Biotechnology and the Politics of Truth : From the Green Revolution to an Evergreen Revolution

This paper investigates why and how issues around the diffusion of GM technologies and products to developing countries have become so central to a debate which has shifted away from technical issues of cost-benefit optimisation in a context of uniform mass production and consumption in the North, to the moral case for GM crops to feed the hungry and aid ‘development’ in the South. Using comparison between agricultural biotechnology and the ‘Green Revolution’ as a cross cutting theme, the contributions of this paper are threefold. Firstly, by analysing biotechnology as a set of overlapping frames within a discursive formation, four frames are identified which summarise key challenges presented by biotechnology era. Secondly, the use of Foucault's concept of bio-power to synthesise key themes from the frame analysis illuminates the ‘revolutionary’ nature of the biotech revolution. Thirdly, the potential of actor-network theory to provide a tools for the empirical study of processes of (re)negotiation of nature/society relations in the context of agricultural biotechnology controversies is explored

Pathways and Policies to (Bio) Pharmaceutical Innovation Systems in Developing Countries

Developing countries have traditionally been regarded as users of technology developed abroad. During the 1980s and 1990s this approach to meeting domestic healthcare needs faced new barriers to consumption and use that resulted from the high cost of drugs and the emergence of new international trade, investment and intellectual property rules. Attention was thus drawn to the possibility of building (bio)pharmaceutical innovation systems at home. By examining the experiences of india, cuba, iran, taiwan, egypt and nigeria, this paper identifies a multiplicity of pathways for doing so. Because innovation is embedded in both a policy and institutional context, country-specific triggers and drivers of innovation processes have been important. None the less, some commonalities do appear. Among the more notable triggers were the existence of healthcare crises and earlier incentives that had focused the attention of critical actors on domestic healthcare problems and stimulated a conscious effort by firms to master technology. The interactivity among four types of policies—those strengthening the knowledge base, stimulating capacity building, opening space for local firms and creating incentives for innovation were important in shaping the way these triggers were perceived and in driving the subsequent innovation process