Imagining the impossible before breakfast: the relation between creativity, dissociation, and sleep

Dissociative symptoms have been related to higher rapid eye movement sleep density, a sleep phase during which hyperassociativity may occur. This may enhance artistic creativity during the day. To test this hypothesis, we conducted a creative photo contest to explore the relation between dissociation, sleep, and creativity. During the contest, participants (N = 72) took one photo per day for five consecutive days, based on specific daily themes (consisting of single words) and the instruction to take as creative a photo as possible each day. Furthermore, they completed daily measures of state dissociation and a short sleep diary The photos and their captions were ranked by two professional photographers and two clinical psychologists based on creativity, originality, bizarreness, and quality. We expected that dissociative people would rank higher in the contest compared with low-dissociative participants, and that the most original photos would be taken on days when the participants scored highest on acute dissociation. We found that acute dissociation predicted a higher ranking on creativity. Poorer sleep quality and fewer hours of sleep predicted more bizarreness in the photos and captions. None of the trait measures could predict creativity. In sum, acute dissociation related to enhanced creativity. These findings contribute to our understanding of dissociative symptomatology

Schizotypy and performance on an insight problem-solving task: The contribution of persecutory ideation

Insight problem solving is thought to underpin creative thought as it incorporates both divergent (generating multiple ideas and solutions) and convergent (arriving at the optimal solution) thinking approaches. The current literature on schizotypy and creativity is mixed and requires clarification. An alternate approach was employed by designing an exploratory web-based study using only correlates of schizotypal traits (paranoia, dissociation, cognitive failures, fantasy proneness, and unusual sleep experiences) and examining which (if any) predicted optimal performance on an insight problem-solving task. One hundred and twenty-one participants were recruited online from the general population and completed the number reduction task. The discovery of the hidden rule (HR) was used as a measure of insight. Multivariate logistic regression analyses highlighted persecutory ideation to best predict the discovery of the HR (OR = 1.05; 95% CI 1.01–1.10, p = 0.017), with a one-point increase in persecutory ideas corresponding to the participant being 5% more likely to discover the HR. This result suggests that persecutory ideation, above other schizotypy correlates, may be involved in insight problem solving

The interaction between subclinical psychotic experiences, insomnia and objective measures of sleep

Investigations into schizophrenia have revealed a high incidence of comorbidity with disturbed sleep and circadian timing. Acknowledging this comorbidity on a dimensional level, we tested prospectively whether subclinical psychotic symptoms are more prevalent in individuals with insomnia. An insomnia group (n = 21) and controls (n = 22) were recruited on their subjective sleep quality, recorded actigraphically for 3 weeks and assessed for psychotic-like experiences with The Prodromal Questionnaire-16. Using multivariate Poisson regression analyses, we found that objective and subjective sleep measures interact to predict the highest risk for psychotic experiences. Objective measures of sleep and statistical modelling are rarely used in either clinical trials or practice for schizophrenia, yet this study highlights their value in these areas

Unravelling the links between psychotic-like experiences, sleep and circadian rhythms

Psychotic-like experiences (PLEs) are prevalent occurrences deemed comparable with the symptoms of psychosis, but not sufficiently severe to warrant a diagnosis upon clinical presentation. Their presence is associated with several adverse clinical outcomes: the onset of various common mental health disorders (e.g. anxiety, mood, substance abuse), poorer functioning, non-remission and relapse. Sleep and circadian rhythm disruption (SCRD) is observed in 30-80% of patients with psychosis. The omnipotence of SCRD across all phases of the disorder (including the prodromal, acute, chronic and residual phases) raises the question as to whether SCRD may directly contribute to the development of psychosis. Assuming that PLEs are along the same continuum to developing psychosis, a logical next step to further disentangle the sleep-psychosis relationship is to examine whether SCRD relates to the experience of PLEs and whether this relationship is bi-directional. This thesis begins by examining the core predictions made by a continuum model of understanding psychosis and how specific parameters of sleep may influence PLEs. A smaller high-definition cross-sectional study follows, examining biological underpinnings (electroencephalography (EEG), electrocardiography (ECG), endogenous melatonin rhythms and actigraphy) of a complaint of poor sleep and their relation to the occurrence of PLEs. We then refocus on which parameters of sleep are most integral to the sleep-PLE relationship and close with an investigation of how Hypothalamic Pituitary Adrenal (HPA) axis activity may further our knowledge of this relationship. The findings of this thesis demonstrate specificity in the parameters of sleep shown to impact certain PLEs. The importance of objective sleep and biologically driven measures in this line of research are underscored, with group differences in EEG, ECG and melatonin. This thesis also highlights dissociative symptomatology as a candidate mediator for the sleep-psychosis relationship, and emphasises the ties between paranoia and negative affect. Finally, this thesis also illuminates the challenges of examining the relationship between sleep and PLEs in isolation, and suggests that they must be considered within the broader framework of co-existing mental health problems.</p

