Reply to Comment on "Triviality of the Ground State Structure in Ising Spin Glasses"

We reply to the comment of Marinari and Parisi [cond-mat/0002457 v2] on our paper [Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 5126 (1999) and cond-mat/9906323]. We show that the data in the comment are affected by strong finite-size corrections. Therefore the original conclusion of our paper still stands.Comment: Reply to comment cond-mat/0002457 on cond-mat/9906323. Final version with minor change

Comment on ``Triviality of the Ground State Structure in Ising Spin Glasses''

We show that the evidence of cond-mat/9906323 does not discriminate among droplet model and mean field like behavior.Comment: 1 page comment with two .ps figures included. Rewritten version, one error correcte

Spin and link overlaps in 3-dimensional spin glasses

Excitations of three-dimensional spin glasses are computed numerically. We find that one can flip a finite fraction of an LxLxL lattice with an O(1) energy cost, confirming the mean field picture of a non-trivial spin overlap distribution P(q). These low energy excitations are not domain-wall-like, rather they are topologically non-trivial and they reach out to the boundaries of the lattice. Their surface to volume ratios decrease as L increases and may asymptotically go to zero. If so, link and window overlaps between the ground state and these excited states become ``trivial''.Comment: Extra fits comparing TNT to mean field, summarized in a tabl

On the Effects of Changing the Boundary Conditions on the Ground State of Ising Spin Glasses

We compute and analyze couples of ground states of 3D spin glass systems with the same quenched noise but periodic and anti-periodic boundary conditions for different lattice sizes. We discuss the possible different behaviors of the system, we analyze the average link overlap, the probability distribution of window overlaps (among ground states computed with different boundary conditions) and the spatial overlap and link overlap correlation functions. We establish that the picture based on Replica Symmetry Breaking correctly describes the behavior of 3D Spin Glasses.Comment: 25 pages with 11 ps figures include

On the Effects of a Bulk Perturbation on the Ground State of 3D Ising Spin Glasses

We compute and analyze couples of ground states of 3D spin glasses before and after applying a volume perturbation which adds to the Hamiltonian a repulsion from the true ground state. The physical picture based on Replica Symmetry Breaking is in excellent agreement with the observed behavior.Comment: 4 pages including 5 .ps figure

The +/-J Spin Glass: Effects of Ground State Degeneracy

We perform Monte Carlo simulations of the Ising spin glass at low temperature in three dimensions with a +/-J distribution of couplings. Our results display crossover scaling between T=0 behavior, where the order parameter distribution P(q) becomes trivial for L -> $\infty$, and finite-T behavior, where the non-trivial part of P(q) has a much weaker dependence on the size L, and is possibly size independent.Comment: 4 pages, 5 figures. Replaced with published version. Minor change

Landscape of solutions in constraint satisfaction problems

We present a theoretical framework for characterizing the geometrical properties of the space of solutions in constraint satisfaction problems, together with practical algorithms for studying this structure on particular instances. We apply our method to the coloring problem, for which we obtain the total number of solutions and analyze in detail the distribution of distances between solutions.Comment: 4 pages, 4 figures. Replaced with published versio

Domain wall entropy of the bimodal two-dimensional Ising spin glass

We report calculations of the domain wall entropy for the bimodal two-dimensional Ising spin glass in the critical ground state. The L * L system sizes are large with L up to 256. We find that it is possible to fit the variance of the domain wall entropy to a power function of L. However, the quality of the data distributions are unsatisfactory with large L > 96. Consequently, it is not possible to reliably determine the fractal dimension of the domain walls.Comment: 4 pages, 2 figures, submitted to PR

Nature of the Spin Glass State

The nature of the spin glass state is investigated by studying changes to the ground state when a weak perturbation is applied to the bulk of the system. We consider short range models in three and four dimensions and the infinite range Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) and Viana-Bray models. Our results for the SK and Viana-Bray models agree with the replica symmetry breaking picture. The data for the short range models fit naturally a picture in which there are large scale excitations which cost a finite energy but whose surface has a fractal dimension, $d_s$, less than the space dimension $d$. We also discuss a possible crossover to other behavior at larger length scales than the sizes studied.Comment: 4 pages, 4 postscript figures included. Final version, only minor changes mad

State Hierarchy Induced by Correlated Spin Domains in short range spin glasses

We generate equilibrium configurations for the three and four dimensional Ising spin glass with Gaussian distributed couplings at temperatures well below the transition temperature T_c. These states are analyzed by a recently proposed method using clustering. The analysis reveals a hierarchical state space structure. At each level of the hierarchy states are labeled by the orientations of a set of correlated macroscopic spin domains. Our picture of the low temperature phase of short range spin glasses is that of a State Hierarchy Induced by Correlated Spin domains (SHICS). The complexity of the low temperature phase is manifest in the fact that the composition of such a spin domain (i.e. its constituent spins), as well as its identifying label, are defined and determined by the ``location'' in the state hierarchy at which it appears. Mapping out the phase space structure by means of the orientations assumed by these domains enhances our ability to investigate the overlap distribution, which we find to be non-trivial. Evidence is also presented that these states may have a non-ultrametric structure.Comment: 30 pages, 17 figure