Cooperation with both synergistic and local interactions can be worse than each alone

Cooperation is ubiquitous ranging from multicellular organisms to human societies. Population structures indicating individuals' limited interaction ranges are crucial to understand this issue. But it is still at large to what extend multiple interactions involving nonlinearity in payoff play a role on cooperation in structured populations. Here we show a rule, which determines the emergence and stabilization of cooperation, under multiple discounted, linear, and synergistic interactions. The rule is validated by simulations in homogenous and heterogenous structured populations. We find that the more neighbors there are the harder for cooperation to evolve for multiple interactions with linearity and discounting. For synergistic scenario, however, distinct from its pairwise counterpart, moderate number of neighbors can be the worst, indicating that synergistic interactions work with strangers but not with neighbors. Our results suggest that the combination of different factors which promotes cooperation alone can be worse than that with every single factor.Comment: 32 pages, 4 figure

High-Accuracy Approximation of Evolutionary Pairwise Games on Complex Networks

Previous studies have shown that the topological properties of a complex network, such as heterogeneity and average degree, affect the evolutionary game dynamics on it. However, traditional numerical simulations are usually time-consuming and demand a lot of computational resources. In this paper, we propose the method of dynamical approximate master equations (DAMEs) to accurately approximate the evolutionary outcomes on complex networks. We demonstrate that the accuracy of DAMEs supersedes previous standard pairwise approximation methods, and DAMEs require far fewer computational resources than traditional numerical simulations. We use prisoner's dilemma and snowdrift game on regular and scale-free networks to demonstrate the applicability of DAMEs. Overall, our method facilitates the investigation of evolutionary dynamics on a broad range of complex networks, and provides new insights into the puzzle of cooperation.Comment: 21 pages, 4 figure

Temporal higher-order interactions facilitate the evolution of cooperation

Motivated by the vital progress of modeling higher-order interactions by hypernetworks, where a link connects more than two individuals, we study the evolution of cooperation on temporal hypernetworks. We find that temporal hypernetworks may promote cooperation compared with their static counterparts. Our results offer new insights into the impact of network temporality in higher-order interactions on understanding the evolution of cooperation, suggesting traditional networks based on pairwise or static interactions may underestimate the potential of local interactions to foster cooperation.Comment: 6 pages, 4 figure