Comprehensive assessment of shallow surf zone fish biodiversity requires a combination of sampling methods

Surf zones of sandy beaches are crucial environments for numerous fishes but one of the most challenging habitats when it comes to sampling, due to high-energy currents and waves. In this study, we compared the efficiency of 2 methods currently used to sample the biodiversity of shallow surf zone fish communities: the traditional method of beach seine nets and the more recently introduced surf zone Baited Remote Underwater Video Stations (surf-BRUVS). We applied both sampling strategies at 67 sites along 27 sandy beaches with different environmental characteristics in southeastern Brazil. We compared overall abundance, species richness, and beta (turnover) and functional trait diversity recorded from both methods. Our results showed that seine nets captured a higher species richness, greater abundance, greater functional richness and more functionally singular species than surf-BRUVS, particularly in areas with low wave energy. Beta diversity analyses, however, showed a clear difference in assemblage composition detected by each method regardless of environmental conditions, mainly driven by species turnover and variations in abundance. Only seine nets captured small species (&lt;10 cm total length), while surf-BRUVS were more effective in recording larger species. Our results suggest that shallow surf zone assemblages sampled with surf-BRUVS and beach seine nets are almost totally taxonomically and highly functionally divergent, and the application of both methods provides complementary results. Additionally, the non-extractive nature of surf-BRUVS presents an opportunity for sampling vulnerable areas or species. However, when using a single method, researchers should take into consideration each method’s biases and be aware that biodiversity may be underestimated for certain groups.</jats:p

Benthic Estuarine Assemblages of the Southeastern Brazil Marine Ecoregion (SBME)

We assess the current knowledge of the benthic assemblages in the Southeastern Brazil Marine Ecoregion (SBME), which extends for approximately 1200 km of coastline and includes seven major estuarine systems from Guanabara Bay in Rio de Janeiro to Babitonga Bay (or Sao Francisco do Sul) in Santa Catarina. The high ecosystem diversity of SBME putatively accounts for the high levels of endemism of the regional marine invertebrate fauna. However, until more taxonomical and biogeographical evidence is available, the SBME should be treated as a working biogeographical hypothesis rather than a cohesive unit identified by endemic fauna. As a consequence of urban, agricultural, and industrial development, the coastal areas from the SBME have been the most altered in the country over the last 500 years. Some of the largest cities and busiest harbors of the country are in or near the regional estuarine areas. The rapid environmental changes over the last several decades do not allow for the assessment if current similarities and dissimilarities in the benthic assemblages express pristine conditions or if they are already the result of major human interventions, especially in the case of the Guanabara, Sepetiba, and Santos estuaries.Univ Fed Parana, Ctr Estudos Mar, Pontal Do Sul, Parana, BrazilUniv Fed Sao Paulo, Inst Mar, Santos, SP, BrazilUniv Catolica Norte, Millennium Nucleus Ecol & Sustainable Management, Fac Ciencias Mar, Dept Biol Marina, Coquimbo, ChileUniv Estadual Paulista, Inst Biociencias, Campus Litoral Paulista, Sao Vicente, SP, BrazilUniv Fed Fluminense, Dept Biol Marinha, Campus Valonguinho, Niteroi, RJ, BrazilUniv Estadual Paulista, Inst Biociencias, Campus Litoral Paulista, Sao Vicente, SP, Brazi