6 research outputs found
Comment Sections of News Websites as Counterpublic Spaces
Research scrutinizing political talk online has been developed largely against
the backdrop of deliberative discursive norms and considered political talk
without a systematic analysis of surrounding mass-mediated discourses. By
contrast, this study operationalizes counterpublic theory as an alternative
theoretical perspective and analyzes comments on news websites as a reaction
to hegemonic mainstream public spheres. It juxtaposes a qualitative framing
analysis of all articles about a new anti-Euro party in devotedly pro-European
Germany published on 9 news websites in the week following the 2013 elections
(n = 22) with a content analysis of all comments posted below these articles
(n = 3,154). It finds counterpublic spheres differently shaped in comment
sections of right- and left-leaning, and tabloid and nontabloid, outlets.
Consequences for democracy are discussed
Targeting dominant publics: How counterpublic commenters align their efforts with mainstream news
This study illustrates how the emphasis structure of counterpublic discourses surfacing online can be predicted by that of the dominant publics that these counterpublics—at the argumentative level—so resolutely oppose. Deploying a single common case study design, the article scrutinizes a counterpublic discourse that surfaced in the comment sections of Germany’s opinion-leading news websites in the week after the surprising electoral success of a new anti-Euro party, the Alternative für Deutschland (AfD). Quantitative content analysis identifies 75% of all comments posted (N = 2955) to all articles about the AfD (N = 19) as part of an anti-Euro counterpublic. While this counterpublic sharply opposed the editorial lines of Germany’s unanimously pro-common-currency media, it still aligned its efforts closely with this dominant public—albeit at a deeper level. As the findings demonstrate, the frequencies with which commenters adopted six emphasis frames were significantly predicted by the frequencies of these frames in mainstream news