Prognostication in Stargardt disease using Fundus Autofluorescence: Improving Patient Care

PURPOSE: To explore fundus autofluorescence (FAF) imaging as an alternative to electroretinogram (ERG), as a non-invasive, quick, and readily interpretable method to predict disease progression in Stargardt disease (STGD). DESIGN: Retrospective case series of patients who attended Moorfields Eye Hospital (London, UK). SUBJECTS: Patients with STGD who met the following criteria were included: (i) biallelic disease-causing variants in ABCA4, (ii) ERG testing performed inhouse with an unequivocal ERG group classification, and (iii) ultra-widefield (UWF) FAF imaging performed up to 2 years before or after the ERG. METHODS: Patients were divided into three ERG groups based on retinal function and three FAF groups according to the extent of the hypoautofluorescence and their retinal background appearance. FAF imaging of 30 and 55° were also subsequently reviewed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: ERG/FAF concordance and its association with baseline visual acuity and genetics. RESULTS: 234 patients were included in the cohort. 170 patients (73%) had the same ERG and FAF group, 33 (14%) had a milder FAF than ERG group, and 31 (13%) had a more severe FAF than ERG group. Children under the age of 10 (n=23) had the lowest ERG/FAF concordance, 57% (9 out of the 10 with discordant ERG/FAF had milder FAF than ERG), and adults with adult onset had the highest (80%). Missense genotypes were more commonly seen in the mildest phenotypes. In 97% and 98% of the cases, respectively, 30° and 55° FAF imaging matched with the group defined by UWF FAF. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate that FAF imaging is an effective modality to determine the extent of retinal involvement and thereby inform prognostication, by comparing FAF to the current gold standard of ERG testing to determine retinal involvement and thereby prognosis. In 80% of patients in our large molecularly proven cohort we were able to predict if the disease was confined to the macula or also affected the peripheral retina. Children assessed at a young age, with at least one null variant, early disease onset, and/or poor initial VA may have wider retinal involvement than predicted by FAF alone and/or progress to a more severe FAF phenotype over time

Cone-driven strong flash electroretinograms in healthy adults: Prevalence of negative waveforms

Purpose Both rod and cone-driven signals contribute to the electroretinogram (ERG) elicited by a standard strong flash in the dark. Negative ERGs usually reflect inner retinal dysfunction. However, in diseases where rod photoreceptor function is selectively lost, a negative waveform might represent the response of the dark-adapted cone system. To investigate the dark-adapted cone-driven waveform in healthy individuals, we delivered flashes on a dim blue background, designed to saturate the rods, but minimally adapt the cones. Methods ERGs were recorded, using conductive fibre electrodes, in adults from the TwinsUK cohort. Responses to 13 cd m−2 s white xenon flashes (similar to the standard DA 10 flash), delivered on a blue background, were analysed. Photopic and scotopic strengths of the background were 1.3 and 30 cd m−2, respectively; through a dilated pupil, this is expected to largely saturate the rods, but adapt the cones much less than the standard ISCEV background. Results Mean (SD) participant age was 62.5 (11.3) years (93% female). ERGs from 203 right and 204 left eyes were included, with mean (SD) b/a ratios of 1.22 (0.28) and 1.18 (0.28), respectively (medians, 1.19 and 1.17). Proportions with negative waveforms were 23 and 26%, respectively. Right and left eye b/a ratios were strongly correlated (correlation coefficient 0.74, p < 0.0001). We found no significant correlation of b/a ratio with age. Conclusions Over 20% of eyes showed b/a ratios less than 1, consistent with the notion that dark-adapted cone-driven responses to standard bright flashes can have negative waveforms. The majority had ratios greater than 1. Thus, whilst selective loss of rod function can yield a negative waveform (with reduced a-wave) in some, our findings also suggest that loss of rod function can occur without necessarily yielding a negative ERG. One potential limitation is possible mild cone system adaptation by the background

Panel-Based Genetic Testing for Inherited Retinal Disease screening 176 Genes

Background: This case series reports the performance of a next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel of 176 retinal genes (NGS 176) in patients with inherited retinal disease (IRD). Methods: Subjects are patients who underwent genetic testing between 1 August 2016 and 1 January 2018 at Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK. Panel-based genetic testing was performed unless a specific gene (e.g., RS1) or small group of genes (e.g., ABCA4, PRPH2) were suspected. If a novel variant was identified, a further comment on their predicted pathogenicity and evolutionary conservation was offered and segregation studies performed. The main outcome measure is the likelihood of obtaining a genetic diagnosis using NGS 176. Results: 488 patients were included. A molecular diagnosis was obtained for 59.4% of patients. Younger patients were more likely to receive a molecular diagnosis; with 92% of children under the age of 6 years receiving a conclusive result. There was a change in their initially assigned inheritance pattern in 8.4% of patients following genetic testing. Selected IRD diagnoses (e.g., achromatopsia, congenital stationary night blindness) were associated with high diagnostic yields. Conclusion: This study confirms that NGS 176 is a useful first-tier genetic test for most IRD patients. Age and initial clinical diagnosis were strongly associated with diagnostic yield

