СРАВНИТЕЛЬНАЯ ХАРАКТЕРИСТИКА МУЛЬТИМОРБИДНОСТИ, МЕДИКАМЕНТОЗНОГО ЛЕЧЕНИЯ И ИСХОДОВ У БОЛЬНЫХ С СОЧЕТАНИЕМ ПЕРЕНЕСЕННОГО ОСТРОГО НАРУШЕНИЯ МОЗГОВОГО КРОВООБРАЩЕНИЯ И ФИБРИЛЛЯЦИИ ПРЕДСЕРДИЙ ПРИ НАЛИЧИИ ИЛИ ОТСУТСТВИИ АНАМНЕЗА ИНФАРКТА МИОКАРДА (ДАННЫЕ РЕГИСТРОВ РЕГИОН)

AIM. Within the framework of outpatient and hospital registers of REGION (REGIster of patients who have undergone acute cerebrovascular accident) to carry out a comparative assessment of demographic and clinical-anamnestical characteristics, medical treatment and outcomes in clinical practice in patients with a combination of undergone acute cerebrovascular accident (ACVA) and atrial fibrillation (AF) in the presence or absence of myocardial infarction (MI) in the medical history.MATERIAL AND METHODS. Outpatient registers REGION (Ryazan) and hospital register REGION (Moscow) included 1886 patients who have undergone ACVA (age 70.6 ± 12.5 years, 41.9% of men), of them 516 (27.4%) people with AF. Comparison groups included 152 (8.1%) patients with a combination of ACVA, AF and MI in medical history (ACVA + AF + MI group) and 364 (19.3%) patients with ACVA, AF without MI (ACVA + AF without MI group). The presence of cardiovascular diseases (CVD), concomitant diseases, drug therapy and outcomes were analyzed.RESULTS. In the group of ACVA + AF + MI patients, compared to the ACVA + AF without MI group, the share of patients with AH (100% and 97.2%), IHD (100% and 87.1%), CHD (68.4% and 57.1%), repeated ACVA (36.9% and 23.9%), diabetes mellitus in women (39.5% and 20.4%) was statistically significantly higher. In the comparison groups, the share of smokers (13.3% and 15.5%), patients with burdened heredity of early development of CVDs (2.1% and 1.1%) and hypercholesterolemia (41.1% and 50.0%) did not differ significantly, however, in the group of ACVA + AF + MI, in comparison with the group of ACVA + AF without MI, there was a higher risk on the CHA2DS2-VASc scale (5.26 ± 1.32 and 4.09 ± 1.44; p < 0.001) and HAS-BLED scale (1.91 ± 0.76 and 1.62 ± 0.79; p < 0.01). Patients with AF of REGION register, both with and without MI, had insufficient frequency of proper medical prescriptions for CVDs (46.6% and 38.9% on average), especially prescription of anticoagulants (19.1% and 21.4%), statins in case of IHD (33.6% and 27.4%) and beta-adrenoblockers in case of CHD (39.4% and 35.6%).  During the four-year period of observation, in comparison with post-stroke patients without a history of MI, the mortality rate for all causes was 1.5 times higher (56.6% and 37.6%, p = 0.0001), the incidence of non-fatal MI was higher (2.0% and 0.3%,p = 0.04). CONCLUSION. Patients with a combination of ACVA, AF and MI history are a very high risk group for adverse outcomes observed on an outpatient stage. For these patients it is very important to improve the quality of drug therapy and the effectiveness of secondary prophylaxis.ЦЕЛЬ. В рамках амбулаторных и госпитального регистров РЕГИОН (РЕГИстр больных, перенесших Острое Нарушение мозгового кровообращения) провести сравнительную оценку демографических и клинико-анамнестических характеристик, медикаментозного лечения и исходов в клинической практике у больных с сочетанием перенесенного острого нарушения мозгового кровообращения (ОНМК) и фибрилляции предсердий (ФП) при наличии или отсутствии инфаркта миокарда (ИМ) в анамнезе.МАТЕРИАЛ И МЕТОДЫ. В амбулаторные регистры РЕГИОН (Рязань) и в госпитальный регистр РЕГИОН (Москва) включено 1886 пациентов, перенесших ОНМК (возраст 70,6 ± 12,5 лет, 41,9% мужчин), из них с ФП 516 (27,4%) человек. Группы сравнения составили 152 (8,1%) пациента с сочетанием перенесенного ОНМК, ФП и ИМ в анамнезе (группа ОНМК + ФП + ИМ) и 364 (19,3%) больных с ОНМК, ФП без анамнеза ИМ (группа ОНМК + ФП без ИМ). Проанализированы наличие сердечно-сосудистых заболеваний (ССЗ), сопутствующих заболеваний, медикаментозная терапия и исходы.РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ. В группе пациентов ОНМК + ФП + ИМ, по сравнению с пациентами группы ОНМК + ФП без ИМ, была статистически значимо выше доля лиц с АГ (100% и 97,2%), ИБС (100% и 87,1%), ХСН (68,4% и 57,1%), повторного ОНМК (36,9% и 23,9%), сахарного диабета у женщин (39,5% и 20,4%). В группах сравнения доля курящих (13,3% и 15,5%), пациентов с отягощенной наследственностью раннего развития ССЗ (2,1% и 1,1%) и гиперхолестеринемией (41,1% и 50,0%) существенно не различалась, однако в группе ОНМК + ФП + ИМ, по сравнению с группой ОНМК + ФП без ИМ, был выше риск по шкале СHA 2DS2–VASc (5,26 ± 1,32 и 4,09 ± 1,44; p < 0,001) и шкале HAS-BLED (1,91 ± 0,76 и 1,62 ± 0,79; p < 0,01). У больных с ФП регистра РЕГИОН, как с перенесенным ИМ, так и без ИМ, частота должных медикаментозных назначений по поводу ССЗ была недостаточной (в среднем 46,6% и 38,9%), особенно назначения антикоагулянтов (19,1% и 21,4%), статинов при ИБС (33,6% и 27,4%) и бета-адреноблокаторов при ХСН (39,4% и 35,6%). За четырехлетний период наблюдения у больных группы ОНМК + ФП + ИМ, по сравнению с постинсультными пациентами без анамнеза ИМ, смертность от всех причин была в 1,5 раза выше (56,6% и 37,6%, p = 0,0001), чаще развивался нефатальный ИМ (2,0% и 0,3%, р = 0,04).ЗАКЛЮЧЕНИЕ. Больные с сочетанием перенесенных ОНМК, ФП и анамнеза ИМ являются группой очень высокого риска неблагоприятного исхода при наблюдении на амбулаторном этапе. Для данных пациентов крайне важным является повышение качества медикаментозной терапии и эффективности вторичной профилактики

