Das olfaktorische System der Blattschneiderameisen: Neuroanatomie und Korrelation zur sozialen Organisation

In leaf-cutting ants (genera Atta and Acromyrmex), the worker caste exhibits a pronounced size-polymorphism, and division of labor is largely dependent on worker size (alloethism). Behavioral studies have shown a rich diversity of olfactory-guided behaviors, and the olfactory system seems to be highly developed and very sensitive. To allow fine-tuned behavioral responses to different tasks, adaptations within the olfactory system of different sized workers are expected. In a recent study, two different phenotypes of the antennal lobe of Atta vollenweideri workers were found: MG- and RG-phenotype (with and without a macroglomerulus, MG). The existence of the macroglomerulus is correlated to the body size of workers, with small workers showing the RG-phenotype and large workers showing the MG-phenotype. In the MG, the information about the releaser component of the trail-pheromone is processed. In the first part of my PhD-project, I focus on quantifying behavioral differences between different sized workers in Atta vollenweideri. The study analyzes the trail following behavior; which can be generally performed by all workers. An artificial trail consisting of the releaser component of the trail-pheromone in decreasing concentration was used to test the trail-following performance of individual workers. The trail-following performance of the polymorphic workers is depended of the existence of the MG in the antennal lobe. Workers possessing the MG-phenotype were significantly better in following a decreasing trail then workers showing the RG-phenotype. In the second part I address the question if there are more structural differences, besides the MG, in the olfactory system of different sized workers. Therefore I analyze whether the glomerular numbers are related to worker size. The antennal lobes of small workers contain ~390 glomeruli (low-number; LN-phenotype), and in large workers I found a substantially higher number of ~440 glomeruli (high-number; HN-phenotype). All LN-phenotype workers and some of the small HN-phenotype workers do not possess an MG (LN-RG-phenotype and HN-RG-phenotype) at all, whereas the remaining majority of HN-phenotype workers do possess an MG (HN-MG-phenotype). Mass-stainings of antennal olfactory receptor neurons revealed that the sensory tracts divide the antennal lobe into six clusters of glomeruli (T1-T6). In the T4-cluster ~50 glomeruli are missing in the LN-phenotype workers. Selective staining of single sensilla and their associated receptor neurons showed that T4-glomeruli are innervated by receptor neurons from the main type of olfactory sensilla, the Sensilla trichodea curvata which are also projecting to glomeruli in all other clusters. The other type of olfactory sensilla, the Sensilla basiconica, exclusively innervates T6-glomeruli. Quantitative analyses revealed a correlation between the number of Sensilla basiconica and the volume of T6 glomeruli in different sized workers. The results of both behavioral and neuroanatomical studies in Atta vollenweideri suggest that developmental plasticity of antennal-lobe phenotypes promotes differences in olfactory-guided behavior which may underlie task specialization within ant colonies. The last part of my project focuses on the evolutionary origin of the macroglomerulus and the number of glomeruli in the antennal lobe. I compared the number, volumes and position of the glomeruli of the antennal lobe of 25 different species from all three major Attini groups (lower, higher and leaf-cutting Attini). The antennal lobes of all investigated Attini comprise a high number of glomeruli (257-630). The highest number was found in Apterostigma cf. mayri. This species is at a basal position within the Attini phylogeny, and a high number of glomeruli might have been advantageous in the evolution of the advanced olfactory systems of this Taxa. The macroglomerulus can be found in all investigated leaf-cutting Attini, but in none of the lower and higher Attini species. It is found only in large workers, and is located close to the entrance of the antennal nerve in all investigated species. The results indicate that the presence of a macroglomerulus in large workers of leaf-cutting Attini is a derived overexpression of a trait in the polymorphic leaf-cutting species. It presumably represents an olfactory adaptation to elaborate foraging and mass recruitment systems, and adds to the complexity of division of labor and social organization known for this group.Die Arbeiterinnenkaste der Blattschneideameisen zeigt einen