Recommendations for reporting ion mobility mass spectrometry measurements

© 2019 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Here we present a guide to ion mobility mass spectrometry experiments, which covers both linear and nonlinear methods: what is measured, how the measurements are done, and how to report the results, including the uncertainties of mobility and collision cross section values. The guide aims to clarify some possibly confusing concepts, and the reporting recommendations should help researchers, authors and reviewers to contribute comprehensive reports, so that the ion mobility data can be reused more confidently. Starting from the concept of the definition of the measurand, we emphasize that (i) mobility values (K0) depend intrinsically on ion structure, the nature of the bath gas, temperature, and E/N; (ii) ion mobility does not measure molecular surfaces directly, but collision cross section (CCS) values are derived from mobility values using a physical model; (iii) methods relying on calibration are empirical (and thus may provide method-dependent results) only if the gas nature, temperature or E/N cannot match those of the primary method. Our analysis highlights the urgency of a community effort toward establishing primary standards and reference materials for ion mobility, and provides recommendations to do so. © 2019 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc

Near-Complete Structural Characterization of Phosphatidylcholines Using Electron Impact Excitation of Ions from Organics

Although lipids are critical components of many cellular assemblies and biological pathways, accurate descriptions of their molecular structures remain difficult to obtain. Many benchtop characterization methods require arduous and time-consuming procedures, and multiple assays are required whenever a new structural feature is probed. Here, we describe a new mass-spectrometry-based workflow for enhanced structural lipidomics that, in a single experiment, can yield almost complete structural information for a given glycerophospholipid (GPL) species. This includes the lipid’s sum (Brutto) composition from the accurate mass measured for the intact lipid ion and the characteristic headgroup fragment, the regioisomer composition from fragment ions unique to the sn-1 and sn-2 positions, and the positions of carbon–carbon double bonds in the lipid acyl chains. Here, lipid ions are fragmented using electron impact excitation of ions from organics (EIEIO)a technique where the singly charged lipid ions are irradiated by an electron beam, producing diagnostic product ions. We have evaluated this methodology on various lipid standards, as well as on a biological extract, to demonstrate this new method’s utility

Probing Electrospray Ionization Dynamics Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry: The Curious Case of 4‑Aminobenzoic Acid

Here, we present the separation of two ions that differ only by the site of protonation of the analyte molecule using differential mobility spectrometry (DMS). Protonated 4-aminobenzoic acid molecules (4-ABA) generated by positive-mode electrospray ionization [ESI­(+)] can exist with the proton residing on either the amine nitrogen (N-protonated) or the carboxylic acid oxygen (O-protonated), and the protonation site can differ on the basis of the solvent system used. In this study, we demonstrate the identification and separation of N- and O-protonated 4-ABA using DMS, with structural assignments verified by: (1) the presence of distinct peaks in the DMS ionogram, (2) the observed effects resulting from altering the ESI­(+) solvent system, (3) the observed ¹³C NMR chemical shifts arising from altering the solvent system, (4) the observation of distinct MS/MS fragmentation patterns for the two DMS-separated ions, (5) the unique hydrogen–deuterium exchange behavior for these ions, and (6) the fundamental behavior of these two ions within the DMS cell, linked back to the structural differences between the two protonated forms

Distinguishing Cis and Trans Isomers in Intact Complex Lipids Using Electron Impact Excitation of Ions from Organics Mass Spectrometry

We present a mass spectrometry-based method for the identification of cis and trans double-bond isomers within intact complex lipid mixtures using electron impact excitation of ions from organics (EIEIO) mass spectrometry. EIEIO involves irradiating singly charged lipid ions with electrons having kinetic energies of 5–16 eV. The resulting EIEIO spectra can be used to discern cis and trans double-bond isomers by virtue of the differences in the fragmentation patterns at the carbon–carbon single bonds neighboring the double bonds. For trans double bonds, these characteristic fragments include unique closed-shell and open-shell (radical) products. To explain this fragmentation pattern in trans double bonds, we have proposed a reaction mechanism involving excitation of the double bond’s π electrons followed by hydrogen atom rearrangement. Several lipid standards were analyzed using the EIEIO method, including mixtures of these standards. Prior to EIEIO, some of the lipid species in these mixtures were separated from their isomeric forms by using differential mobility spectrometry (DMS). For example, mixed cis and trans forms of triacylglycerols and phosphatidylcholines were identified by this DMS–EIEIO workflow. With this combined gas-phase separation and subsequent fragmentation, we could eliminate the need for authentic standards for identification. When DMS could not separate cis and trans isomers completely, as was the case with sphingomyelins, we relied upon the aforementioned diagnostic EIEIO fragment peaks to determine the relative contribution of the trans double-bond isomer in the mixed samples. We also applied the DMS–EIEIO methodology to natural samples extracted from a ruminant (bovine), which serve as common origins of trans fatty acids in a typical Western diet that includes dairy products

