A Thermodynamic Model for Multivalency in 14-3-3 Protein-Protein Interactions

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are at the core of molecular control over cellular function. Multivalency in PPI formation, such as via proteins with multiple binding sites and different valencies, requires fundamental understanding to address correlated challenges in pathologies and drug development. Thermodynamic binding models are needed to provide frameworks for describing multivalent PPIs. We established a model based on ditopic host-guest systems featuring the effective molarity, a hallmark property of multivalency, as a prime parameter governing the intramolecular binding in divalent interactions. By way of illustration, we study the interaction of the bivalent 14-3-3 protein scaffold with both the nonavalent CFTR and the hexavalent LRRK2 proteins, determining the underlying thermodynamics and providing insights into the role of individual sites in the context of the multivalent platform. Fitting of binding data reveals enthalpy-entropy correlation in both systems. Simulations of speciations for the entire phosphorylated protein domains reveal that the CFTR protein preferably binds to 14-3-3 by combinations including the strongest binding site pS768, but that other binding sites take over when this site is eliminated, leading to only a minor decrease in total affinity for 14-3-3. For LRRK2, two binding sites dominate the complex formation with 14-3-3, but the distantly located pS1444 site also plays a role in complex formation. Thermodynamic modeling of these multivalent PPIs allowed analyzing and predicting the effects of individual sites regarding their modulation via, for example, (de)phosphorylation or small-molecule targeting. The results specifically bring forward the potential of PPI stabilization, as an entry for drug discovery for multivalent PPIs.</p

14-3-3τ as a Modulator of Early α-Synuclein Multimerization and Amyloid Formation

The aggregation of α-synuclein (αS) plays a key role in Parkinson’s disease (PD) etiology. While the onset of PD is age-related, the cellular quality control system appears to regulate αS aggregation throughout most human life. Intriguingly, the protein 14-3-3τ has been demonstrated to delay αS aggregation and the onset of PD in various models. However, the molecular mechanisms behind this delay remain elusive. Our study confirms the delay in αS aggregation by 14-3-3τ, unveiling a concentration-dependent relation. Utilizing microscale thermophoresis (MST) and single-molecule burst analysis, we quantified the early αS multimers and concluded that these multimers exhibit properties that classify them as nanoscale condensates that form in a cooperative process, preceding the critical nucleus for fibril formation. Significantly, the αS multimer formation mechanism changes dramatically in the presence of scaffold protein 14-3-3τ. Our data modeling suggests that 14-3-3τ modulates the multimerization process, leading to the creation of mixed multimers or co-condensates, comprising both αS and 14-3-3τ. These mixed multimers form in a noncooperative process. They are smaller, more numerous, and distinctively not on the pathway to amyloid formation. Importantly, 14-3-3τ thus acts in the very early stage of αS multimerization, ensuring that αS does not aggregate but remains soluble and functional. This offers long-sought novel entries for the pharmacological modulation of PD.</p

Discovery of 14-3-3 PPI Stabilizers by Extension of an Amidine-Substituted Thiophene Fragment

Protein-protein interaction (PPI) modulation is a promising approach in drug discovery with the potential to expand the 'druggable' proteome and develop new therapeutic strategies. While there have been significant advancements in methodologies for developing PPI inhibitors, there is a relative scarcity of literature describing the 'bottom-up' development of PPI stabilizers (Molecular Glues). The hub protein 14-3-3 and its interactome provide an excellent platform for exploring conceptual approaches to PPI modulation, including evolution of chemical matter for Molecular Glues. In this study, we employed a fragment extension strategy to discover stabilizers for the complex of 14-3-3 protein and an Estrogen Receptor alpha-derived peptide (ERα). A focused library of analogues derived from an amidine-substituted thiophene fragment enhanced the affinity of the 14-3-3/ERα complex up to 6.2-fold. Structure-activity relationship (SAR) analysis underscored the importance of the newly added, aromatic side chain with a certain degree of rigidity. X-ray structural analysis revealed a unique intermolecular π-π stacking binding mode of the most active analogues, resulting in the simultaneous binding of two molecules to the PPI binding pocket. Notably, analogue 11 displayed selective stabilization of the 14-3-3/ERα complex.</p

