Benchmarking of FDM Machines through Part Quality Using IT Grades

The diffusion of Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) was recently boosted by the expiration of the FDM patent and the subsequent worldwide development of low cost FDM machines by a huge number of small companies. In most of the cases, FDM machines are worth what they cost. Thus the performance of expensive industrial FDM systems is better than that of low cost machines, also known as 3D printers. In this paper a benchmarking is carried out between a Dimension EliteTM by Stratasys and a 3D TouchTM by Bits from Bytes (BFB). The study and comparison is based on a reference part that was designed to fit into the building volume of most of low cost FDM machines. The part includes several classic geometries (planes, cylinders, spheres and cones) of different sizes to cover several ranges of basic sizes as defined by the ISO 286 standard. Geometric features appear both in the concave and convex shapes to account for all design possibilities. The proposed reference part allows to consider a higher number of features for each range of basic sizes with respect to other benchmarking models presented in the literature. Moreover the part does not require support structures for its production, allowing for manufacturing on 3D printers that come with a unique extruder. Replicas of the reference part are printed out of ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene) material with different layer thicknesses using the compared machines. After inspecting the replicas by means of a Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM), the dimensional accuracy of the compared FDM systems is reported through part quality using IT grades associated with the ISO basic sizes. GD&T values are also evaluated for some of the geometric features appearing on the reference part

Evaluation of the flexural behaviour of 3D printed multimaterial beams

Among Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes, Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM), more popularly renown as 3D printing1, allows the fabrication of multimaterial parts by extrusion of multiple thermoplastic filaments that are then deposited layer after layer. In such a way parts are built bottom to top and the different materials can be deployed in each cross section according to strategies aiming at optimizing the reinforcement through the exploitation of the design freedom of AM technologies. Most diffused commercial materials for FDM are Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) and the biodegradable PolyLactic Acid (PLA), that are amorphous polymers characterized by similar mechanical properties. The use of semicrystalline polymers in FDM is often avoided because of the higher amount of shrinkage which causes the warpage of the deployed layers during manufacturing. The innovative aspect of this paper is the use of a filament made of a Polyammide (PA) blend as a reinforcement in multimaterial beams of PLA that are fabricated by FDM. The flexural behaviour of the composite beams is evaluated by three point bending tests according to the ASTM D790 method. Owing to the lack of a specific reference for 3D printing, dimensions of the specimens are assumed equal to those of injection molded specimens. Their nominal overall dimensions are 3.25 x 12.7 x 127 mm. In this preliminary study, test specimens are 3D printed with a core of PA having a rectangular cross section, whose width (w) and height (h) are varied. Bending tests show that the PA core increases both the flexural stiffness and the flexural strength of the PLA beam. Experimental results are compared with those of the finite element (FE) simulation of the bending test performed by using Abaqus/CAE software. 3D printing issues are also considered and discussed along with the influence of the layer by layer fabrication on the beam resistance

Impact of additive manufacturing on engineering education – evidence from Italy

Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to evaluate how the direct access to additive manufacturing (AM) systems impacts on education of future mechanical engineers, within a Master's program at a top Italian University. Design/methodology/approach - A survey is specifically designed to assess the relevance of entry-level AM within the learning environment, as a tool for project development. The survey is distributed anonymously to three consecutive cohorts of students who attended the course of "computer-aided production (CAP)", within the Master of Science Degree in Mechanical Engineering at Politecnico di Torino. The course includes a practical project, consisting in the design of a polymeric product with multiple components and ending with the production of an assembled prototype. The working assembly is fabricated by the students themselves, who operate a fused deposition modelling (FDM) machine, finish the parts and evaluate assemblability and functionality. The post-course survey covers diverse aspects of the learning process, such as: motivation, knowledge acquisition, new abilities and team-working skills. Responses are analyzed to evaluate students' perception of the usefulness of additive technologies in learning product design and development. Among the projects, one representative case study is selected and discussed. Findings - Results of the research affirm a positive relationship of access to AM devices to perceived interest, motivation and ease of learning of mechanical engineering. Entry-level additive technologies offer a hands-on experience within academia, fostering the acquisition of technical knowledge. Research limitations/implications - The survey is distributed to more than 200 students to cover the full population of the CAP course over three academic years. The year the students participated in the CAP course is not tracked because the instructor was the same and there were no administrative differences. For this reason, the survey administration might be a limitation of the current study. In addition to this, no gender distinction is made because historically, the percentage of female students in Mechanical Engineering courses is about 10 per cent or lower. Although the answers to the survey are anonymous, only 37 per cent of the students gave a feedback. Thus, on the one hand, impact assessment is limited to a sample of about one-third of the complete population, but, on the other hand, the anonymity ensures randomization in the sample selection. Practical implications - Early exposure of forthcoming designers to AM tools can turn into a "think-additive" approach to product design, that is a groundbreaking conception of geometries and product functionalities, leading to the full exploitation of the possibilities offered by additive technologies. Social implications - Shared knowledge can act as a springboard for mass adoption of AM processes. Originality/value - The advantages of adopting AM technologies at different levels of education, for diverse educational purposes and disciplines, are well assessed in the literature. The innovative aspect of this paper is that the impact of AM is evaluated through a feedback coming directly from mechanical engineering students

