Can mood disorder in women with breast cancer be identified preoperatively?

The Hospital Anxiety and Depression (HAD) scale, a self-report questionnaire, was tested as a method of identifying mood disorder among patients with operable breast cancer during the year after diagnosis. In a cohort of 91 patients anxiety and depression were assessed preoperatively, and at 3 and 12 months post-operatively, using a standardised psychiatric interview and diagnostic rating criteria. The patients also completed the HAD scale at each assessment. Fifty out of 91 (55%) patients were full or borderline cases of depression and/or anxiety at one or more assessment points. Using a receiver operator characteristic curve analysis, the optimum threshold for the preoperative HAD scale total score to identify psychiatric disorder either preoperatively or at 3 and 12 months post-operatively was 11. With this threshold 70% of both full and borderline cases occurring at any of the assessment points were correctly identified. The false-positive rate was 12%. This approach was particularly sensitive to full cases, correctly identifying 90% of them. The potential for the preoperative HAD scale total score to identify mood disorder in the year after diagnosis was influenced by age. Among women aged less than 50 years, a preoperative HAD scale total score > or = 11 provided a highly sensitive indicator of mood disorder (full and borderline cases) at any time in the year after diagnosis (sensitivity = 90%). The false-positive rate was 40%. Among women older than 50 who experienced a mood disorder, only 57% were correctly identified by a HAD scale total score of > or = 11 (sensitivity = 57%). However, the false-positive rate among older women was low (3%). This simple preoperative screening approach can be used to identify patients who have or are at high risk of developing severe mood disorder in the year after diagnosis. The HAD scale is also sensitive to the detection of borderline mood disorder in patients under the age of 50. It is a specific screening tool among patients over 50, but is not sensitive to the detection of borderline mood disorder in this age group

Time trends in breast cancer survival: experience in a single centre, 1975-89.

The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to investigate whether survival of patients with breast cancer has changed over the period 1975-89. A total of 2604 women diagnosed as having invasive breast cancer at a clinical oncology unit in London were followed up for between 5 and 20 years. Patients were divided into four groups according to menstrual status (pre or post) and the staging of cancer (operable or inoperable). For each group, survival from diagnosis was compared between three consecutive 5-year cohorts, both with and without adjustments made for relevant prognostic factors. No temporal patterns were found in patients with inoperable cancer, in whom the survival rate was consistently low. Of women with operable cancers, differences were seen only among post-menopausal women, for whom the best survival patterns were seen in patients diagnosed between 1985-89. This is probably due to tamoxifen being commonly prescribed as adjuvant treatment for this cohort of patients. We cannot explain an apparently worse survival in the group of patients presenting in the early 1980s compared with that observed in the late 1970s