55 research outputs found
"The End of Immortality!" Eternal Life and the Makropulos Debate
Responding to a well-known essay by Bernard Williams, philosophers (and a few theologians) have engaged in what I call “the Makropulos debate,” a debate over whether immortality—“living forever”—would be desirable for beings like us. Lacking a firm conceptual grounding in the religious contexts from which terms such as “immortality” and “eternal life” gain much of their sense, the debate has consisted chiefly in a battle of speculative fantasies. Having presented my four main reasons for this assessment, I examine an alternative and neglected conception, the idea of eternal life as a present possession, derived in large part from Johannine Christianity. Without claiming to argue for the truth of this conception, I present its investigation as exemplifying a conceptually fruitful direction of inquiry into immortality or eternal life, one which takes seriously the religious and ethical surroundings of these concepts
‘Foreigners’, ‘ethnic minorities’, and ‘non-Western allochtoons’: an analysis of the development of ‘ethnicity’ in health policy in the Netherlands from 1970 to 2015
'Ashkenazi mutations' and the BRCA genes: genetics, disease and Jewish identity
This thesis explores the increased risk of genetic breast cancer for
Ashkenazi Jews who are at significantly increased risk of carrying three
specific mutations in the high risk breast cancer genes, BRCA1 and
BRCA2. The Ashkenazi Jewish population has the highest known risk of
genetic breast cancer and are the most well researched in relation to genetic
disease. They are believed to have a particularly supportive and unique
relationship with genetics, despite also having a history of discrimination
that includes claims of biological inferiority.
The use of racial or ethnic groups in genetic research is highly contentious
and the implications for those populations being studied are usually
assumed to be negative. There is also significant discussion about the
potential of new genetic knowledge to transform individual and collective
identity and alter how individuals conceive of themselves and the groups to
which they belong.
This thesis contributes to both of these areas of debate by exploring the
implications for individuals of knowing that they are at increased risk of
genetic breast cancer because they are of Ashkenazi Jewish origin. It
specifically addresses whether being at increased risk has an impact on how
Ashkenazi Jewish women feel about their own Jewish identity, whether they
have concerns about current genetic research related to them, and if they are
particularly supportive as if often claimed.
Evidence is provided principally from qualitative interview material with
Ashkenazi women at increased risk of genetic breast cancer as well as non
high risk individuals. The qualitative data is supplemented by a quantitative
survey.
Ethnic identity can be an important mediating factor for the ways in which
genetic knowledge is interpreted and genetic medicine can become
intertwined with culturally specific issues. Ashkenazi Jews conceive of
themselves, their history and their future in ways that are compatible with
new genetic knowledge. While it is important not to assume there are necessarily damaging or transformative consequences for those populations
that are the subjects of genetic research, there were implications for
Ashkenazi women and their disease was interwoven with their identity in
complex ways
- …