PRACTICE OF PRESCRIBING BETA-BLOCKERS AND ITS COMPLIANCE WITH CLINICAL GUIDELINES ACCORDING TO TWO REGISTERS OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES

Aim. To assess real clinical practice of prescribing beta-blockers (BB) and its compliance with updated guidelines, using data from outpatient registers that are carried out in medical institutions of different levels. Material and methods. We analyzed data from two outpatient registries - RECVASA and PROFILE. RECVASA register included patients aged ≥18 years with arterial hypertension (HT), ischemic heart disease (IHD), chronic heart failure (CHF) and atrial fibrillation (AF) that consulted in 3 outpatient clinics of Ryazan city in 2012-2013 (n=3690). PROFILE register included patients aged ≥18 years with HT, IHD, CHF, AF that consulted in specialized cardiac unit of the State Research Center for Preventive Medicine in 2011-2015 (n=1531). Results. There were differences in the basic characteristics of the registers: in the RECVASA register average age of patients was higher, HT, IHD and CHF were more frequent; PROFILE register included more patients with the history of myocardial infarction. In the RECVASA register 41.5% (n=1533) of patients received BB, and in the PROFILE register – 47.7% (n=731). The most frequently prescribed BB was bisoprolol in all cardiovascular diseases. Conclusion. In a specialized medical institution BB used more often under the conditions where they are necessary. The choice of a specific BB inside the pharmacological group, even in a specialized medical institution does not always correspond to clinical guidelines and evidence-based medicine

THE STUDY "REGISTER OF PATIENTS AFTER ACUTE STROKE (REGION)". PART 2. OUTPATIENT PROSPECTIVE REGISTER OF PATIENTS AFTER ACUTE STROKE (ACCORDING TO THE RESULTS OF THE PILOT PHASE OF THE STUDY)