Experimental analysis of residual stresses on AlSi10Mg parts produced by means of Selective Laser Melting (SLM)

Abstract During the Selective Laser Melting (SLM) process, the scanned layers are subjected to rapid thermal cycles. Steep temperature gradients generate residual stresses. Residual stresses can be detrimental to the proper functioning and the structural integrity of built parts. In this paper, the semi-destructive hole-drilling method has been used to measure the residual stresses on AISi10Mg parts after building, stress relieving and shot-peening, respectively. The outcomes have shown the presence, on the as-built components, of high tensile stresses that the usual post-processing operations are not able to minimize. The adopted method has proved to be a suitable tool to identify optimal process parameters for each step of the production cycle

Comparison of dimensional tolerance grades for metal AM processes

Each manufacturing process produces geometric features with some dimensional errors from the ideal nominal geometry. The knowledge of the dimensional tolerances associated with the specific fabrication process is fundamental for choosing the proper sequence of finishing operations to meet the design requirements. While the ranges of dimensional tolerances for traditional manufacturing processes are well mapped in the literature, a little information is available for additive manufacturing (AM) techniques. In this paper, a benchmarking analysis is carried out between two different AM processes for metals and the dimensional accuracy of each AM machine is defined using the ISO IT grades of a reference artifact

An investigation of the influence of 3d printing defects on the tensile performance of ABS material

Recently, the popularity of 3d printing for industrial and consumer use has spread across many different sectors. For this reason, quality assurance of 3d printed parts is becoming increasingly important. The extrusion and layer-by-layer deposition of a polymer filament on the print bed can introduce defects such as pores and voids into the internal structure of 3d printed parts. The relation between 3d printing defects and tensile performance of 3d printed samples is studied in this paper. The study considers tensile specimens of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) that were 3d printed by varying the infill strategy and percentage to simulate different levels of strength for the part. Before the tensile tests, the ABS samples were inspected by X-ray tomography to identify the presence of internal voids generated by the 3d printing process. For each sample, data and statistics about the internal defects were used for determining a relation with the tensile test results. The local deformation of the sample and the position of the final fracture were observed using a digital camera and digital image correlation (DIC). In most cases, the experimental results confirmed the matching between the presence of internal voids and the areas of high deformation. However, the position of the specimen fracture did not always coincide with the largest defects. Nevertheless, this study highlights the importance of non-destructive inspection in quality assurance of 3d printed parts when in-situ monitoring of the 3d printing process is not applied. Copyright (C) 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the Third International Conference on Aspects of Materials Science and Engineering

An investigation of the influence of 3d printing parameters on the tensile strength of PLA material

Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM), also known as 3d printing, is one of the most widespread Additive Manufacturing (AM) technologies based on the extrusion of a thermoplastic filament. This layerwise technology allows lightweight products to be built using different infill strategies and percentages. Furthermore, by varying other parameters, such as temperature, printing speed or layer thickness, it is possible to obtain components with different characteristics. Polylactic Acid (PLA) is one of the cheapest and most sustainable materials for 3d printing because it is a biobased and biodegradable plastic. Its use in 3D printing is widely spread among hobbyists and in the communities, such as the ones of Fablabs or the Makers movement.Nevertheless, to reduce the number of uncompliant parts that may fail into operation since they do not meet the expectations of the user, it is important to know in advance the mechanical performance that different 3d printing strategies can ensure for PLA parts.In this paper, Design of Experiment (DOE) is applied to investigate how main 3D printing parameters influence the tensile strength of PLA products. For this purpose, a 3x3 factorial plane with one replication was constructed and used for 3d printing tensile specimens of PLA Tough material using a Makerbot Replicator machine. The tensile test results show that the layer thickness is more significant than the infill percentage for the resistance of PLA products. A regression model is also proposed to allow the user to predict the ultimate tensile strength of PLA products depending on the values of those two parameters.Copyright (c) 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the Third International Conference on Aspects of Materials Science and Engineering

Additive manufacturing redesigning of metallic parts for high precision machines

The conventional approach to design and manufacturing often has geometries with an efficient material distribution. For the high-precision machines, that approach involves the design of heavy components that guarantees the stiffness requirements. However, the higher the weight of the part, the higher inertia it has. As a result, when the feed axes are accelerated, the inertial forces deform the machine components and the precision of the machine is reduced. This study investigated the designing for additive manufacturing (DfAM) and designing for assembly (DfA) to increase the material efficiency of components for high-precision applications. A new methodology which considered the design and manufacturing issues and machining as well is given. A comprehensive model for cost evaluation of the part is presented. The case study refers to the rails and the bracket that support and move the flying probe of a testing machine for microelectromechanical systems (MEMS). The weight of the rails has been decreased by 32% and the components to be assembled have been reduced from 16 to 7. The optimized bracket is more than 50% stiffer than the original one, 10% lighter, and economically competitive