Novel agmatine derivatives in Maerua edulis with bioactivity against Callosobruchus maculatus, a cosmopolitan storage insect pest

Food security in developing countries is threatened by crop pests and ectoparasites in livestock. Strategies for their management still rely on synthetic pesticides which are not always effective and the active ingredients persist in the environment with negative consequences for beneficial arthropods, farmers and consumers, hence necessitating research on sustainable alternatives. Botanical insecticides are increasingly relevant, typically having lower impacts on users, consumers and the environment. One example is the southern African shrub the Blue bush-berry, Maerua edulis. Recent work reported effective pest control using this plant species against cattle ticks, storage beetles and vegetable pests. However, little is known about the chemistry underlying activity and this is essential to optimize its use. Here, we identified two novel plant chemical tructures, the E and Z isomers of cinnamoyl-4-aminobutylguanidine along with the E and Z isomers of 4-hydroxycinnamoyl-4-aminobutylguanidine in the leaves of M. edulis. We isolated these compounds from the leaves and elucidated their chemical structures using various spectroscopic techniques including High Resolution Mass Spectrometry and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy. We also identified a further 11 closely related structures of which 6 are tentatively reported here for the first time. Stachydrine and 3-hydroxystachydrine were also identified in the leaf extract, and occurred at very high concentrations; up to 2% w/w of dry leaves. We tested these two compounds, along with the 4 main cinnamoylamides and the crude M. edulis leaf extract against the cowpea bruchid Callosobruchus maculatus at concentrations equivalent to those present in extracts used by smallholder farmers. Mortality of insects exposed to crude plant extracts after 72 h was significantly higher than the untreated control although still lower than for insects exposed to rotenone, the positive control. The two new compounds and stachydrine showed similar activity to the crude extracts suggesting that these compounds explained the activity of the extract. After 6 days, the mortality of insects exposed to crude extracts and isolated compounds was similar to that recorded with the positive control. The stachydrine fraction and the E and Z isomers of cinnamoyl-4-aminobutylguanidine also inhibited oviposition activity in fecund female beetles. Our data show that methanol extracts of M. edulis were toxic to C. maculatus and inhibited oviposition even at 0.1% w/v so these foliar chemicals may explain the activity of the plant material. We also synthesized the amides which facilitated structural elucidation, produced adequate quantities for testing and demonstrated the potential for commercial synthesis

Addition of a surfactant to water increases the acaricidal activity of extracts of some plant species used to control ticks by Zimbabwean smallholder farmers

BACKGROUND : Many studies have revealed that bioactive compounds for different indications are not extracted from plants with water, the only extractant practically available to rural communities. We compared the acaricidal activity of acetone extracts of 13 species used traditionally to protect cattle against ticks. We also investigated if the extraction of biologically active compounds against Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) decoloratus ticks could be enhanced by adding a liquid soap that is locally available to smallholder farmers. METHODS : A total of 13 plant species selected based on reported traditional use in Zimbabwe, were dried and finely ground before extraction with water, or water plus a surfactant, or acetone. The adapted Shaw Larval Immersion Test (SLIT) method was used to determine the activity of acetone and crude water extracts with or without liquid soap against the tick larvae. The activity of four fractions of crude acetone extracts (extracted using solvents of different polarity), of the most active plant species, Maerua edulis (tuber and leaf) was also compared to identify the most active fraction. RESULTS : Aqueous plant extracts were not toxic to ticks, but the addition of 1% liquid soap as a surfactant increased mortality of the R. (B) decoloratus larvae significantly. With the Maerua edulis tuber extract, the efficacy of the 1% liquid soap was comparable to that of the amitraz based commercial synthetic acaricide. The use of acetone as an extractant, also increased the mortality of the tick larvae in all the plant species. With M. edulis (tuber and leaf), Monadenium lugardae and Kleinia sp. acetone extracts, the activity was comparable to that of the positive control (a commercially available amitraz-based synthetic acaricide). The non-polar fractions of the acetone extract of leaf and tuber of M. edulis caused up to 100% mortality. This indicates that non-polar to intermediate polarity compounds are responsible for the acaricidal activity. CONCLUSION : Organic solvents such as acetone extracted active compounds but water did not. By adding commonly available dishwashing soap to water active compounds were extracted leading to a high acaricidal activity of the plant extracts. In some cases, it was as active as non-polar extracts and a synthetic commercial acaricide (positive control). This approach makes it possible for the smallholder farmers and traditional healers to extract biologically active compounds from plants by using water.The European Commission’s European Development Fund ACP S&T Programme grant FED/2013/329272 (OPTIONs) and the Technology Innovation Agency in South Africa.https://bmcvetres.biomedcentral.comam2020Production Animal Studie

Acaricidal characteristics of ethnoveterinary plants used for tick control in southern Africa

