31 research outputs found
The Contemporary Deconstruction of Religion: How Current Scholarship in Religious Studies is Changing Methods and Theories
My paper has 3 goals: 1) to introduce and outline the field of âcritical religionâ; 2) to set out my contribution to this field by explaining how and why religions should be considered âvestigial statesâ; and 3) to suggest ways in which the approach to the topic of religious synthesis in India might be influenced by critical religion in general and vestigial state theory in particular. I argue that âreligionâ as an ahistorical, eternal, indefinable category âwhat Roland Barthes called âdepoliticizedâ speech âwarrants energetic critique. To this end, I survey a variety of theorists whose work deconstructs âreligionâ and attendant binaries such as religious/secular and religion/politics. I maintain that religions function as vestigial states within contemporary states. By âvestigial statesâ I mean practices and institutions originating in particular histories as survivals of former sovereignties. These remnants are tolerated as attenuated jurisdictions within fully functioning states. These vestigial states (religions) are always somewhat problematic because they compete with contemporary states - especially if they challenge the present stateâs right to control violence. However, religions also work to ground the governments that authorize them by recalling earlier, mystified forms of sovereignty. Moreover, religions are useful because they can be depicted as less progressive versions of power. Thus do âreligionsâ, understood as vestigial states, both disturb and maintain current regimes. I conclude with some speculations on how insights derived from critical religion might impact work on conceptualizing âreligious synthesisâ in India specifically and âinterreligiousâ interactions more generally in a global context
âReligionâ and its limits: reflections on discursive borders and boundaries
Joint JISASR-JBASR Special IssueThe keynote contributes to critical analysis of religion and attendant
categories by proposing that religions be understood as vestigial states. According
to this hypothesis, religion is a modern discursive product that is not present in the
Bible. The category evolves as a management strategy, a technology of statecraft to
contain and control conquered, colonized and/or marginalized populations as an
alternative to genocide. Examples are drawn from Greek mythology, Jewish and
Druid history and recent Buddhist politics. The author uses texts pertaining to
international law and political philosophy to argue that viewing religion as
synonymous with displaced, uneasy, former government opposes male hegemony
by revealing the political structure of mystified nostalgia for male leadership. She
also maintains that understanding religions as restive governments promotes
clarity in regard to contemporary conflicts between religious freedom and equality
rights. Psychoanalytic theories of Sigmund Freud, Melanie Klein and Wilfrid Bion
are cited to support the disassembling of foundational terms of Religious Studies
The Divine Masquerade - A Psychoanalytic Theory about the Play of Gender in Religion
The argument I am advancing in this lecture is composed of three interlocking parts: the first is a methodological reflection about the relationship of psychoanalysis and religion; the second is a discussion about gender and religion in the context of Freud's theory of theism followed by an update inspired by the work of Nancy Chodorow; and the third is an application of Melanic Klein's concepts of envy and jealousy to traditional religions and the contemporary women's spirituality movement
Your fi&
copies of this thesis in microform, paper or electronic formats. The author retains ownership of the copyright in this thesis. Neither the thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it may be printed or otherwise reproduced without the author's permission. L'auteur a accordĂ© une licence non exclusive permettant Ă la BibliothĂšque nationale du Canada de reproduire, prĂȘter, distribuer ou vendre des copies de cette thĂšse sous la fome de microfiche/film, de reproduction sur papier ou sur forma