Comparative analysis of plant genomes through data integration

When we started our research in 2008, several online resources for genomics existed, each with a different focus. TAIR (The Arabidopsis Information Resource) has a focus on the plant model species Arabidopsis thaliana, with (at that time) little or no support for evolutionary or comparative genomics. Ensemble provided some basic tools and functions as a data warehouse, but it would only start incorporating plant genomes in 2010. There was no online resource at that time however, that provided the necessary data content and tools for plant comparative and evolutionary genomics that we required. As such, the plant community was missing an essential component to get their research at the same level as the biomedicine oriented research communities. We started to work on PLAZA in order to provide such a data resource that could be accessed by the plant community, and which also contained the necessary data content to help our research group’s focus on evolutionary genomics. The platform for comparative and evolutionary genomics, which we named PLAZA, was developed from scratch (i.e. not based on an existing database scheme, such as Ensemble). Gathering the data for all species, parsing this data into a common format and then uploading it into the database was the next step. We developed a processing pipeline, based on sequence similarity measurements, to group genes into gene families and sub families. Functional annotation was gathered through both the original data providers and through InterPro scans, combined with Interpro2GO. This primary data information was then ready to be used in every subsequent analysis. Building such a database was good enough for research within our bioinformatics group, but the target goal was to provide a comprehensive resource for all plant biologists with an interest in comparative and evolutionary genomics. Designing and creating a user-friendly, visually appealing web interface, connected to our database, was the next step. While the most detailed information is commonly presented in data tables, aesthetically pleasing graphics, images and charts are often used to visualize trends, general statistics and also used in specific tools. Design and development of these tools and visualizations is thus one of the core elements within my PhD. The PLAZA platform was designed as a gene-centric data resource, which is easily navigated when a biologist wants to study a relative small number of genes. However, using the default PLAZA website to retrieve information for dozens of genes quickly becomes very tedious. Therefore a ’gene set’-centric extra layer was developed where user-defined gene sets could be quickly analyzed. This extra layer, called the PLAZA workbench, functions on top of the normal PLAZA website, implicating that only gene sets from species present within the PLAZA database can be directly analyzed. The PLAZA resource for comparative and evolutionary genomics was a major success, but it still had several issues. We tried to solve at least two of these problems at the same time by creating a new platform. The first issue was the building procedure of PLAZA: adding a single species, or updating the structural annotation of an existing one, requires the total re-computation of the database content. The second issue was the restrictiveness of the PLAZA workbench: through a mapping procedure gene sets could be entered for species not present in the PLAZA database, but for species without a phylogenetic close relative this approach did not always yield satisfying results. Furthermore, the research in question might just focus on the difference between a species present in PLAZA and a close relative not present in PLAZA (e.g. to study adaptation to a different ecological niche). In such a case, the mapping procedure is in itself useless. With the advent of NGS transcriptome data sets for a growing number of species, it was clear that a next challenge had presented itself. We designed and developed a new platform, named TRAPID, which could automatically process entire transcriptome data sets, using a reference database. The target goal was to have the processing done quickly with the results containing both gene family oriented data (such as multiple sequence alignments and phylogenetic trees) and functional characterization of the transcripts. Major efforts went into designing the processing pipeline so it could be reliable, fast and accurate

Gene space completeness in complex plant genomes

Genome annotations offer ample opportunities to study gene functions, biochemical and regulatory pathways, or quantitative trait loci in plants. Determining the quality and completeness of a genome annotation, and maintaining the balance between them, are major challenges, even for genomes of well-studied model organisms. In this review, we present a historical overview of the complexity in different plant genomes and discuss the hurdles and possible solutions in obtaining a complete and high-quality genome annotation. We illustrate there is no clear-cut answer to solve these challenges for different gene types, but provide tips on guiding the iterative process of generating a superior genome annotation, which is a moving target as our knowledge about plant genomics increases and additional data sources become available

TRAPID : an efficient online tool for the functional and comparative analysis of de novo RNA-Seq transcriptomes

Transcriptome analysis through next-generation sequencing technologies allows the generation of detailed gene catalogs for non-model species, at the cost of new challenges with regards to computational requirements and bioinformatics expertise. Here, we present TRAPID, an online tool for the fast and efficient processing of assembled RNA-Seq transcriptome data, developed to mitigate these challenges. TRAPID offers high-throughput open reading frame detection, frameshift correction and includes a functional, comparative and phylogenetic toolbox, making use of 175 reference proteomes. Benchmarking and comparison against state-of-the-art transcript analysis tools reveals the efficiency and unique features of the TRAPID system

A collection of conserved noncoding sequences to study gene regulation in flowering plants

Transcription factors (TFs) regulate gene expression by binding cis-regulatory elements, of which the identification remains an ongoing challenge owing to the prevalence of large numbers of nonfunctional TF binding sites. Powerful comparative genomics methods, such as phylogenetic footprinting, can be used for the detection of conserved noncoding sequences (CNSs), which are functionally constrained and can greatly help in reducing the number of false-positive elements. In this study, we applied a phylogenetic footprinting approach for the identification of CNSs in 10 dicot plants, yielding 1,032,291 CNSs associated with 243,187 genes. To annotate CNSs with TF binding sites, we made use of binding site information for 642 TFs originating from 35 TF families in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). In three species, the identified CNSs were evaluated using TF chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing data, resulting in significant overlap for the majority of data sets. To identify ultraconserved CNSs, we included genomes of additional plant families and identified 715 binding sites for 501 genes conserved in dicots, monocots, mosses, and green algae. Additionally, we found that genes that are part of conserved mini-regulons have a higher coherence in their expression profile than other divergent gene pairs. All identified CNSs were integrated in the PLAZA 3.0 Dicots comparative genomics platform (http://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/plaza/versions/plaza_v3_dicots/) together with new functionalities facilitating the exploration of conserved cis-regulatory elements and their associated genes. The availability of this data set in a user-friendly platform enables the exploration of functional noncoding DNA to study gene regulation in a variety of plant species, including crops

PLAZA 4.0 : an integrative resource for functional, evolutionary and comparative plant genomics

PLAZA (https://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/plaza) is a plant-oriented online resource for comparative, evolutionary and functional genomics. The PLAZA platform consists of multiple independent instances focusing on different plant clades, while also providing access to a consistent set of reference species. Each PLAZA instance contains structural and functional gene annotations, gene family data and phylogenetic trees and detailed gene colinearity information. A user-friendly web interface makes the necessary tools and visualizations accessible, specific for each data type. Here we present PLAZA 4.0, the latest iteration of the PLAZA framework. This version consists of two new instances (Dicots 4.0 and Monocots 4.0) providing a large increase in newly available species, and offers access to updated and newly implemented tools and visualizations, helping users with the ever-increasing demands for complex and in-depth analyzes. The total number of species across both instances nearly doubles from 37 species in PLAZA 3.0 to 71 species in PLAZA 4.0, with a much broader coverage of crop species (e.g. wheat, palm oil) and species of evolutionary interest (e.g. spruce, Marchantia). The new PLAZA instances can also be accessed by a programming interface through a RESTful web service, thus allowing bioinformaticians to optimally leverage the power of the PLAZA platform