Discovery of Small-Molecule Stabilizers of 14-3-3 Protein-Protein Interactions via Dynamic Combinatorial Chemistry

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) play an important role in numerous biological processes such as cell-cycle regulation and multiple diseases. The family of 14-3-3 proteins is an attractive target as they serve as binding partner to various proteins and are therefore capable of regulating their biological activities. Discovering small-molecule modulators, in particular stabilizers, of such complexes via traditional screening approaches is a challenging task. Herein, we pioneered the first application of dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC) to a PPI target, to find modulators of 14-3-3 proteins. Evaluation of the amplified hits from the DCC experiments for their binding affinity via surface plasmon resonance (SPR), revealed that the low-micromolar (KD 15-16 μM) acylhydrazones are 14-3-3/synaptopodin PPI stabilizers. Thus, DCC appears to be ideally suited for the discovery of not only modulators but even the more elusive stabilizers of notoriously challenging PPIs

Reversible Dual-Covalent Molecular Locking of the 14-3-3/ERRγ Protein-Protein Interaction as a Molecular Glue Drug Discovery Approach

Molecules that stabilize protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are invaluable as tool compounds for biophysics and (structural) biology, and as starting points for molecular glue drug discovery. However, identifying initial starting points for PPI stabilizing matter is highly challenging, and chemical optimization is labor-intensive. Inspired by chemical crosslinking and reversible covalent fragment-based drug discovery, we developed an approach that we term “molecular locks” to rapidly access molecular glue-like tool compounds. These dual-covalent small molecules reversibly react with a nucleophilic amino acid on each of the partner proteins to dynamically crosslink the protein complex. The PPI between the hub protein 14-3-3 and estrogen-related receptor γ (ERRγ) was used as a pharmacologically relevant case study. Based on a focused library of dual-reactive small molecules, a molecular glue tool compound was rapidly developed. Biochemical assays and X-ray crystallographic studies validated the ternary covalent complex formation and overall PPI stabilization via dynamic covalent crosslinking. The molecular lock approach is highly selective for the specific 14-3-3/ERRγ complex, over other 14-3-3 complexes. This selectivity is driven by the interplay of molecular reactivity and molecular recognition of the composite PPI binding interface. The long lifetime of the dual-covalent locks enabled the selective stabilization of the 14-3-3/ERRγ complex even in the presence of several other competing 14-3-3 clients with higher intrinsic binding affinities. The molecular lock approach enables systematic, selective, and potent stabilization of protein complexes to support molecular glue drug discovery.</p

Molecular basis and dual ligand regulation of tetrameric Estrogen Receptor α/14-3-3ζ protein complex

Therapeutic strategies targeting Nuclear Receptors (NRs) beyond their endogenous ligand binding pocket have gained significant scientific interest, driven by a need to circumvent problems associated with drug resistance and pharmacological profile. The hub protein 14-3-3 is an endogenous regulator of various NRs, providing a novel entry point for small molecule modulation of NR activity. Exemplified, 14-3-3 binding to the C-terminal F-domain of the Estrogen Receptor alpha (ERα), and small molecule stabilization of the ERα/14-3-3ζ protein complex by the natural product Fusicoccin A (FC-A), was demonstrated to downregulate ERα-mediated breast cancer proliferation. This presents a novel drug discovery approach to target ERα, however, structural and mechanistic insights into ERα/14-3-3 complex formation are lacking. Here, we provide an in-depth molecular understanding of the ERα/14-3-3ζ complex by isolating 14-3-3ζ in complex with an ERα protein construct comprising its Ligand Binding Domain (LBD) and phosphorylated F-domain. Bacterial co-expression and co-purification of the ERα/14-3-3ζ complex, followed by extensive biophysical and structural characterization, revealed a tetrameric complex between the ERα homodimer and the 14-3-3ζ homodimer. 14-3-3ζ binding to ERα, and ERα/14-3-3ζ complex stabilization by FC-A, appeared to be orthogonal to ERα endogenous agonist (E2) binding, E2-induced conformational changes, and cofactor recruitment. Similarly, the ERα antagonist 4-hydroxytamoxifen inhibited cofactor recruitment to the ERα LBD while ERα was bound to 14-3-3ζ. Furthermore, stabilization of the ERα/14-3-3ζ protein complex by FC-A was not influenced by the disease-associated and 4-hydroxytamoxifen resistant ERα-Y537S mutant. Together, these molecular and mechanistic insights provide direction for targeting ERα via the ERα/14-3-3 complex as an alternative drug discovery approach.</p

