35 research outputs found

    Regional Frequency Analysis at Ungauged Sites with Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines.

    Get PDF
    Hydrological systems are naturally complex and nonlinear. A large number of variables, many of which not yet well considered in regional frequency analysis (RFA), have a significant impact on hydrological dynamics and consequently on flood quantile estimates. Despite the increasing number of statistical tools used to estimate flood quantiles at ungauged sites, little attention has been dedicated to the development of new regional estimation (RE) models accounting for both nonlinear links and interactions between hydrological and physio-meteorological variables. The aim of this paper is to simultaneously take into account nonlinearity and interactions between variables by introducing the multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS) approach in RFA. The predictive performances of MARS are compared with those obtained by one of the most robust RE models: the generalized additive model (GAM). Both approaches are applied to two datasets covering 151 hydrometric stations in the province of Quebec (Canada): a standard dataset (STA) containing commonly used variables and an extended dataset (EXTD) combining STA with additional variables dealing with drainage network characteristics. Results indicate that RE models using MARS with the EXTD outperform slightly RE models using GAM. Thus, MARS seems to allow for a better representation of the hydrological process and an increased predictive power in RFA

    Evaluation of additional physiographical variables characterising drainage network systems in regional frequency analysis, a Quebec watersheds case-study

    No full text
    Regional Frequency Analysis (RFA) relies on a wide range of physiographical and meteorological variables to estimate hydrological quantiles at ungauged sites. However, additional catchment characteristics related to its drainage network are not yet fully understood and integrated in RFA procedures. The aim of the present paper is to propose the integration of several physiographical variables characterizing the drainage network systems in RFA, and to evaluate their added value in predicting quantiles at ungauged sites. The proposed extended dataset (EXTD) includes several variables characterising drainage network characteristics. To evaluate the new variables, a number of commonly used RFA approaches are applied to the extended data representing 151 stations in Quebec (Canada) and compared to a standard dataset (STA) that excludes the new variables. The considered RFA approaches include the combination of two neighborhood methods namely the canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and the region of influence (ROI) with two regional estimation (RE) models which are the log-linear regression model (LLRM) and the generalized additive model (GAM). The RE models are also applied without the hydrological neighborhood. Results show that regional models using the extended dataset lead to significantly better flood quantile predictions, especially for large basins. Indeed, the variable selection performed with EXTD consistently includes some of the new variables, in particular the drainage density, the stream length ratio, and the ruggedness number. Two other new variables are also identified and included in the DHR step: the circularity ratio and the texture ratio. This leads to better predictions with relative errors about 29% for EXTD, versus around 42% for STA in the case of the best combination of RFA approaches. Thus, the proposed new variables allow for a better representation of the physical dynamics within the watersheds

    A Network Approach for Delineating Homogeneous Regions in Regional Flood Frequency Analysis

    Full text link
    Regional flood frequency analysis forms the basis for ascertaining design thresholds for extreme flow events for the purpose of resource management and design of hydraulic structures, especially at ungauged or partially gauged basins. A crucial step in this analysis is transferring available information from gauged sites to ungauged sites, which is achieved through delineation of homogeneous regions encompassing multiple catchment locations, followed by the formulation of a flood estimation model. While this process has been accomplished through a range of statistical homogenization alternatives, the present study offers a new approach rooted in the theory of complex networks, offering considerable advantages over what is traditionally followed. Data from 202 sites in Australia representing catchments of varying geographic, climatic, and vegetation attributes are used to assess the alternative proposed. The results are examined via (1) direct comparison of the location and number of homogeneous neighbors from network theory with results using canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and (2) assessing the accuracy of estimated flood quantiles by applying a common model that estimates flood quantiles using information from the two alternate groups of homogeneous sites (from network theory and CCA). Results show that network theory offers merit in delineating homogenous regions, with resulting design flood estimates showing improvements across different return periods compared to the CCA alternative used
    corecore