ausgeprägten Größenpolymorphismus. Man findet hier einen Alloethismus; unterschiedlich große Arbeiterinnen führen verschiedene Arbeiten im Stock durch. Verschiedene Verhaltensversuche haben gezeigt, dass viele Verhaltensweisen der Arbeiterinnen olfaktorisch gesteuert werden und dass das olfaktorische System hoch entwickelt und sehr sensitiv ist. Es ist wahrscheinlich, dass sich im olfaktorischen System verschieden großer Arbeiterinnen Anpassungen finden lassen, die gut abgestimmte Verhaltensantworten auf die verschiedenen Aufgaben der Tiere ermöglichen. Und tatsächlich zeigt eine aktuelle Studie, dass zwei verschiedene Phänotypen des Antennallobus der Arbeiterin bei Atta vollenweideri existieren, der MG- und der RG-Phänotyp (mit oder ohne Makroglomerulus, MG). Die Existenz des Makroglomerulus kann mit der Körpergröße der Tiere korreliert werden: bei kleinen Arbeiterinnen findet man den RG-Phänotyp, bei großen den MG-Phänotyp. Im Makroglomerulus wird die olfaktorische Information über den verhaltensauslösenden Bestandteil des Spurpheromons verarbeitet. Im ersten Tel meiner Doktorarbeit versuche ich, Verhaltensunterschiede verschieden großer Atta vollenweideri Arbeiterinnen zu quantifizieren. Dazu konzentriere ich mich auf das Spurfolgeverhalten, dass bei Arbeiterinnen jeder Größe beobachtet werden kann. Um die Spurfolgeleistung einzelner Arbeiterinnen zu testen, wurde eine künstlich gelegte Spur mit abnehmender Konzentration des verhaltensauslösenden Bestandteils des Spurpheromons verwendet. Die Spurfolgeleistung der Arbeiterinnen hängt von der Existenz des Makroglomerulus im Antennallobus ab. Im zweiten Teil meiner Doktorarbeit untersuche ich die Neuroanatomie des olfaktorischen Systems bei verschieden großen Atta vollenweideri Arbeiterinnen auf eventuelle weitere anatomische Unterschiede neben dem Makroglomerulus – im Besonderen ob die Anzahl an Glomeruli bei verschieden großen Tieren unterschiedlich ist. Die Antennalloben kleiner Arbeiterinnen beinhalten cirka 390 Glomeruli (geringe Anzahl, LN-Phänotyp), die Antennalloben großer Arbeiterinnen dagegen cirka 440 Glomeruli (hohe Anzahl, HN-Phänotyp). Alle Arbeiterinnen mit dem LN-Phänotyp und einige mit dem HN-Phänotyp besitzen keinen Makroglomerulus (LN-RG-Phänotyp und HN-RG-Phänotyp). Die meisten Tiere mit HN-Phänotyp besitzen jedoch einen Makroglomerulus (HN-MG-Phänotyp). Massenfärbungen der olfaktorischen Rezeptorneuron-Axone zeigen, dass der Antennennerv sich in sechs Trakte teilt und so die Glomeruli in sechs verschiedene Glomerulicluster unterteilt werden können (T1-T6). Bei den Arbeiterinnen mit LN-Phänotyp fehlen cirka 50 Glomeruli im T4-Cluster. Einzelsensillenfärbungen zeigen, dass die Rezeptorneuronen der olfaktorischen Sensilla trichodea curvata alle sechs Cluster, also auch das T4-Cluster innervieren. Ein weiterer Sensillentyp, die Sensilla basiconica, innerviert ausschließlich Glomeruli im T6-Cluster. Quantitative Analysen ergeben eine Korrelation zwischen der Anzahl der Sensilla basiconica auf der Arbeiterinnenantenne und des durchschnittlichen Volumens der T6-Glomeruli bei verschieden großen Tieren. Die Ergebnisse der Verhaltensversuche und der neuroanatomischen Studien könnten darauf hinweisen, dass Unterschiede im Verhalten auf olfaktorische Reize möglicherweise durch die Entwicklungsplastizität der Antenallobus-Phänotypen ausgelöst werden. Dies könnte innerhalb der Kolonie die Grundlage der Spezialisierung von Arbeiterinnen auf bestimmte Arbeiten sein. Den letzten Teil meiner Doktorarbeit nimmt eine Untersuchung über den evolutionären Ursprung des Makroglomerulus und der Anzahl der Glomeruli im Antennallobus ein. Dazu verglich ich in den Antennalloben 25 verschiedener Arten aus den drei Attini-Gruppen (basale, höhere und blattschneidende Attini) die Anzahl, das Volumen und die Position der Glomeruli. Die Antennalloben aller untersuchten Arten bestehen aus sehr vielen Glomeruli (257-630). Der Makroglomerulus findet sich in allen untersuchten blattschneidenden Attini-Arten, aber nie in den untersuchten basalen und höheren Attini-Arten. Er findet sich nur bei größeren Arbeiterinnen und befindet sich immer in der Nähe des Antennennerveingangs. Dies bedeutet, dass es sich bei der Existenz des Makroglomerulus in den großen Blattschneidearbeiterinnen um eine abgeleitete Überexpression eines Merkmals innerhalb der polymorphen blattschneidenden Attini-Arten handelt. Der Makroglomerulus ist wahrscheinlich eine olfaktorische Anpassung an das hoch entwickelte Fouragier- und Rekrutiersystem dieser Arten. Er ist ein Baustein der komplexen Arbeitsteilung und der komplexen sozialen Organisation, die für die Arten dieser Gruppe bekannt sind