Phenotyping of ABCA4 Retinopathy by Machine Learning Analysis of Full-Field Electroretinography

PURPOSE: Biallelic pathogenic variants in ABCA4 are the commonest cause of monogenic retinal disease. The full-field electroretinogram (ERG) quantifies severity of retinal dysfunction. We explored application of machine learning in ERG interpretation and in genotype–phenotype correlations. METHODS: International standard ERGs in 597 cases of ABCA4 retinopathy were classified into three functional phenotypes by human experts: macular dysfunction alone (group 1), or with additional generalized cone dysfunction (group 2), or both cone and rod dysfunction (group 3). Algorithms were developed for automatic selection and measurement of ERG components and for classification of ERG phenotype. Elastic-net regression was used to quantify severity of specific ABCA4 variants based on effect on retinal function. RESULTS: Of the cohort, 57.6%, 7.4%, and 35.0% fell into groups 1, 2, and 3 respectively. Compared with human experts, automated classification showed overall accuracy of 91.8% (SE, 0.169), and 96.7%, 39.3%, and 93.8% for groups 1, 2, and 3. When groups 2 and 3 were combined, the average holdout group accuracy was 93.6% (SE, 0.142). A regression model yielded phenotypic severity scores for the 47 commonest ABCA4 variants. CONCLUSIONS: This study quantifies prevalence of phenotypic groups based on retinal function in a uniquely large single-center cohort of patients with electrophysiologically characterized ABCA4 retinopathy and shows applicability of machine learning. Novel regression-based analyses of ABCA4 variant severity could identify individuals predisposed to severe disease. Translational Relevance: Machine learning can yield meaningful classifications of ERG data, and data-driven scoring of genetic variants can identify patients likely to benefit most from future therapies

CERKL-associated retinal dystrophy: Genetics, Phenotype and Natural History

PURPOSE: To analyze the clinical characteristics, natural history, and genetics of CERKL-associated retinal dystrophy in the largest series to date. DESIGN: Multicenter retrospective cohort study. SUBJECTS: 47 patients (37 families) with likely disease-causing CERKL variants METHODS: Review of clinical notes, ophthalmic images, and molecular diagnosis from two international centres. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Visual function, retinal imaging and characteristics were evaluated and correlated. RESULTS: The mean age at the first visit was 29.6 + 13.9 years and the mean follow-up time was 9.1 + 7.4 years. The most frequent initial symptom was central vision loss (40%) and the most common retinal feature was well-demarcated areas of macular atrophy (57%). Seventy percent of the participants had double-null genotypes and 64% had electrophysiological assessment. Amongst the latter, 53% showed similar severity of rod and cone dysfunction, 27% revealed a rod-cone, 10% a cone-rod, and 10% a macular dystrophy dysfunction pattern. Patients without double-null genotypes tended to have fewer pigment deposits and included a higher proportion of older patients with a relatively mild electrophysiological phenotype. Longitudinal analysis showed that over half of the cohort lost 15 ETDRS letters or more in at least one eye during the first 5 years of follow up. CONCLUSIONS: The phenotype of CERKL-retinal dystrophy is broad, encompassing isolated macular disease to severe retina-wide involvement, with a range of functional phenotypes, generally not fitting in the rod-cone/cone-rod dichotomy. Disease onset is often earlier, with more severe retinal degenerative changes and photoreceptor dysfunction, in nullizygous cases

CRB1-associated Retinal Dystrophies: Genetics, Clinical Characteristics and Natural History