Aim. To study particularities of course and outcomes of acute cerebrovascular accident (ACVA), quality of examination and medical treatment within a framework of an outpatient register.Material and methods. Two outpatient registries were organized on the base of one of Ryazan outpatient clinics within a framework of the pilot phase of the REGION study: the register of patients who had experienced ACVA of any remoteness (ACVA-AR register, n=200) and the register of patients who had visited the outpatient clinic for the first time after cerebral stroke (ACVA-FV register, n=115). Particularities of ACVA development, concomitant cardiovascular diseases (CVD) and noncardiac diseases were analyzed. We estimated accordance of methods of examination and prescribed medical treatment with clinical guidelines. Long-term outcomes were also evaluated in the course of prospective follow-up.Results. Patients of both  registers had  concomitant CVD (on an average 3 diagnosis) and  noncardiac comorbidity (on an average 1 diagnosis). Majority of patients at the outpatient phase  received inadequate treatment for cardiovascular risk decrease, especially before  reference ACVA. The ACVA-FV register patients as compared to the ACVA-AR ones (who had experienced ACVA on an average 4.8 years earlier) were more often (p<0.05) examined by instrumental and laboratory methods of diagnostics during the post-stroke follow-up in outpatient settings. ACVA-FV register patients as compared to the ACVA-AR ones were also more often (p˂0.05) prescribed prognosis-modifying therapy (statins – 46.9% vs 11%, acetylsalicylic acid – 54.8% vs 28%, ACE inhibitors – 46.1% vs 29%, and anticoagulants in atrial fibrillation – 17.6% vs 2.3%, respectively). Mortality rates in the ACVA-AR and ACVA-FV registers for 2 years were 15.5% and 32.2%, respectively (p=0.005), incidence rates of myocardial infarction – 2.5% and 0%, respectively (p=0.09), recurrent ACVA – 14.5% and 11.3%, respectively, (p=0.42).Conclusion. Examination and medical treatment of the patients in the outpatient clinic were suboptimal especially before  ACVA development. However examination and treatment quality had improved significantly (although insufficiently) during 5-year time span between ACVA development in the ACVA-AR and ACVA-FV registers. High mortality rate (22.7%) in the first 3 months of outpatient follow-up after ACVA is an unsolved challenge

Cardiovascular Diseases and Drug Treatment in Patients with the History of Cerebral Stroke: Data of the Outpatient Registry REGION

Aim. To evaluate the structure of combined cardiovascular diseases, drug treatment and observation of patients with a history of stroke in the framework of prospective outpatient registries. Material and methods. The study was conducted based on 3 outpatient clinics of Ryazan city. Patients with a history of acute cerebrovascular accident (ACVA) of any remoteness (AR) were included into ACVA-AR outpatient registry (n=511). Patients who had visited the outpatient clinics for the first time (FT) after cerebral stroke (n=475) were included into the ACVA-FT outpatient registry. The structure of the cardiovascular diseases (CVD), compliance with the clinical recommendations of the prescribed and received drug therapy were evaluated. The proportion of patients with dispensary observation for CVD, using preferential drug provision was determined. Results. A combination of 2 or more CVDs was found in 84.4% and 82.5% of cases, and severe cardiovascular multimorbidity (3-4 CVDs) – in 69% and 64% of cases, respectively, in ACVA-AR and ACVA-FT registers. Compliance with the clinical guidelines prescribed and received drug therapy was insufficient at the outpatient stage. Necessary prescription of drugs with a proven beneficial effect on the prognosis were observed significantly more frequent in the ACVA-FT registry, compared to the ACVA-AR registry at the enrolling stage of the study (p<0.05): statins for stroke – 50.1% vs 25.2%; statins for coronary heart disease (CHD) – 47.2% vs 27.9%; antiplatelet agents for CHD without atrial fibrillation – 65.6% vs 54.3%; anticoagulants for atrial fibrillation – 17.7% vs 9.3%; beta-blockers for heart failure 43.5% vs 33.1%, respectively. After 2-3 years of the follow-up frequency of prognostically significant prescriptions in patients of the compared registries were not significantly different, except prescriptions for statin therapy (47.6% vs 21.3%, respectively). The prognostically significant prescriptions during the enrolling stage in ACVA-AR and ACVA-FT registries occurred in 44.4% and 54% of the total number of proper prescriptions, and in the long-term follow-up period – in 55% and 57%, respectively; and the dispensary observation coverage was only 35.0% and 31.8%, respectively. According to patient contact only 21-24% of patients used the system of preferential drug provision at the stage of inclusion into the registers, and after 2-3 years of follow-up – 1.5-2 times less (12-14%). Conclusion The results of the study REGION found the presence of cardiovascular multimorbidity in 83% of patients with a history of stroke, insufficient quality of prescribed drug therapy in the out-patient clinic, especially in the ACVA-AR registry. The quality of medical treatment of patients improved within 2-3-year follow-up after the reference visit to out-patient clinic, but not sufficiently. Increase in dispensary observation coverage and optimization of the system of preferential drug provision are also important reserves for improving the quality of treatment of patients with a history of stroke, as well as prevention of cardiovascular complications

DRUG TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH THE HISTORY OF ACUTE STROKE: DATA OF THE PILOT PHASE OF THE OUTPATIENT REGISTRY «REGION»