A simple method for developing lysine targeted covalent protein reagents

Peptide-based covalent probes can target shallow protein surfaces not typically addressable using small molecules, yet there is a need for versatile approaches to convert native peptide sequences into covalent binders that can target a broad range of residues. Here we report protein-based thio-methacrylate esters—electrophiles that can be installed easily on unprotected peptides and proteins via cysteine side chains, and react efficiently and selectively with cysteine and lysine side chains on the target. Methacrylate phosphopeptides derived from 14-3-3-binding proteins irreversibly label 14-3-3σ via either lysine or cysteine residues, depending on the position of the electrophile. Methacrylate peptides targeting a conserved lysine residue exhibit pan-isoform binding of 14-3-3 proteins both in lysates and in extracellular media. Finally, we apply this approach to develop protein-based covalent binders. A methacrylate-modified variant of the colicin E9 immunity protein irreversibly binds to the E9 DNAse, resulting in significantly higher thermal stability relative to the non-covalent complex. Our approach offers a simple and versatile route to convert peptides and proteins into potent covalent binders.</p

Glucocorticoid receptor Thr524 phosphorylation by MINK1 induces interactions with 14-3-3 protein regulators

The glucocorticoid receptor (GR) is a ligand-dependent transcription factor that plays a central role in inflammation. The GR activity is also modulated via protein-protein interactions, including binding of 14-3-3 proteins induced by GR phosphorylation. However, the specific phosphorylation sites on the GR that trigger these interactions and their functional consequences are less clear. Hence, we sought to examine this system in more detail. We used phosphorylated GR peptides, biophysical studies, and X-ray crystallography to identify key residues within the ligand-binding domain of the GR, T524 and S617, whose phosphorylation results in binding of the representative 14-3-3 protein 14-3-3ζ. A kinase screen identified misshapen-like kinase 1 (MINK1) as responsible for phosphorylating T524 and Rho-associated protein kinase 1 for phosphorylating S617; cell-based approaches confirmed the importance of both GR phosphosites and MINK1 but not Rhoassociated protein kinase 1 alone in inducing GR-14-3-3 binding. Together our results provide molecular-level insight into 14-3-3-mediated regulation of the GR and highlight both MINK1 and the GR-14-3-3 axis as potential targets for future therapeutic intervention

Structure-Based Optimization of Covalent, Small-Molecule Stabilizers of the 14-3-3σ/ERα Protein-Protein Interaction from Nonselective Fragments

The stabilization of protein-protein interactions (PPIs) has emerged as a promising strategy in chemical biology and drug discovery. The identification of suitable starting points for stabilizing native PPIs and their subsequent elaboration into selective and potent molecular glues lacks structure-guided optimization strategies. We have previously identified a disulfide fragment that stabilized the hub protein 14-3-3σ bound to several of its clients, including ERα and C-RAF. Here, we show the structure-based optimization of the nonselective fragment toward selective and highly potent small-molecule stabilizers of the 14-3-3σ/ERα complex. The more elaborated molecular glues, for example, show no stabilization of 14-3-3σ/C-RAF up to 150 μM compound. Orthogonal biophysical assays, including mass spectrometry and fluorescence anisotropy, were used to establish structure-activity relationships. The binding modes of 37 compounds were elucidated with X-ray crystallography, which further assisted the concomitant structure-guided optimization. By targeting specific amino acids in the 14-3-3σ/ERα interface and locking the conformation with a spirocycle, the optimized covalent stabilizer 181 achieved potency, cooperativity, and selectivity similar to the natural product Fusicoccin-A. This case study showcases the value of addressing the structure, kinetics, and cooperativity for molecular glue development. </p