School Quality, Educational Attainment and Aggregation Bias

Data from 31 countries participating in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) is used to estimate education production functions for reading literacy.The analysis suggests that the probability of finding statistically significant and correctly signed class size effects increases the higher the level of aggregation used to measure class size.Class size, PISA data, bias

Probing Vortex Unbinding via Dipole Fluctuations

We develop a numerical method for detecting a vortex unbinding transition in a two-dimensional system by measuring large scale fluctuations in the total vortex dipole moment ${\vec P}$ of the system. These are characterized by a quantity $\cal F$ which measures the number of configurations in a simulation for which the either $P_x$ or $P_y$ is half the system size. It is shown that $\cal F$ tends to a non-vanishing constant for large system sizes in the unbound phase, and vanishes in the bound phase. The method is applied to the XY model both in the absence and presence of a magnetic field. In the latter case, the system size dependence of $\cal F$ suggests that there exist three distinct phases, one unbound vortex phase, a logarithmically bound phase, and a linearly bound phase.Comment: 6 pages, 2 figure

The motif problem

Fix a choice and ordering of four pairwise non-adjacent vertices of a parallelepiped, and call a motif a sequence of four points in R^3 that coincide with these vertices for some, possibly degenerate, parallelepiped whose edges are parallel to the axes. We show that a set of r points can contain at most r^2 motifs. Generalizing the notion of motif to a sequence of L points in R^p, we show that the maximum number of motifs that can occur in a point set of a given size is related to a linear programming problem arising from hypergraph theory, and discuss some related questions.Comment: 17 pages, 1 figur

Band topology and quantum spin Hall effect in bilayer graphene

We consider bilayer graphene in the presence of spin orbit coupling, to assess its behavior as a topological insulator. The first Chern number $n$ for the energy bands of single and bilayer graphene is computed and compared. It is shown that for a given valley and spin, $n$ in a bilayer is doubled with respect to the monolayer. This implies that bilayer graphene will have twice as many edge states as single layer graphene, which we confirm with numerical calculations and analytically in the case of an armchair terminated surface. Bilayer graphene is a weak topological insulator, whose surface spectrum is susceptible to gap opening under spin-mixing perturbations. We also assess the stability of the associated topological bulk state of bilayer graphene under various perturbations. Finally, we consider an intermediate situation in which only one of the two layers has spin orbit coupling, and find that although individual valleys have non-trivial Chern numbers, the spectrum as a whole is not gapped, so that the system is not a topological insulator.Comment: 9 pages. 9 figures include

Collective charge density fluctuations in superconducting layered systems with bilayer unit cells

Collective modes of bilayered superconducting superlattices (e.g., YBCO) are investigated within the conserving gauge-invariant ladder diagram approximation including both the nearest interlayer single electron tunneling and the Josephson-type Cooper pair tunneling. By calculating the density-density response function including Coulomb and pairing interactions, we examine the two collective mode branches corresponding to the in-phase and out-of-phase charge fluctuations between the two layers in the unit cell. The out-of-phase collective mode develops a long wavelength plasmon gap whose magnitude depends on the tunneling strength with the mode dispersions being insensitive to the specific tunneling mechanism (i.e., single electron or Josephson). We also show that in the presence of tunneling the oscillator strength of the out-of-phase mode overwhelms that of the in-phase-mode at $k_{\|} = 0$ and finite $k_z$, where $k_z$ and $k_{\|}$ are respectively the mode wave vectors perpendicular and along the layer. We discuss the possible experimental observability of the phase fluctuation modes in the context of our theoretical results for the mode dispersion and spectral weight.Comment: 9 pages, 3 figure

Theory of Phonon Shakeup Effects on Photoluminescence from the Wigner Crystal in a Strong Magnetic Field

We develop a method to compute shakeup effects on photoluminescence from a strong magnetic field induced two-dimensional Wigner crystal. Only localized holes are considered. Our method treats the lattice electrons and the tunneling electron on an equal footing, and uses a quantum-mechanical calculation of the collective modes that does not depend in any way on a harmonic approximation. We find that shakeup produces a series of sidebands that may be identified with maxima in the collective mode density of states, and definitively distinguishes the crystal state from a liquid state in the absence of electron-hole interaction. In the presence of electron-hole interaction, sidebands also appear in the liquid state coming from short-range density fluctuations around the hole. However, the sidebands in the liquid state and the crystal state have different qualitative behaviors. We also find a shift in the main luminescence peak, that is associated with lattice relaxation in the vicinity of a vacancy. The relationship of the shakeup spectrum with previous mean-field calculations is discussed.Comment: 14 pages, uuencoded postscript file for entire paper, also available at (click phd14) http://rainbow.uchicago.edu/~ldz/paper/paper.htm

Collective Modes of Quantum Hall Stripes

The collective modes of striped phases in a quantum Hall system are computed using the time-dependent Hartree-Fock approximation. Uniform stripe phases are shown to be unstable to the formation of modulations along the stripes, so that within the Hartree-Fock approximation the groundstate is a stripe crystal. Such crystalline states are generically gapped at any finite wavevector; however, in the quantum Hall system the interactions of modulations among different stripes is found to be remarkably weak, leading to an infinite collection of collective modes with immeasurably small gaps. The resulting long wavelength behavior is derivable from an elastic theory for smectic liquid crystals. Collective modes for the phonon branch are computed throughout the Brillouin zone, as are spin wave and magnetoplasmon modes. A soft mode in the phonon spectrum is identified for partial filling factors sufficiently far from 1/2, indicating a second order phase transition. The modes contain several other signatures that should be experimentally observable.Comment: 36 pages LaTex with 11 postscript figures. Short animations of the collective modes can be found at http://www.physique.usherb.ca/~rcote/stripes/stripes.ht

Dynamics of quantum Hall stripes in double-quantum-well systems

The collective modes of stripes in double layer quantum Hall systems are computed using the time-dependent Hartree-Fock approximation. It is found that, when the system possesses spontaneous interlayer coherence, there are two gapless modes, one a phonon associated with broken translational invariance, the other a pseudospin-wave associated with a broken U(1) symmetry. For large layer separations the modes disperse weakly for wavevectors perpendicular to the stripe orientation, indicating the system becomes akin to an array of weakly coupled one-dimensional XY systems. At higher wavevectors the collective modes develop a roton minimum associated with a transition out of the coherent state with further increasing layer separation. A spin wave model of the system is developed, and it is shown that the collective modes may be described as those of a system with helimagnetic ordering.Comment: 16 pages including 7 postscript figure