Mean-field diffusivities in passive scalar and magnetic transport in irrotational flows

Certain aspects of the mean-field theory of turbulent passive scalar transport and of mean-field electrodynamics are considered with particular emphasis on aspects of compressible fluids. It is demonstrated that the total mean-field diffusivity for passive scalar transport in a compressible flow may well be smaller than the molecular diffusivity. This is in full analogy to an old finding regarding the magnetic mean-field diffusivity in an electrically conducting turbulently moving compressible fluid. These phenomena occur if the irrotational part of the motion dominates the vortical part, the P\`eclet or magnetic Reynolds number is not too large, and, in addition, the variation of the flow pattern is slow. For both the passive scalar and the magnetic cases several further analytical results on mean-field diffusivities and related quantities found within the second-order correlation approximation are presented, as well as numerical results obtained by the test-field method, which applies independently of this approximation. Particular attention is paid to non-local and non-instantaneous connections between the turbulence-caused terms and the mean fields. Two examples of irrotational flows, in which interesting phenomena in the above sense occur, are investigated in detail. In particular, it is demonstrated that the decay of a mean scalar in a compressible fluid under the influence of these flows can be much slower than without any flow, and can be strongly influenced by the so-called memory effect, that is, the fact that the relevant mean-field coefficients depend on the decay rates themselves.Comment: 13 pages, 10 figures, published on PR

Compressible Test-field Method and Its Application to Shear Dynamos

| openaire: EC/H2020/818665/EU//UniSDyn Funding Information: We acknowledge fruitful and inspiring discussions with Prof. Nishant Singh, Dr. Hongzhe Zhou, Dr. Jonathan Squire, and Prof. Amitava Bhattacharjee, many of which took place in the inspiring atmosphere of the Max Planck Princeton Center for Plasma Physics framework. M.J.K. and M.R. acknowledge the support of the Academy of Finland ReSoLVE Centre of Excellence (grant number 307411). This project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Project UniSDyn, grant agreement n:o 818665). A.B. acknowledges support through the Swedish Research Council (Vetenskapsrådet), grant 2019-04234. Publisher Copyright: © 2022. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.In this study, we present a compressible test-field method (CTFM) for computing α-effect and turbulent magnetic diffusivity tensors, as well as those relevant for the mean ponderomotive force and mass source, applied to the full MHD equations. We describe the theoretical background of the method and compare it to the quasi-kinematic test-field method and to the previously studied variant working in simplified MHD (SMHD). We present several test cases using velocity and magnetic fields of the Roberts geometry and also compare with the imposed-field method. We show that, for moderate imposed-field strengths, the nonlinear CTFM (nCTFM) gives results in agreement with the imposed-field method. A comparison of different flavors of the nCTFM in the shear dynamo case also yields agreement up to equipartition field strengths. Some deviations between the CTFM and SMHD variants exist. As a relevant physical application, we study nonhelically forced shear flows, which exhibit large-scale dynamo action, and present a reanalysis of low-Reynolds-number, moderate shear systems, where we previously ignored the pressure gradient in the momentum equation and found no coherent shear-current effect. Another key difference is that in the earlier study we used magnetic forcing to mimic small-scale dynamo action, while here it is self-consistently driven by purely kinetic forcing. The kinematic CTFM with general validity forms the core of our analysis. We still find no coherent shear-current effect, but do recover strong large-scale dynamo action that, according to our analysis, is driven by incoherent effects.Peer reviewe