Multiple olfactory receptor neurons and their axonal projections in the antennal lobe of the honeybee Apis mellifera

The poreplate sensilla of honeybees are equipped with multiple olfactory receptor neurons (ORNs), which innervate glomeruli of the antennal lobe (AL). We investigated the axonal projection pattern in glomeruli of the AL (glomerular pattern), formed by the multiple ORNs of individual poreplate sensilla. We used the different glomerular patterns to draw conclusions about the equipment of poreplate sensilla with different ORN types. ORNs of single poreplate sensilla were stained and analyzed by laser-scanning confocal microscopy and 3D software (AMIRA). In 13 specimens we found between 7 and 23 ORNs. This is in accordance with data found in the literature (5–35 ORNs) suggesting that all ORNs of the single poreplate sensilla were stained. The ORNs innervate the AL via all four sensory tracts (T1–T4), and glomeruli of the anterior part of the AL are more often innervated. Each ORN innervates a single glomerulus (uniglomerular), and all ORNs of one poreplate sensillum project to different glomeruli. Visual inspection and individual identification of glomeruli, based on the honeybee digital AL atlas, were used to evaluate mapping of glomeruli by a rigid transformation of the experimental ALs onto a reference AL. ORNs belonging to individual poreplate sensilla form variable glomerular patterns, and we did not find a common organization of glomerular patterns. We conclude that poreplate sensilla are equipped with different ORN types but that the same ORN types can be found in different poreplate sensilla. The equipment of poreplate sensilla with ORNs is overlapping. The mapping of glomeruli by rigid transformation is revealed to be a powerful tool for comparative neuroanatomy

Phenotypic plasticity in number of glomeruli and sensory innervation of the antennal lobe in leaf-cutting ant workers (A. vollenweideri)

In the leaf-cutting ant Atta vollenweideri, the worker caste exhibits a pronounced size-polymorphism, and division of labor is dependent on worker size (alloethism). Behavior is largely guided by olfaction, and the olfactory system is highly developed. In a recent study, two different phenotypes of the antennal lobe of Atta vollenweideri workers were found: MG- and RG-phenotype (with/without a macroglomerulus). Here we ask whether the glomerular numbers are related to worker size. We found that the antennal lobes of small workers contain ∼390 glomeruli (low-number; LN-phenotype), and in large workers we found a substantially higher number of ∼440 glomeruli (high-number; HN-phenotype). All LN-phenotype workers and some small HN-phenotype workers do not possess an MG (LN-RG-phenotype and HN-RG-phenotype), and the remaining majority of HN-phenotype workers do possess an MG (HN-MG-phenotype). Using mass-staining of antennal olfactory receptor neurons we found that the sensory tracts divide the antennal lobe into six clusters of glomeruli (T1 T6). In LN-phenotype workers, ∼50 glomeruli are missing in the T4-cluster. Selective staining of single sensilla and their associated receptor neurons revealed that T4-glomeruli are innervated by receptor neurons from the main type of olfactory sensilla, the Sensilla trichodea curvata. The other type of olfactory sensilla (Sensilla basiconica) exclusively innervates T6-glomeruli. Quantitative analyses of differently sized workers revealed that the volume of T6 glomeruli scales with the power of 2.54 to the number of Sensilla basiconica. The results suggest that developmental plasticity leading to antennal-lobe phenotypes promotes differences in olfactory-guided behavior and may underlie task specialization within ant colonies

