Bioaccessibility of metals and human health risk assessment in community urban gardens

Pseudo-total (i.e. aqua regia extractable) and gastric-bioaccessible (i.e. glycine + HCl extractable) concentrations of Ca, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn were determined in a total of 48 samples collected from six community urban gardens of different characteristics in the city of Madrid (Spain). Calcium carbonate appears to be the soil property that determines the bioaccessibility of a majority of those elements, and the lack of influence of organic matter, pH and texture can be explained by their low levels in the samples (organic matter) or their narrow range of variation (pH and texture). A conservative risk assessment with bioaccessible concentrations in two scenarios, i.e. adult urban farmers and children playing in urban gardens, revealed acceptable levels of risk, but with large differences between urban gardens depending on their history of land use and their proximity to busy areas in the city center. Only in a worst-case scenario in which children who use urban gardens as recreational areas also eat the produce grown in them would the risk exceed the limits of acceptabilit

The relationship between soil geochemistry and the bioaccessibility of trace elements in playground soil

A total of 32 samples of surficial soil were collected from 16 playground areas in Madrid (Spain), in order to investigate the importance of the geochemistry of the soil on subsequent bioaccessibility of trace elements. The in vitro bioaccessibility of As, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn was evaluated by means of two extraction processes that simulate the gastric environment and one that reproduces a gastric + intestinal digestion sequence. The results of the in vitro bioaccessibility were compared against aqua regia extractions (“total” concentration), and it was found that total concentrations of As, Cu, Pb and Zn were double those of bioaccessible values, whilst that of Cr was ten times higher. Whereas the results of the gastric + intestinal extraction were affected by a high uncertainty, both gastric methods offered very similar and consistent results, with bioaccessibilities following the order: As = Cu = Pb = Zn > Co > Ni > Cr, and ranging from 63 to 7 %. Selected soil properties including pH, organic matter, Fe and CaCO3 content were determined to assess their influence on trace element bioaccessibility, and it was found that Cu, Pb and Zn were predominantly bound to organic matter and, to a lesser extent, Fe oxides. The former fraction was readily accessible in the gastric solution, whereas Fe oxides seemed to recapture negatively charged chloride complexes of these elements in the gastric solution, lowering their bioaccessibility. The homogeneous pH of the playground soils included in the study does not influence trace element bioaccessibility to any significant extent except for Cr, where the very low gastric accessibility seems to be related to the strongly pH-dependent formation of complexes with organic matter. The results for As, which have been previously described and discussed in detail in Mingot et al. (Chemosphere 84: 1386–1391, 2011), indicate a high gastric bioaccessibility for this element as a consequence of its strong association with calcium carbonate and the ease with which these bonds are broken in the gastric solution. The calculation of risk assessments are therefore dependant on the methodology used and the specific environment they address. This has impacts on management strategies formulated to ensure that the most vulnerable of society, children, can live and play without adverse consequences to their health

Arsenic, antimony and selenium in urban soils: potential risks for human health in urban gardening

The benefits of urban agriculture are many and well documented, ranging from health improvement to community betterment, more sustainable urban development and environment protection. On the negative side, urban soils are commonly enriched in toxic trace elements that have accumulated over time through the deposition of atmospheric particles (generated by automotive traffic, heating systems, historical industrial activities and resuspended street dust), and the uncontrolled disposal of domestic, commercial and industrial wastes. This in turn has given rise to concerns about the level of exposure of urban farmers to these elements and the potential health hazards associated with this exposure. Research efforts in this field have started relatively recently and have almost systematically omitted the influence of Sb and Se, and to a lesser extent of As, although all three have proven toxic effects

Bioaccessibility of heavy metals and risk assessment in urban gardens of Madrid

Human health problems and solutions. Urban gardening has spread worldwide in recent years as it enhances food security and selfsupply and promotes community integration. However urban soils are significantly enriched in trace elements relative to background levels. Exposure to the soil in urban gardens may therefore result in adverse health effects depending on the degree of contact during gardening, infant recreational activities and ingestion of vegetables grown in them. In order to evaluate this potential risk, 36 composite samples were collected from the top 20 cm of the soil of 6 urban gardens in Madrid. The aqua regia (pseudototal) and glycine-extractable (bioaccessible) concentrations of Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn were determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Additionally, pH, texture, Fe, Ca, and Mn concentrations, and organic matter and calcium carbonate contents were determined in all urban gardens and their influence on trace element bioaccessibility was analyzed

Bioaccesibilidad de elementos traza en suelos de parques infantiles. Aplicación al análisis de riesgo