Ticks and tick borne diseases remain a huge threat to livestock productivity the world over. While several efforts have been made to control ticks, current control measures are still not adequate. Conventionally, tick control programmes are heavily reliant on the use of synthetic chemical acaricides while the impact of other less frequently used control methods has not been fully established. Unfortunately, heavy chemical use has led to a number challenges that include: unsustainable high costs of acaricides, development of tick resistance, environmental pollution, contamination of animal products with chemical residues and many other topical issues. Ethnoveterinary plants are however an alternative but possibly effective, environmentally benign and safe option that can complement and in some cases substitute synthetic chemical acaricides. In this study, plant species identified in Zimbabwe and found elsewhere in southern Africa were characterised for anti-tick properties with the aim of developing an ethnobotanical product for use. The initial step involved the identification of plants through an ethnobotanical survey carried out in 4 arid and semi-arid districts of Zimbabwe, namely Muzarabani, Chiredzi, Matobo and Kadoma. These areas were purposively selected on the basis of high cattle production and high likelihood of use of traditional practices in primary animal health care. More than 51 plant species were recorded and a ranking according to frequency of mention showed that Cissus quadrangularis, Aloe sp., Lippia javanica and Psydrax livida were the most popular plants mentioned by farmers. The most common method for preparation was crushing and soaking in water before spraying the animals. Despite the farmers acknowledging that they had access challenges to the normal government-provided dipping services and having knowledge on traditional practices of tick control, the actual use of these practices was low. It was concluded that farmers and other knowledgeable people do have plants they know that have anti-tick properties, thus providing a good basis for the development of ethno-based tick control products. In order to confirm farmer claims of efficacy of the plant extracts and to find ways of increasing that efficacy, three in vitro screening experiments were done using the modified Shaw Larval Immersion Test on Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) decoloratus tick larvae. Different extraction methods were used in the screening: crude water extracts, acetone extracts and solvent – solvent fractions of acetone extracts of Maerua edulis. Results showed that contrary to the high activity reported by farmers in the surveys, water extracts were not toxic to the tick larvae. Perhaps the high activity reported by farmers, if confirmed may be associated with the repellence of volatile emissions from the plants. The addition of a liquid soap as a surfactant however increased the efficacy of the M. edulis tuber aqueous extract to activity levels comparable with those of an amitraz-based commercial acaricide, which was the positive control. The use of the organic solvent acetone as an extractant markedly increased the efficacy of 13 of the plant species under study, particularly M. edulis, Monadenium lugardae and Kleinia species. The chloroform and hexane fractions from M. edulis exhibited very high activity, possibly indicating that less-polar compounds are responsible for the observed activity. Thus, the use of water as a sole extractant is limited in terms of extracting compounds active against ticks, but organic solvents and acetone in particular increase the efficacy of the extracts. In the case of M. edulis less polar extracts and fractions were most active against the ticks. Because Maerua edulis consistently showed good activity in all prior testing, it was further tested using low-cost optimisation strategies like the use of hot water, a surfactant and a different organic solvent (methanol). Hot water extraction and use of a surfactant increased efficacy of the crude extracts of the M. edulis leaves against ticks to satisfactory levels compared to cold water extracts. There was no significant difference between the positive control and methanol-extracted M. edulis. It is, however, the use of ordinary soap that may bring relief to rural farmers who are generally unable to have access to organic solvents. From the observation that the hexane and chloroform extracts of the M. edulis leaf and roots were very active against the ticks, cytotoxicity of the extracts on African Green monkey kidney (Vero) cells and bovine dermal cells was determined to shed some preliminary insights on safety aspects of the plant. Neither extract had high toxicity against these cell lines. The LC50 was greater than 20 _g/ml which is considered as a maximum threshold for indicating toxicity of plant extracts. After confirmation that non-polar fractions of M. edulis were active against ticks and that cytotoxicity results showed that the extracts are relatively non-toxic to animal cell lines, attempts to isolate and identify the active compounds in the chloroform fractions of M. edulis were made without much success. Using column chromatography, an impure compound was isolated in the chloroform fraction but the amount was too low for characterisation by NMR. When the compound was analysed using Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry, a number of chemicals in the isolate were avident but which did not have the pre requisite high similarities with the compound library to be considered. Because of the low quantities no further work was done to further purify and test the compounds against the ticks. For purposes of confirming laboratory activity under field conditions, M. edulis, C. quadrangularis and Aloe vera crude water extracts combined with a surfactant (liquid soap), were tested on Mashona cattle at Henderson Research Station (Zimbabwe) over 7 weeks during the period of peak tick infestation. Only M. edulis tuber extracts with a surfactant were as effective as the amitraz-based positive control. There was no significant difference in activity between the other plant extracts and the negative control. It can be concluded that there is scope to use M. edulis tubers extracted with locally available surfactant as a tick control product. This whole study therefore shows that ticks can be controlled using locally available plant materials provided they are prepared and applied properly. While the overall aim of the study of producing a working plant based tick control product was not met, there is sufficient data from the study to justify developing crude formulations from M. edulis that can be used to control ticks.Thesis (PhD)--University of Pretoria, 2019.Paraclinical SciencesPhDUnrestricte

