81 research outputs found
Fast Polyhedral Adaptive Conjoint Estimation
We propose and test a new adaptive conjoint analysis method that draws on recent polyhedral âinterior-pointâ developments in mathematical programming. The method is designed to offer accurate estimates after relatively few questions in problems involving many parameters. Each respondentâs ques-tions are adapted based upon prior answers by that respondent. The method requires computer support but can operate in both Internet and off-line environments with no noticeable delay between questions. We use Monte Carlo simulations to compare the performance of the method against a broad array of relevant benchmarks. While no method dominates in all situations, polyhedral algorithms appear to hold significant potential when (a) metric profile comparisons are more accurate than the self-explicated importance measures used in benchmark methods, (b) when respondent wear out is a concern, and (c) when product development and/or marketing teams wish to screen many features quickly. We also test hybrid methods that combine polyhedral algorithms with existing conjoint analysis methods. We close with suggestions on how polyhedral methods can be used to address other marketing problems.Sloan School of Management and the Center for Innovation in Product Development at MI
Application and Test of Web-based Adaptive Polyhedral Conjoint Analysis
In response to the need for more rapid and iterative feedback on customer preferences, researchers are developing new web-based conjoint analysis methods that adapt the design of conjoint questions based on a respondentâs answers to previous questions. Adapting within a respondent is a difficult dy-namic optimization problem and until recently adaptive conjoint analysis (ACA) was the dominant method available for addressing this adaptation. In this paper we apply and test a new polyhedral method that uses âinterior-pointâ math programming techniques. This method is benchmarked against both ACA and an efficient non-adaptive design (Fixed).
Over 300 respondents were randomly assigned to different experimental conditions and were asked to complete a web-based conjoint exercise. The conditions varied based on the design of the con-joint exercise. Respondents in one group completed a conjoint exercise designed using the ACA method, respondents in another group completed an exercise designed using the Fixed method, and the remaining respondents completed an exercise designed using the polyhedral method. Following the conjoint exer-cise respondents were given 100.
We compare the methods on both internal and external validity. Internal validity is evaluated by comparing how well the different conjoint methods predict several holdout conjoint questions. External validity is evaluated by comparing how well the conjoint methods predict the respondentsâ selections from the choice sets of five bags.
The results reveal a remarkable level of consistency across the two validation tasks. The polyhe-dral method was consistently more accurate than both the ACA and Fixed methods. However, even better performance was achieved by combining (post hoc) different components of each method to create a range of hybrid methods. Additional analyses evaluate the robustness of the predictions and explore al-ternative estimation methods such as Hierarchical Bayes. At the time of the test, the bags were proto-types. Based, in part, on the results of this study these bags are now commercially available.The Sloan School of Management, the Center for Innovation in Product Development at MIT and the EBusiness Center at MI
Measuring Consumer Preferences Using Conjoint Poker
We develop and test an incentive-compatible Conjoint Poker (CP) game. The preference data collected in the context of this game are comparable to incentive-compatible choice-based conjoint (CBC) analysis data. We develop a statistical efficiency measure and an algorithm to construct efficient CP designs. We compare incentive-compatible CP to incentive-compatible CBC in a series of three experiments (one online study and two eye-tracking studies). Our results suggest that CP induces respondents to consider more of the profile-related
information presented to them compared with CBC
Fast Polyhedral Adaptive Conjoint Estimation
We propose and test new "polyhedral" question design and estimation methods that
use recent developments in mathematical programming. The methods are designed to
offer accurate estimates after relatively few questions in problems involving many
parameters. With polyhedral question design, each respondent's questions are adapted
based upon prior answers by that respondent to reduce a feasible set of parameters as
rapidly as possible. Polyhedral estimation provides estimates based on a centrality
criterion (the "analytic center" of the feasible parameter set). The methods require
computer support but can operate in both Internet and other computer-aided
environments with no noticeable delay between questions.
We evaluate the proposed methods using two approaches. First, we use Monte Carlo
simulations to compare the methods against established benchmarks in a variety of
domains. In the simulations we compare polyhedral question design to three
benchmarks: random selection, efficient Fixed designs, and Adaptive Conjoint
Analysis (ACA). We compare polyhedral estimation to Hierarchical Bayes estimation
for each question design method. The simulations evaluate the methods across different
levels of respondent heterogeneity, response accuracy, and numbers of questions. For
low numbers of questions, polyhedral question design does best (or is tied for best) for
all domains. For high numbers of questions, efficient Fixed designs do better in some
domains. The best estimation method depends on respondent heterogeneity and
response accuracy. Polyhedral (analytic center) estimation shows particular promise
for high heterogeneity and/or for low response errors.
The second evaluation employs a large-scale field test. The field test involved 330
respondents, who were randomly assigned to a question-design method and asked to
complete a web-based conjoint exercise. Following the conjoint exercise, respondents
were given 100. We compare the question-design and estimation methods on both internal
validity (holdout tasks) and external validity (actual choice of a laptop bag). The field
test findings are consistent with the simulation results and offer strong support for the
polyhedral question design method. The preferred estimation method varied based on
the question design method, although Hierarchical Bayes estimation consistently
per-formed well in this domain.