En este trabajo doctoral se evaluó la bioaccesibilidad in vitro para As, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb y Zn (en la fracción menor de 100μm) por tres procedimientos distintos en 32 muestras de suelo superficial, recogidas en 16 parques infantiles de la ciudad de Madrid.. Dos de los métodos de extracción (SBET y extracción con HCl a pH=1.5) reproducen únicamente la fase gástrica, mientras que otro (RIVM) tiene en cuenta un proceso completo de digestión (gástrico+intestinal). La bioaccesibilidad (%) se definió frente a las concentraciones pseudototales de los elementos traza estudiados (agua regia), utilizando un modelo de regresión lineal pasando por el origen. Los dos métodos gástricos ofrecieron resultados similares y consistentes con datos de otros estudios, siendo el orden de bioaccesibilidad As ≈ Cu ≈ Pb ≈ Zn > Co > Ni > Cr, con rangos entre el 63 y el 7%. Para el procedimiento RIVM (gástrico + intestinal) se obtuvieron valores de un orden similar a los obtenidos en fase gástrica para los elementos As, Cu, Pb y Zn (muy similares para el Zn, algo superiores para Cu y Pb, y algo inferiores para As). Por el contrario, la bioaccesibilidad de Co y Cu es, en este caso, muy superior a la resultante de los ensayos en fase gástrica. El orden de bioaccesibilidad es Co ≈ Cu ≈ Pb > As ≈ Cr ≈ Zn, con rangos entre el 42 y el 69%. Los resultados de los tres procedimientos evaluados correlacionan muy intensamente para los elementos traza As, Cu, Pb y Zn, existiendo intensas correlaciones entre casi todos los elementos estudiados para las dos fases gástricas, no siendo así en el ensayo de digestión completa. Se estudiaron algunas propiedades físico-químicas de los suelos muestreados, así como su composición en algunos elementos mayoritarios con el objeto de evaluar su influencia sobre la bioaccesibilidad. Se observa una dependencia de la bioaccesibilidad (%) de distintos elementos respecto a algunas propiedades de los suelos estudiados, tales como: contenido en Fe, Ca (carbonatos) y P, materia orgánica y pH. El contenido en Fe resulta ser muy relevante en cuanto a la bioaccesibilidad obtenida. En todos los casos correlaciona negativamente con el porcentaje de bioaccesibilidad siendo más significativo este fenómeno en el caso de las extracciones en fase gástrica. Se sugiere que dada la baja solubilización de los óxidos de hierro en los medios extractantes empleados hay una fuerte adsorción de complejos aniónicos (metal-anión cloruro) sobre la superficie de estos óxidos de Fe, con la consiguientes disminución de la bioaccesibilidad. En cuanto al contenido en calcio (carbonatos) este dato parece muy relevante si nos referimos a la bioaccesibilidad del As. Efectivamente el As aparece ligado al Ca del suelo y su solubilización en medios ácidos implicaría un aumento de la bioaccesibilidad del As, mientras que su precipitación al pasar a pH básico (fase intestinal) provocaría una disminución de la bioaccesibilidad. La materia orgánica sólo se ha demostrado relevante respecto a los contenidos pseudototales para el Zn. Para el porcentaje de bioaccesibilidad es significativo para muchos elementos en los ensayos en fase gástrica. La influencia del pH de los suelos estudiados sólo parece ser muy significativo en el caso del Cr. Los valores altamente homogéneos del pH de los suelos estudiados sin duda hacen que este parámetro no resulte significativo para más elementos, tal como se desprende de estudios anteriores. ABSTRACT A total of 32 samples of superficial soil were collected from 16 playground areas in Madrid. The in vitro bioaccessibility of As, Co, Cr, Ni, Pb and Zn (fraction below 100μm) was evaluated by means of three extraction processes. Two of them (SBET and HCl-extraction, pH=1.5) simulate the gastric enviroment, while the other one (RIVM) reproduces a gastric+intestinal digestion sequence. Bioaccessibility (%) was compared against pseudo-total concentrations of trace elements studied (aqua regia) with a linear regression model (forced to intercept the origin) Both gastric methods offered very similar and consistent results with data from other studies, with bioaccessibilities following the order: As ≈ Cu ≈ Pb ≈ Zn > Co > Ni > Cr, and ranging from 63% to 7% The values obtained through RIVM (gastric+ intestinal) method are similar to those obtained in gastric environment for elements: As, Cu, Pb and Zn (very similar to Zn, to a higher extent Cu and Pb, and to a lower extent As). On the contrary the bioaccessibility obtained for elements Co and Cu is considerable higher than in gastric environment sequence. Bioaccessibilities follows the order Co ≈ Cu ≈ Pb >As ≈ Cr ≈ Zn, ranging between 42 and 69%. The three procedures used correlate very intensively to trace elements As,Cu, Pb and Zn, existing strong correlations between almost all elements studied for the two gastric environment, not in the case of the complete digestion sequence. Some soil physical – chemical properties selected were studied, as well as their composition in some main elements in order to assess their influence on bioaccessibility. A dependence was observed between different elements bioaccesibility (%) and some soil properties, such as: Fe, Ca (carbonate) content and P, organic matter and pH. Fe content becomes very relevant regarding the bioaccessibility obtained. In all cases it correlated negatively with bioaccessibility percentage being more significant this phenomenon in gastric environment extractions. It is suggested that given the low solubility of iron oxide in the extractant media used there has to be a strong adsorption of anionic complexes (metal – chloride anion) on these Fe oxides surface, with a consequent decrease of bioaccessibility. Regarding calcium (carbonate) content this data seems very relevant referred to As bioaccessibility. Indeed, As appears to be bound to soil Ca and its solubilisation in acid media would increase As bioaccessibility, while its precipitation at basic pH (intestinal environment) would cause a reduction in bioaccessibility. The influence of organic matter only seemed significant for Zn “total” content, while it is significant in terms of gastric bioaccessibility for many elements. Soil pH only seems to be very significant in case of Cr. The highly homogeneous values for soil pH makes the influence of this parameter negligible for the other elements, unlike what has been observed in several previous studies