Electron Capture Dissociation in a Branched Radio-Frequency Ion Trap

We have developed a high-throughput electron capture dissociation (ECD) device coupled to a quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer using novel branched radio frequency ion trap architecture. With this device, a low-energy electron beam can be injected orthogonally into the analytical ion beam with independent control of both the ion and electron beams. While ions and electrons can interact in a “flow-through” mode, we observed a large enhancement in ECD efficiency by introducing a short ion trapping period at the region of ion and electron beam intersection. This simultaneous trapping mode still provides up to five ECD spectra per second while operating in an information-dependent acquisition workflow. Coupled to liquid chromatography (LC), this LC-ECD workflow provides good sequence coverage for both trypsin and Lys C digests of bovine serum albumin, providing ECD spectra for doubly charged precursor ions with very good efficiency

Characterizing the Tautomers of Protonated Aniline Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry and Mass Spectrometry

The site of protonation for gas-phase aniline has been debated for many years, with many research groups contributing experimental and computational evidence for either the amino-protonated or the <i>para</i>-carbon-protonated tautomer as the gas-phase global minimum structure. Here, we employ differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) and mass spectrometry (MS) to separate and characterize the amino-protonated (N-protonated) and <i>para</i>-carbon-protonated (<i>p</i>-protonated) tautomers of aniline. We demonstrate that upon electrospray ionization (ESI), aniline is protonated predominantly at the amino position. Similar analyses are conducted on another three isotopically labeled forms of aniline to confirm our structural assignments. We observe a significant reduction of the relative population of the <i>p</i>-protonated tautomer when a protic ESI solvent is employed (methanol/water) compared to when an aprotic solvent (acetonitrile) is employed. We also observe conversion of the <i>p</i>-protonated species into the N-protonated species upon clustering with protic solvent vapor post-DMS selectiona finding supported by previous experimental data acquired using DMS-MS

Identifying Fenton-Reacted Trimethoprim Transformation Products Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry

A transformation product of trimethoprim, a contaminant of emerging concern in the environment, is generated using an electro-assisted Fenton reaction and analyzed using differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) in combination with MS/MS techniques and quantum chemical calculations to develop a rapid method for identification. DMS is used as a prefilter to separate positional isomers prior to subsequent identification by mass spectrometric analyses. Collision induced dissociation of each DMS separated species is used to reveal fragmentation patterns that can be correlated to specific isomer structures. Analysis of the experimental data and supporting quantum chemical calculations show that methylene-hydroxylated and methoxy-containing phenyl ring hydroxylated transformation products are observed. The proposed methodology outlines a high-throughput technique to determine transformation products of small molecules accurately, in a short time and requiring minimal sample concentrations (<25 ng/mL)

Direct Interface between Digital Microfluidics and High Performance Liquid Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry

We introduce an automated method to facilitate in-line coupling of digital microfluidics (DMF) with HPLC-MS, using a custom, 3D-printed manifold and a custom plugin to the popular open-source control system, DropBot. The method was designed to interface directly with commercial autosamplers (with no prior modification), suggesting that it will be widely accessible for end-users. The system was demonstrated to be compatible with samples dissolved in aqueous buffers and neat methanol and was validated by application to a common steroid-labeling derivatization reaction. We propose that the methods described here will be useful for a wide range of applications, combining the automated sample processing power of DMF with the resolving and analytical capacity of HPLC-MS

Rapid Characterization of Naphthenic Acids Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry and Mass Spectrometry

To analyze the naphthenic acid content of environmental waters quickly and efficiently, we have developed a method that employs differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS). This technique combines the benefits of infusion-based MS experiments (parallel, on-demand access to individual components) with DMS’s ability to provide liquid chromatography-like separations of isobaric and isomeric compounds in a fraction of the time. In this study, we have applied a DMS-MS workflow to the rapid gas-phase separation of naphthenic acids (NAs) within a technical standard and a real-world oil sands process-affected water (OSPW) extract. Among the findings provided by this workflow are the rapid characterization of isomeric NAs (i.e., same molecular formulas) in a complex OSPW sample, the ability to use DMS to isolate individual NA components (including isomeric NAs) for in-depth structural analyses, and a method by which NA analytes, background ions, and dimer species can be characterized by their distinct behaviors in DMS. Overall, the profiles of the NA content of the technical and OSPW samples were consistent with published values for similar samples, such that the benefits of DMS technology do not detract from the workflow’s accuracy or quality

Direct Interface between Digital Microfluidics and High Performance Liquid Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry

We introduce an automated method to facilitate in-line coupling of digital microfluidics (DMF) with HPLC-MS, using a custom, 3D-printed manifold and a custom plugin to the popular open-source control system, DropBot. The method was designed to interface directly with commercial autosamplers (with no prior modification), suggesting that it will be widely accessible for end-users. The system was demonstrated to be compatible with samples dissolved in aqueous buffers and neat methanol and was validated by application to a common steroid-labeling derivatization reaction. We propose that the methods described here will be useful for a wide range of applications, combining the automated sample processing power of DMF with the resolving and analytical capacity of HPLC-MS