The findings reveal a remarkable level of consistency across the validation tasks. They
suggest that the proposed methods are sufficiently promising to justify further
development. At the time of the test, the bags were prototypes. Based, in part, on the
results of this study the bags were launched successfully and are now commercially
available. Sales of the features of the laptop bags were consistent with
conjoint-analysis predictions
The RNA Binding Protein Quaking Regulates Formation of circRNAs
SummaryCircular RNAs (circRNAs), formed by non-sequential back-splicing of pre-mRNA transcripts, are a widespread form of non-coding RNA in animal cells. However, it is unclear whether the majority of circRNAs represent splicing by-products without function or are produced in a regulated manner to carry out specific cellular functions. We show that hundreds of circRNAs are regulated during human epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) and find that the production of over one-third of abundant circRNAs is dynamically regulated by the alternative splicing factor, Quaking (QKI), which itself is regulated during EMT. Furthermore, by modulating QKI levels, we show the effect on circRNA abundance is dependent on intronic QKI binding motifs. Critically, the addition of QKI motifs is sufficient to induce de novo circRNA formation from transcripts that are normally linearly spliced. These findings demonstrate circRNAs are both purposefully synthesized and regulated by cell-type specific mechanisms, suggesting they play specific biological roles in EMT
Dichotomy in the NRT Gene Families of Dicots and Grass Species
A large proportion of the nitrate (NO3â) acquired by plants from soil is actively transported via members of the NRT families of NO3â transporters. In Arabidopsis, the NRT1 family has eight functionally characterised members and predominantly comprises low-affinity transporters; the NRT2 family contains seven members which appear to be high-affinity transporters; and there are two NRT3 (NAR2) family members which are known to participate in high-affinity transport. A modified reciprocal best hit (RBH) approach was used to identify putative orthologues of the Arabidopsis NRT genes in the four fully sequenced grass genomes (maize, rice, sorghum, Brachypodium). We also included the poplar genome in our analysis to establish whether differences between Arabidopsis and the grasses may be generally applicable to monocots and dicots. Our analysis reveals fundamental differences between Arabidopsis and the grass species in the gene number and family structure of all three families of NRT transporters. All grass species possessed additional NRT1.1 orthologues and appear to lack NRT1.6/NRT1.7 orthologues. There is significant separation in the NRT2 phylogenetic tree between NRT2 genes from dicots and grass species. This indicates that determination of function of NRT2 genes in grass species will not be possible in cereals based simply on sequence homology to functionally characterised Arabidopsis NRT2 genes and that proper functional analysis will be required. Arabidopsis has a unique NRT3.2 gene which may be a fusion of the NRT3.1 and NRT3.2 genes present in all other species examined here. This work provides a framework for future analysis of NO3â transporters and NO3â transport in grass crop species
PAM variants in patients with thyrotrophinomas, cyclical Cushingâs disease and prolactinomas
IntroductionGermline loss-of-function variants in PAM, encoding peptidylglycine α-amidating monooxygenase (PAM), were recently discovered to be enriched in conditions of pathological pituitary hypersecretion, specifically: somatotrophinoma, corticotrophinoma, and prolactinoma. PAM is the sole enzyme responsible for C-terminal amidation of peptides, and plays a role in the biosynthesis and regulation of multiple hormones, including proopiomelanocortin (POMC).MethodsWe performed exome sequencing of germline and tumour DNA from 29 individuals with functioning pituitary adenomas (12 prolactinomas, 10 thyrotrophinomas, 7 cyclical Cushingâs disease). An unfiltered analysis was undertaken of all PAM variants with population prevalence <5%.ResultsWe identified five coding, non-synonymous PAM variants of interest amongst seven individuals (six germline, one somatic). The five variants comprised four missense variants and one truncating variant, all heterozygous. Each variant had some evidence of pathogenicity based on population prevalence, conservation scores, in silico predictions and/or prior functional studies. The yield of predicted deleterious PAM variants was thus 7/29 (24%). The variants predominated in individuals with thyrotrophinomas (4/10, 40%) and cyclical Cushingâs disease (2/7, 29%), compared to prolactinomas (1/12, 8%).ConclusionThis is the second study to demonstrate a high yield of suspected loss-of-function, predominantly germline, PAM variants in individuals with pathological pituitary hypersecretion. We have extended the association with corticotrophinoma to include the specific clinical entity of cyclical Cushingâs disease and demonstrated a novel association between PAM variants and thyrotrophinoma. PAM variants might act as risk alleles for pituitary adenoma formation, with a possible genotype-phenotype relationship between truncating variants and altered temporal secretion of cortisol
âOn Managerially Efficient Experimental Designs
In most marketing experiments, managerial decisions are not based directly on the estimates of the parameters but rather on functions of these estimates. For example, many managerial decisions are driven by whether or not a feature is valued more than the price the consumer will be asked to pay. In other cases, some managerial decisions are weighed more heavily than others. The standard measures used to evaluate experimental designs (e.g., -efficiency or -efficiency) do not accommodate these phenomena. We propose alternative âmanagerial efficiencyâ criteria (-errors) that are relatively easy to implement. We explore their properties, suggest practical algorithms to decrease errors, and provide illustrative examples. Realistic examples suggest improvements of as much as 30% in managerial efficiency. We close by considering approximations for nonlinear criteria and extensions to choice-based experiments.conjoint analysis, experimental design, product development, efficiency
- âŠ