Fair Inputs and Fair Outputs: The Incompatibility of Fairness in Privacy and Accuracy

Fairness concerns about algorithmic decision-making systems have been mainly focused on the outputs (e.g., the accuracy of a classifier across individuals or groups). However, one may additionally be concerned with fairness in the inputs. In this paper, we propose and formulate two properties regarding the inputs of (features used by) a classifier. In particular, we claim that fair privacy (whether individuals are all asked to reveal the same information) and need-to-know (whether users are only asked for the minimal information required for the task at hand) are desirable properties of a decision system. We explore the interaction between these properties and fairness in the outputs (fair prediction accuracy). We show that for an optimal classifier these three properties are in general incompatible, and we explain what common properties of data make them incompatible. Finally we provide an algorithm to verify if the trade-off between the three properties exists in a given dataset, and use the algorithm to show that this trade-off is common in real data

Response Regarding Inherited Regulations and Inherited Rulemaking Authorities (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0012)

Response offering comment on the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau\u27s inherited regulations and inherited rulemaking authorities

Response Regarding Bureau Enforcement Processes (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0003)

Response discussing whether the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau should stop taking enforcement actions against companies and people who violate the consumer financial protection laws

Response Regarding Bureau Rulemaking Processes (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0009)

Response discussing whether the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau should alter its procedures for adopting new rules to protect consumers

Response Regarding Bureau External Engagements (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0005)

Response discussing whether the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau should change the way it reaches out to public and the financial industry

Response Regarding Bureau Guidance and Implementation Support (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0013)

Response discussing whether the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau should continue its programs offering formal and informal guidance and implementation support

Response Regarding the Bureau’s Consumer Complaint and Consumer Inquiry Handling Processes (Docket No. CFPB-2018-0014)

Response discussing whether the Consumer Federal Protection Bureau should change its processes for dealing with consumer complaints and consumer inquiries