Challenges Related to Probabilistic Decision Analysis for Bridge Testing and Reclassification

This paper reviews historical developments and recent challenges in full scale bridge testing and introduces results- and hypotheses related to an ongoing bridge testing research project. This research project encompasses full scale bridge testing in conjunction with bearing capacity analysis as well as related contact- and non-contact monitoring procedures combined with a decision analytical approach. Results from the first steps of the project, focusing on full scale load testing of bridges, are presented. The next part approaches the interfaces between three project areas namely the bearing capacity analysis, the utilization of monitoring procedures and a decision analytical approach. The proposed probabilistic decision analysis approach is described for two scenarios: (1) The decision support for the actual proof load test providing decision rules for a safe and efficient in-situ test and (2) for the identification of efficient strategies for the bridge reclassification accounting for modeling, simulation, and monitoring information. The paper concludes with a summary highlighting deemed challenges in the used approaches

Reliability-Based Proof Load Factors for Assessment of Bridges

Advanced reliability assessment can be required when evaluating existing bridge structures through proof load testing. The target load of a proof load test typically requires input from resistance models; however, bridges with a low documentation level are often the most relevant for proof load testing, and resistance models thus involve significant uncertainties. This paper presents a different approach to proof loading and target proof load, in which the resistance model is not included in the determination of this load. Instead, the target proof load is determined based on load models coupled to the desired target failure probability, thus ensuring sufficient safety of the existing bridge. The method is in line with the proposal for a new Eurocode on assessment of existing structures and is deemed to be superior to existing approaches. An essential assumption of the method is that monitoring systems can identify stop criteria before irreversible damage occurs. The approach was applied in a case study, where an OT-slab bridge with a span of 6.5 m was proof-load-tested and reclassified for capacity upgrading of a road stretch in Denmark