8 research outputs found
All the (Many, Many) Things We Know: Extended Knowledge *
Abstract In this paper we explore the potential bearing of the extended mind thesis-the thesis that the mind extends into the world-on epistemology. We do three things. First, we argue that the combination of the extended mind thesis and reliabilism about knowledge entails that ordinary subjects can easily come to enjoy various forms of restricted omniscience. Second, we discuss the conceptual foundations of the extended mind and knowledge debate. We suggest that the theses of extended mind and extended knowledge lead to a bifurcation with respect to the concepts of belief and knowledge. We suggest that this conceptual bifurcation supports a form of pluralism about these concepts. Third, we discuss whether something similar can be said at the metaphysical level
Constructive Analysis : A Study in Epistemological Methodology
In the present study, it is argued that much of contemporary epistemology
has not been conducted in a way conducive to what should be one of its
main goals, namely to guide epistemic inquiry in the attainment of our most
central epistemic goals. Furthermore, it is claimed that the very reason that
epistemology has failed to do so pertains to an entrenched—indeed, in a sense,
a literally ancient—but implausible methodology, best understood as the pursuit
of definitions by way of intuitions. More specifically, the present study not only (a)
argues that we ought to revise this methodology and (b) puts forward an alternative,
but also (c) demonstrates the usefulness of this alternative methodology
within the analysis of epistemic justification. With respect to the latter, it is first
argued that some of the most influential theories fail and that our concept of
justification—considering the goals of epistemic inquiry—is best reconstructed in
terms of truth-conductivity, and then, through a discussion of psychological
research relevant to reasoning strategies, shown how such a reconstructed concept
may be used to improve on actual truth-seeking inquiry