Aim. To study the pharmacological treatment of patients with acute stroke (AS) within the prospective outpatient registries.Material and methods. In the pilot phase of the study, conducting on the base of one of the out-patient clinic in Ryazan city, 200 and 115 patients were included into the outpatient registry of patients with AS history of any remoteness (AS-AR registry), and outpatient registry of the first apply (AS-FA registry) to the out-patient clinic after stroke, respectively. The correspondence of the prescribed and actually taken drug therapy to clinical recommendations, its continuity, and the adherence of patients to treatment were assessed during the prospective observation.Results. Most patients did not receive adequate therapy to reduce the risk of AS and other cardiovascular complications in the outpatient stage, especially in the period prior to the reference AS. Drugs with a proven beneficial effect on the prognosis in the post-stroke period were prescribed significantly (p and after 2 years – in the AS-FA registry, the frequency of the therapy was not significantly different from the frequency of prescribing at the stage of inclusion in the registers, with the exception of statins (they were taken 1.7 and 1.5 times less frequently). Prognostically significant prescriptions of the inclusion phase were performed in the long-term follow-up period in 49% and 70% of patients (on average 58%), respectively; however, the frequency of first-time therapy was 44% and 19% of the total number of prescriptions in this period, respectively. Adherence to treatment, according to the Morisky-Green questionnaire, was revealed in 17.7 and 51.7% of patients, respectivelyConclusion. The results of the pilot phase of the REGION study (AS-AR and AS-FA outpatient registries) showed that the quality of the prescribed drug therapy of patients in out-patient clinic is inadequate. A comparison of the data of AS-AR and AS-FA registries allows to make a preliminary conclusion that over the 5-year period separating the remoteness of AS development in these registries, the quality of patient treatment has significantly improved, although not enough. The proportion of previously performed prognostically significant prescriptions averaged only about 60% at the stage of the further prospective follow-up. In general, during the observation period, taking into account newly made prescriptions, the frequency of adequate drug therapy during the observation period decreased only for statins. Most patients were not sufficiently committed to pharmacological treatment according to the Morisky-Green questionnaire

Correlation of excess salt intake identified by the survey with urine sodium level and blood pressure: data of ESSE-RF study

Aim. To study the association of blood pressure (BP) and hypertension (HTN) with salt intake estimated by the survey and the urinary Na+ concentration among men and women 25-64 years old, examined within the ESSE-RF and ESSE-RF-2 studies.Material and methods. Representative samples of the Russian population aged 25-64 years were examined. At the first phase in 2012-2014, 21,888 people (men — 38,2%) were included, and at the second phase in 2017 — 6,714 people (men — 44,7%). The response rate was 80%. We used standard questionnaire. Adding more salt and the consumption of salted foods (sausages, deli meats, and pickled foods) in the criteria “daily or almost daily” was considered excess salt intake (ESI). BP measurement was carried out in a sitting position on the right hand. BP was measured twice with an interval of about 2-3 minutes. HTN was diagnosed at a systolic BP (SBP) ≥140 mm Hg and/or diastolic BP ≥90 mm Hg, or in case of antihypertensive therapy. In ESSE-RF-2, an analysis of the morning urine was additionally performed. Na+ was determined using the EX-Ds ion-selective electrolyte analyzer. All participants were stratified by the quintiles of urine sodium level. Data analysis was performed using the software package R 3.6.1. The models of linear and logistic regression were used. The differences were considered at p<0,05.Results. The average level of SBP significantly increases with an increase in Na+ in urine: 1,04 (0,60-1,48) mm Hg for the quintile of sodium distribution (p<0,001), the odds of HTN increases by 1,11 (1,05-1,17) times for the quintile (p<0,001). Questionnaire components of ESI are also significantly related to urinary Na+ levels. The consumption of sausages and deli meats has the greatest effect, causing an increase in the average Na+ level by 11,59 (7,06-16,12) mmol/l (p<0,001). The applied point scale is significantly related to urine sodium level and predicts HTN no worse than Na+ in the urine (p=0,15 for the difference hypothesis). One point on the scale increases the Na+ level by an average of 7,51 (5,01-10,02) mmol/l, SBP by an average of 0,74 (0,41-1,07) mm Hg and the odds of HTN by 1,1 (1,06-1,15) times (p<0,001 for all).Conclusion. In the pattern of ESI components, processed meat and sausage products take first place in terms of association strength with urine sodium. The questionnaire used to assess the proportion of people with ESI can be recommended for assessing this risk factor during screening. ESI detected by the questionnaire is associated with elevated BP and urinary Na+ values