PURPOSE: To analyse the clinical characteristics, natural history, and genetics of CRB1-associated retinal dystrophies. DESIGN: Multicenter international retrospective cohort study. METHODS: Review of clinical notes, ophthalmic images, and genetic testing results of 104 patients (91 probands) with disease-causing CRB1 variants. Macular optical coherence tomography (OCT) parameters, visual function, fundus characteristics, and associations between variables were our main outcome measures. RESULTS: The mean age of the cohort at the first visit was 19.8 ± 16.1 (median 15) years of age, with a mean follow-up of 9.6 ± 10 years. Based on history, imaging, and clinical examination, 26 individuals were diagnosed with retinitis pigmentosa (RP, 26%), 54 with early-onset severe retinal dystrophy/Leber Congenital Amaurosis (EOSRD/LCA, 51%), and 24 with macular dystrophy (MD, 23%). Severe visual impairment was most frequent after 40 years of age for patients with RP and after 20 years of age for EOSRD/LCA. Longitudinal analysis revealed a significant difference between baseline and follow up best corrected visual acuity in the three sub-cohorts. Macular thickness decreased in most patients with EOSRD/LCA and MD, whereas the majority of patients with RP had increased perifoveal thickness. CONCLUSIONS: A subset of individuals with CRB1 variants present with mild, adult-onset RP. EOSRD/LCA phenotype was significantly associated with null variants, and 167_169 deletion was exclusively present in the MD cohort. The poor OCT lamination may have a degenerative component, as well as being congenital. Disease symmetry and reasonable window for intervention highlight CRB1 retinal dystrophies as a promising target for trials of novel therapeutics

An Analysis of the Effect of ABCA4 p.Asn1868Ile Genotypes on Retinal Structure in 26,558 Participants in the UK Biobank

PURPOSE: To determine whether the ABCA4 retinopathy-associated variant p.Asn1868Ile (c.5603A>T) is associated with retinal structure or subclinical disease among the general population. METHODS: UK Biobank participants of European ancestry with available spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (OCT) passing quality control metrics and exome sequencing data were included. Regression analyses using both linear and recessive models tested for the association between the p.Asn1868Ile variant and total retinal thickness, clinically relevant segmented layer thicknesses, and visual acuity. Further regression analyses were performed with automated quality control metrics to determine if the p.Asn1868Ile variant is associated with poor quality or abnormal scans. RESULTS: Retinal layer segmentation and sequencing data for the p.Asn1868Ile variant were available for 26,558 participants, following exclusions. We identified no significant association between the p.Asn1868Ile variant and retinal thickness, any of the segmented layers, or visual acuity. There was also no significant difference for homozygous p.Asn1868Ile when tested under the assumption of a recessive model. No association was identified for any of the quality control metrics, and a χ2 test showed that participants with the p.Asn1868Ile variant were not more likely to be excluded during quality control due to poor quality scans (P = 0.56). CONCLUSIONS: The p.Asn1868Ile variant does not appear to affect the retinal structure or have pathogenic or subclinical effects on its own within the general population. The variant is likely to require other specific cis- or trans-acting modifying factors to cause ABCA4 retinopathy

RP2-associated X-linked Retinopathy: Clinical Findings, Molecular Genetics, and Natural History

PURPOSE: To review and describe in detail the clinical course, functional and anatomical characteristics of RP2-associated retinal degeneration. DESIGN: Retrospective case series. PARTICIPANTS: Males with disease-causing variants in the RP2 gene. METHODS: Review of all case notes and results of molecular genetic testing, retinal imaging (fundus autofluorescence (FAF) imaging, optical coherence tomography (OCT)) and electrophysiology assessment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Molecular genetic testing, clinical findings including best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), qualitative and quantitative retinal imaging analysis, and electrophysiology parameters. RESULTS: Fifty-four molecularly confirmed patients were identified, from 38 pedigrees. Twenty-eight disease-causing variants were identified; with 20 not previously clinically characterized. Fifty-three patients (98.1%) presented with retinitis pigmentosa. The mean age of onset (range, ±SD) was 9.6 years of age (1-57 years, ± 9.2 years). Forty-four patients (91.7%) had childhood-onset disease, with mean age of onset of 7.6 years. The commonest first symptom was night blindness (68.8%). Mean BCVA (range, ±SD) was 0.91 LogMAR (0-2.7, ±0.80) and 0.94 LogMAR (0-2.7, ±0.78) for right and left eyes respectively. Based on the WHO visual impairment criteria, 18 patients (34%) had low vision. The majority (17/22) showed ERG evidence of a rod-cone dystrophy. Pattern ERG P50 was undetectable in all but 2 patients. A range of FAF findings was observed, from normal to advanced atrophy. There were no statistically significant differences between right and left eyes for ellipsoid zone (EZ) width and outer nuclear layer (ONL) thickness. The mean annual rate of EZ width loss was 219 μm/year and the mean annual decrease in ONL thickness was 4.93 μm/year. No patient with childhood-onset disease had identifiable EZ after the age of 26 years at baseline or follow-up. Four patients had adulthood-onset disease and a less severe phenotype. CONCLUSIONS: This study details the clinical phenotype of RP2 retinopathy in a large cohort. The majority presented with early-onset severe retinal degeneration, with early macular involvement and complete loss of the foveal photoreceptor layer by the third decade of life. Full-field ERGs revealed rod-cone dystrophy in the vast majority, but with generalised (peripheral) cone system involvement of widely varying severity in the first two decades of life

