Comparative Analysis of Thermal Energy Storage Performance in District Heating Networks: Evaluating the Impact of Different Injection Systems

A primary objective of contemporary district heating (DH) networks is to minimize the use of primary energy, especially fossil fuels, for meeting the heating demands of grid customers. In this context, thermal energy storages (TESs) serve as crucial devices, facilitating the decoupling of grid demand from heat generation. This study presents an experimental comparison of three large-scale TESs, each employing distinct injection and extraction systems. The performance of these were examined based on data collected over a consistent two-month operational period, enabling a quantitative comparison. The TESs under scrutiny, located in the DH networks of Milan and Brescia in Northern Italy, each have a capacity of a few thousand cubic meters of water and differ in their injection system and shape ratio. Notably, the evolution and thickness of the thermocline and the percentage of energy waste were examined to discern the impact of the injection system, specifically the presence of a flow-straightening device, and the shape ratio on the performance of the TES systems. These characteristics were found to significantly influence energy waste in heat storage, which ranged from 1.56% to 6.50% of the total stored energy, depending on the specific TES tank under consideration

Design of a 5th Generation District Heating Substation Prototype for a Real Case Study

The evolution of district heating networks is moving toward low temperatures in heat distribution with so called 4th generation networks. However, the lowest heat transfer fluid temperatures in district heating are achieved through ultra-low temperature networks, referred to as 5th generation district heating networks (5GDHNs). Low temperatures in heat distribution results in an extremely different configuration of 5GDHN compared to traditional district heating network, especially in the grid substation due to the inability to directly couple the grid with the buildings. This paper presents a detailed design of a 5th generation substation prototype, which is carried out to verify the proper operation and monitor the performance of this type of substation in a real case study. The prototype is fed by low-temperature waste heat, currently dissipated through evaporative towers, and will be built in the city of Brescia, Italy. The layout of the substation prototype, consisting of a bidirectional pumping system, a reversible water-to-water heat pump, an inertial thermal energy storage and a heat exchanger, is presented. An analysis is performed to figure out which refrigerant offers the best performance of the heat pump. In addition, fixed the refrigerant, the performance of the grid connected heat pump is found to be increased from 29.5% to 55.5% for both heating and cooling compared with a stand-alone air-to-water heat pump solution. Finally, the process flow diagram and the piping and instrumentation diagram of the substation are presented and commented

Design of a 5th Generation District Heating Substation Prototype for a Real Case Study

The evolution of district heating networks is moving toward low temperatures in heat distribution with so called 4th generation networks. However, the lowest heat transfer fluid temperatures in district heating are achieved through ultra-low temperature networks, referred to as 5th generation district heating networks (5GDHNs). Low temperatures in heat distribution results in an extremely different configuration of 5GDHN compared to traditional district heating network, especially in the grid substation due to the inability to directly couple the grid with the buildings. This paper presents a detailed design of a 5th generation substation prototype, which is carried out to verify the proper operation and monitor the performance of this type of substation in a real case study. The prototype is fed by low-temperature waste heat, currently dissipated through evaporative towers, and will be built in the city of Brescia, Italy. The layout of the substation prototype, consisting of a bidirectional pumping system, a reversible water-to-water heat pump, an inertial thermal energy storage and a heat exchanger, is presented. An analysis is performed to figure out which refrigerant offers the best performance of the heat pump. In addition, fixed the refrigerant, the performance of the grid connected heat pump is found to be increased from 29.5% to 55.5% for both heating and cooling compared with a stand-alone air-to-water heat pump solution. Finally, the process flow diagram and the piping and instrumentation diagram of the substation are presented and commented