195 research outputs found
Critical Psychiatry
Critical psychiatry appraises and comments upon psychiatric services as they are usually provided. This article,
prompted by the publication of a recent book, considers the place of critical psychiatry historically and in the context
of contemporary mental health care and treatment
Critical Psychiatry
Critical psychiatry appraises and comments upon psychiatric services as they are usually provided. This article,
prompted by the publication of a recent book, considers the place of critical psychiatry historically and in the context
of contemporary mental health care and treatment
New ways of working in acute inpatient care: a case for change
This position paper focuses on the current tensions
and challenges of aligning inpatient care with
innovations in mental health services. It argues that a
cultural shift is required within inpatient services.
Obstacles to change including traditional perceptions
of the role and responsibilities of the psychiatrist are
discussed. The paper urges all staff working in acute
care to reflect on the service that they provide, and
to consider how the adoption of new ways of
working might revolutionise the organisational
culture. This cultural shift offers inpatient staff the
opportunity to fully utilise their expertise. New ways
of working may be perceived as a threat to existing
roles and responsibilities or as an exciting opportunity
for professional development with increased job
satisfaction. Above all, the move to new ways of
working, which is gathering pace throughout the UK,
could offer service users1 a quality of care that meets
their needs and expectations
Sociological conceptions of happiness and its implications for psychotherapy and public policy
This paper critiques the usefulness of cognitive-behavioural therapy, which is often seen as a means of redressing the loss of community and friendship networks within society. Therapy in this context they runs the danger of becoming an Iatrogenesis at worst and just another `technology of mood’ at best. In this paper we develop the critiques made elsewhere and provide a more nuanced argument that considers a wider range of psychological therapies. While all psychological therapies operate at an individual level, there are wide differences in the epistemological stances taken by differing therapeutic schools. Cognitive-behavioural therapy focuses on the idea of dysfunctional thinking within the individual, psychoanalytic therapy focuses upon developmental legacies, whereas person-centred therapy focuses on currently active social influences. In this form one to one therapy can be a route to change which is compatible with our sociological critique. However, the broader criticism that psychological therapies attempt to compensate for breakdowns in friendship and social networks remains. Furthermore reviews of psychotherapeutic outcome data and qualitative enquiry both point to the experience of authentic relationship rather than psychotherapeutic technique as the major determinant of outcome. Preventing social dislocation rather than trying to repair it post hoc should be the goal. This would beg a wider range of questions such as; what does social isolation actually mean in contemporary western society and what does this mean for people with mental health problems in particular? What are the various ways in which social networks provide support functions and what may be missing in an individual’s life and then what can be done to try and compensate for that lack
A Utilitarian Perspective of Social and Medical Contributions to Three Illustrative Conditions, and Recent UK NHS Policy Initiatives
Background: To date debate concerning the relative merits of social and medical sciences has been
largely academic.
Aims: To outline and critically appraise a utilitarian approach to mental health research that reflects a
critical realist perspective.
Method: Consideration of the relative utility of differing approaches to illustrative ‘‘psychiatric’’
disorders, and recent policy initiatives.
Results: Socially relevant outcomes of Bipolar Affective Disorder are determined by influences that
operate independently of the characteristic instability of mood. There is now a highly specific and
effective psychological treatment for Panic Disorder. Its benefits are still not fully exploited because of
continuing lay and professional focus upon the condition’s social manifestations. Great numbers of
people presenting in primary care are unhelpfully caused to adopt the role of ‘‘patient’’ due to practices
limiting the professional response to a medical one. Such practices reflect public and professional
perceptions of the nature of ‘‘mental health difficulties’’ much more than they do the achievements of
medicine. Recent policy-supporting initiatives influencing UK NHS mental health services are much
more likely to be supported by social sciences than by medical research.
Conclusions: There is considerable scope for a contribution to applied mental health research from
frameworks and methodologies that are rooted in a social sciences perspective
Approaches to “mental health” in low-income countries: a case study of Uganda
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to explore the ways in which “mental health” difficulties are approached in low-income countries, using a case study of Uganda focus down upon the issues.
Design/methodology/approach – The study involved two phases. The first was the collection and analysis of documentary evidence and interviews with policy makers in Uganda. The second involved interviews with health staff, traditional healers and the public in the Buganda Kingdom of Uganda. Interviews were conducted in English or Luganda and translated as necessary. No external sources of funding to declare.
Findings – There are differing perceptions of mental health and illness in Uganda and there exists culturally accepted sources of support for distress. This highlights the important role of traditional healers and the paper argues that they should be recognised for their work in mental health care.
Research limitations/implications – The paper is a small-scale study of one area of Uganda (Buganda Kingdom), the extent to which it can be generalised is therefore very limited. However, the research is sufficient to indicate the benefits of traditional healers in mental health care and supports an argument towards a public mental health model.
Practical implications – The paper argues for a move in priority away from a focus upon a biomedical model of mental health support towards a public health model and the meaningful engagement of traditional healers. This would also necessitate a refocus of spending in the wider society.
Originality/value – The paper poses a challenge to the Global Public Health movement and questions the relevance of expanding biomedical psychiatry in low-income countries. The paper also adds weight to emerging literature on the value of a public health approach to mental health and illness, especially in the developing world
A Letter of Consequence: Referral Letters from General Practitioners to Secondary Mental Health Services
The referral letter is a key instrument in moving patients from primary to secondary care services. Consequently, the circumstances in which a referral should be made and its contents have been the subject of clinical guidelines. This article is based on a project that demonstrated
that physicians do not adhere to clinical guidelines when referring patients to secondary mental health services. This research supports earlier findings into noncompliance
with guidelines by general practitioners (GPs). The authors briefly note possible reasons, which have been the subject of some debate. They also present a content analysis of referral letters to demonstrate the important ways in which they differ from guideline criteria. However, their central argument is that the role of the referral letter in relation to the GP’s repertoire of treatments has not been understood fully. Such understanding implies the need for a reexamination of the support available for GPs
- …