Axial Length Distributions in Patients With Genetically Confirmed Inherited Retinal Diseases

PURPOSE: We investigated axial length (AL) distributions in inherited retinal diseases (IRDs), comparing them with reference cohorts. METHODS: AL measurements from IRD natural history study participants were included and compared with reference cohorts (TwinsUK, Raine Study Gen2-20, and published studies). Comparing with the Raine Study cohort, formal odds ratios (ORs) for AL ≥ 26 mm or AL ≤ 22 mm were derived for each IRD (Firth's logistic regression model, adjusted for age and sex). RESULTS: Measurements were available for 435 patients (median age, 19.5 years). Of 19 diseases, 10 had >10 participants: ABCA4 retinopathy; CNGB3- and CNGA3-associated achromatopsia; RPGR-associated disease; RPE65-associated disease; blue cone monochromacy (BCM); Bornholm eye disease (BED); TYR- and OCA2-associated oculocutaneous albinism; and GPR143-associated ocular albinism. Compared with the TwinsUK cohort (n = 322; median age, 65.1 years) and Raine Study cohort (n = 1335; median age, 19.9 years), AL distributions were wider in the IRD groups. Increased odds for longer ALs were observed for BCM, BED, RPGR, RPE65, OCA2, and TYR; increased odds for short AL were observed for RPE65, TYR, and GPR143. In subanalysis of RPGR-associated disease, longer average ALs occurred in cone–rod dystrophy (n = 5) than rod–cone dystrophy (P = 0.002). CONCLUSIONS: Several diseases showed increased odds for longer AL (highest OR with BCM); some showed increased odds for shorter AL (highest OR with GPR143). Patients with RPE65- and TYR-associated disease showed increased odds for longer and for shorter eyes. Albinism genes were associated with different effects on AL. These findings add to the phenotype of IRDs and may yield insights into mechanisms of refractive error development

RBP3-retinopathy - inherited high myopia and retinal dystrophy: Genetic Characterization, Natural History, and Deep Phenotyping

Objective: To examine the genetic and clinical features and the natural history of RBP3-associated retinopathy. // Design: Multi-center international, retrospective, case series. // Setting: Three tertiary referral centers. // Participants: Adults and children, with molecularly confirmed RBP3-associated retinopathy. // Main Outcomes and Measures: Multi-center, international, retrospective, consecutive observational study in three tertiary referral centers of adults and children, with molecularly confirmed RBP3-retinopathy. The genetic, clinical and retinal imaging findings, including optical coherence tomography (OCT) and fundus autofluorescence (FAF), were investigated both cross-sectionally and longitudinally. The results of International standard full-field and pattern electroretinography (ERG; PERG) were reviewed. // Results: We ascertained 12 patients (5 females), from 10 families, with four patients previously reported. Eight novel disease-causing RBP3 variants were identified. Ten patients were homozygous. The mean age (±SD, range) of the group was 21.4 years (±19.1, 2.9-60.5 years) at baseline evaluation. All 12 patients were highly myopic with a mean spherical equivalent of -16.0D (range; -7.0D to -33.0D). Visual acuity was not significantly different between eyes and no significant anisometropia was observed. Mean best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) was 0.48 LogMAR (range; 0.2-1.35, SD; ± 0.29 LogMAR) at baseline. Eleven patients had longitudinal BCVA assessment, with a mean BCVA of 0.46 LogMAR after a mean follow-up of 12.6 years. All patients were symptomatic with reduced VA and myopia by the age of 7 years. All patients had myopic fundi and features in keeping with high myopia on OCT, including choroidal thinning. The 4 youngest patients had no fundus pigmentary changes, with the rest presenting with a variable degree of mid-peripheral pigmentation and macular changes. FAF showed variable phenotypes, ranging from areas of increased signal to advanced atrophy in older patients. OCT showed cystoid macular edema at presentation in three patients, which persisted during follow-up in two patients and resolved to atrophy for the third patient. The ERGs were abnormal in 9 of 9 cases, revealing variable relative involvement of rod and cone photoreceptors with additional milder dysfunction post-phototransduction in some. All but one had PERG evidence of macular dysfunction, severe in most. // Conclusions: This study details the clinical and functional phenotype of RBP3-retinopathy in the largest cohort reported to date. RBP3-retinopathy is a disease characterized by early onset, slow progression over decades, and high myopia. The phenotypic spectrum and natural history as described herein has prognostic and counselling implications. RBP3-related disease should be considered in children with high myopia and retinal dystrophy