Tick control measures from nature

Scientists from the Universities of Zimbabwe and Greenwich delved into the possibility of using fever tea (Lippia javanica) for cattle tick control in Zimbabwe. Here are their findings

Acute Oral Mammalian Toxicity and Effect of Solvents on Efficacy of Maerua edulis (Gilg. & Ben.) De Wolf against Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) decoloratus Koch, 1844 (Acarina: Ixodidae), Tick Larvae

Efficacy and toxicity of aqueous and organic solvents extracts of Maerua edulis against ticks and mice, respectively, were determined. Ground leaves were extracted separately using cold water, cold water plus surfactant (1% v/v liquid soap), hot water plus surfactant, hexane, or methanol to make 25% w/v stock solutions from which serial dilutions of 5, 10, 20, and 25% were made. For each concentration, 20 Rhipicephalus decoloratus tick larvae were put in filter papers impregnated with extracts and incubated for 48 h at 27°C and 85–90% RH for mortality observation after 24 h and 48 h. In the toxicity experiment, hot water plus surfactant treatments of 5, 10, 20, and 25% (w/v) M. edulis were administered in suspension per os to sexually mature Balb/C mice and observed for clinical signs and mortality for 72 h. Larvae mortality was highest (>98%) in methanol-extracted M. edulis treatments (20 and 25%), which was not different from the amitraz-based control (Tickbuster®). Mortality was also higher in the hot water than in cold water plus surfactant treatments (P<0.05). No postadministration adverse health effects were observed in the mice. These results suggest that M. edulis is an effective tick remedy best extracted using methanol or hot water plus surfactant

An aqueous extract of Maerua edulis (Gilg & Ben) DeWolf tuber is as effective as a commercial synthetic acaricide in controlling ticks on cattle in vivo

Farmers in Zimbabwe claim that plant extracts of Cissus quadrangularis, Aloe vera and Maerua edulis are effective in controlling cattle ticks. On-station experiments were conducted at Henderson Research Station to determine the in-vivo efficacy of crude aqueous extracts of Cissus quadrangularis (succulent stems), Aloe vera (succulent leaves) and Maerua edulis (leaves and tuber) at concentrations of 15%, 15% and 10% w/v respectively, against cattle ticks. An amitraz-based acaricide and water were used as positive and negative controls, respectively. Thirty Mashona steers were allocated to the six treatments in a completely randomised design experiment where each animal was an experimental unit replicated five times. The animals were each sprayed weekly with 5 L of the test or control solutions using a knapsack sprayer after which full body tick counts were recorded every other day for seven weeks. The experiments were conducted between January and February when conditions are optimal for tick development. The M. edulis tuber extract was as effective as the amitraz-based commercial acaricide. The other three plants extracts were, however, as ineffective as the negative control (water). Maerua edulis tuber plus soapy water-oil extract is effective against cattle ticks and have potential to be developed into an acaricidal product and thus benefit mostly resource-challenged smallholder farmers who cannot afford commercial synthetic acaricides. In vivo studies using acaricidal plants are rare.The European Commission’s European Development Fund ACP S&T Programme grant FED/2013/329272 (OPTIONs).http://www.elsevier.com/locate/indcrop2018-12-30hj2018Paraclinical Science

Cattle tick control in Africa: potential of ethnoveterinary plants.

Cattle are a livelihood asset to smallholder farmers in Africa yet remain threatened by the effects of ticks and tick-borne diseases during production because they cause morbidity and premature death. The use of indigenous plants in tick control is a worldwide practice spanning thousands of years. Changes in the agricultural and socio–cultural landscape over time have, however, led to neglect of indigenous pesticidal plants in favour of synthetic products. The benefits of synthetic acaricides are well-recognized, but emerging observation indicates that they cannot solve all livestock health problems across production systems, farmer circumstances and agro-ecologies. Concerns associated with commercial acaricides have revived research interest in alternative or complementary remedies. Past research has focused on documenting ethnoveterinary practices, scientific validation of the practices and optimization of these practices. Here, we review the challenges of synthetic acaricides and progress made in ethnoveterinary plant research and development in Africa. The review highlights challenges of access, affordability and availability of commercial acaricides to resource-poor communities; synthetic acaricide resistance development; disposal of obsolete acaricides and environmental pollution; reduced water supply and implications on conventional use of acaricide-treated dipping facilities; and plant bioprospecting and downstream development of products in Africa. This information contributes towards shaping the ethnoveterinary plant research agenda and policy, and investment interventions in Africa