Antennal-Lobe Organization in Desert Ants of the Genus Cataglyphis

Desert ants of the genus Cataglyphis possess remarkable visual navigation capabilities. Although Cataglyphis species lack a trail pheromone system, Cataglyphis fortis employs olfactory cues for detecting nest and food sites. To investigate potential adaptations in primary olfactory centers of the brain of C. fortis, we analyzed olfactory glomeruli (odor processing units) in their antennal lobes and compared them to glomeruli in different Cataglyphis species. Using confocal imaging and 3D reconstruction, we analyzed the number, size and spatial arrangement of olfactory glomeruli in C. fortis, C.albicans, C.bicolor, C.rubra, and C.noda. Workers of all Cataglyphis species have smaller numbers of glomeruli (198–249) compared to those previously found in olfactory-guided ants. Analyses in 2 species of Formica – a genus closely related to Cataglyphis – revealed substantially higher numbers of olfactory glomeruli (c. 370), which is likely to reflect the importance of olfaction in these wood ant species. Comparisons between Cataglyphis species revealed 2 special features in C. fortis. First, with c. 198 C. fortis has the lowest number of glomeruli compared to all other species. Second, a conspicuously enlarged glomerulus is located close to the antennal nerve entrance. Males of C. fortis possess a significantly smaller number of glomeruli (c. 150) compared to female workers and queens. A prominent male-specific macroglomerulus likely to be involved in sex pheromone communication occupies a position different from that of the enlarged glomerulus in females. The behavioral significance of the enlarged glomerulus in female workers remains elusive. The fact that C. fortis inhabits microhabitats (salt pans) that are avoided by all other Cataglyphis species suggests that extreme ecological conditions may not only have resulted in adaptations of visual capabilities, but also in specializations of the olfactory system

The Antennal Lobes of Fungus-Growing Ants (Attini) : Neuroanatomical Traits and Evolutionary Trends

Ants of the tribe Attini are characterized by their obligate cultivation of symbiotic fungi. In addition to the complex chemical communication system of ants in general, substrate selection and fungus cultivation pose high demands on the olfactory system of the Attini. Indeed, behavioral studies have shown a rich diversity of olfactory-guided behaviors and tremendous odor sensitivity has been demonstrated. To allow fine-tuned behavioral responses, adaptations within the olfactory system of the Attini are expected. We compared the number, volumes and position of the glomeruli (functional units) of the antennal lobe of 25 different species from all three major Attini groups (lower, higher and leaf-cutting Attini). The antennal lobes of all investigated Attini comprise a high number of glomeruli ( 1 257). The highest number (630) was found in Apterostigma cf. mayri. This species is at a basal position within the Attini phylogeny, and we suggest that a high number of glomeruli might have been advantageous in the evolution of the advanced olfactory systems of the Attini. In the leaf-cutting Attini, an extremely large glomerulus (macroglomerulus) near the antennal nerve entrance was recently described in two species. Preliminary results show that this macroglomerulus is involved in processing of trail-pheromone information. In our comparative study, we find this macroglomerulus in all investigated leaf-cutting Attini, but in none of the lower and higher Attini species. It is found only in large workers, and for all investigated species it is located close to the entrance of the antennal nerve. Our results indicate that the presence of a macroglomerulus in large workers of leaf-cutting Attini is a derived over-expression of a trait in the polymorphic leaf-cutting species. It presumably represents an olfactory adaptation to elaborate foraging and mass recruitment systems, and adds to the complexity of division of labor and social organization known for this group

Sexual dimorphism in the olfactory system of a solitary and a eusocial bee species

Sexually dimorphic sensory systems are common in Hymenoptera and are considered to result from sex-specific selection pressures. An extreme example of sensory dimorphism is found in the solitary bee tribe Eucerini. Males of long-horned bees bear antennae that exceed body length. This study investigated the pronounced sexual dimorphism of the peripheral olfactory system and its representation in higher brain centers of the species Eucera berlandi. Eucera males have elongated antennae, with 10 times more pore plates and three times more olfactory receptor neurons than females. The male antennal lobe (AL) comprises fewer glomeruli than the female AL (approximate to 100 vs. approximate to 130), of which four are male-specific macroglomeruli. No sex differences were found in the relative volume of the mushroom bodies, a higher order neuropil essential for learning and memory in Hymenoptera. Compared with the Western honeybee, the degree of sexual dimorphism in Eucera is more pronounced at the periphery. In contrast, sex differences in glomerular numbers are higher in the eusocial honeybee and a sexual dimorphism of the relative investment in mushroom body tissue is observed only in Apis. The observed differences between the eusocial and the solitary bee species may reflect differences in male-specific behavioral traits and associated selection pressures, which are discussed in brief