Unravelling the links between psychotic-like experiences, sleep and circadian rhythms

Psychotic-like experiences (PLEs) are prevalent occurrences deemed comparable with the symptoms of psychosis, but not sufficiently severe to warrant a diagnosis upon clinical presentation. Their presence is associated with several adverse clinical outcomes: the onset of various common mental health disorders (e.g. anxiety, mood, substance abuse), poorer functioning, non-remission and relapse. Sleep and circadian rhythm disruption (SCRD) is observed in 30-80% of patients with psychosis. The omnipotence of SCRD across all phases of the disorder (including the prodromal, acute, chronic and residual phases) raises the question as to whether SCRD may directly contribute to the development of psychosis. Assuming that PLEs are along the same continuum to developing psychosis, a logical next step to further disentangle the sleep-psychosis relationship is to examine whether SCRD relates to the experience of PLEs and whether this relationship is bi-directional. This thesis begins by examining the core predictions made by a continuum model of understanding psychosis and how specific parameters of sleep may influence PLEs. A smaller high-definition cross-sectional study follows, examining biological underpinnings (electroencephalography (EEG), electrocardiography (ECG), endogenous melatonin rhythms and actigraphy) of a complaint of poor sleep and their relation to the occurrence of PLEs. We then refocus on which parameters of sleep are most integral to the sleep-PLE relationship and close with an investigation of how Hypothalamic Pituitary Adrenal (HPA) axis activity may further our knowledge of this relationship. The findings of this thesis demonstrate specificity in the parameters of sleep shown to impact certain PLEs. The importance of objective sleep and biologically driven measures in this line of research are underscored, with group differences in EEG, ECG and melatonin. This thesis also highlights dissociative symptomatology as a candidate mediator for the sleep-psychosis relationship, and emphasises the ties between paranoia and negative affect. Finally, this thesis also illuminates the challenges of examining the relationship between sleep and PLEs in isolation, and suggests that they must be considered within the broader framework of co-existing mental health problems

A longitudinal high-resolution exploration into the relationship between sleep disruption and ‘in vivo’ psychotic symptoms, paranoia, and dissociation in early phase psychosis.

More than a century of research highlights the omnipresence of sleep and circadian rhythm disruption in psychosis. While earlier understandings focused more on this being a consequence or ‘side effect’ of psychosis, emergent research has highlighted the potential for a causal pathophysiological link. Clarifying this relationship could pave the way for more targeted treatment programs in early phase psychosis. This thesis opens with a comprehensive overview of the literature surrounding sleep, circadian rhythms, and psychosis to date (Part 1). This overview closes by highlighting that the nature of the relationship (i.e. which specific psychotic experiences (PE) and sleep or circadian parameters are related), directionality of the relationship and whether there is convincing evidence to infer causality remains unclear. Experimental and clinical studies in both clinical and analogue populations have provided mixed results. This highlights the need for more mechanism-driven research targeting specific experiences within psychosis. An empirical study follows in Part 2. This study uses experience sampling method in tandem with actigraphy which permits high resolution sampling of daily “in vivo” psychotic experiences with nightly subjective and objective sleep metrics. This is study was designed to address some of the caveats described in Part 1 and takes a mechanism-driven approach to exploring whether nightly sleep or circadian rhythmicity is predictive of next day hallucinations, dissociation, and paranoia in early phase psychosis. In Part 3, this thesis closes with a critical reflection of the work and what I as a researcher have learned through the process of this study and will take forward into both my clinical and academic career

Schizotypy and Performance on an Insight Problem-Solving Task: The Contribution of Persecutory Ideation

Insight problem solving is thought to underpin creative thought as it incorporates both divergent (generating multiple ideas and solutions) and convergent (arriving at the optimal solution) thinking approaches. The current literature on schizotypy and creativity is mixed and requires clarification. An alternate approach was employed by designing an exploratory web-based study using only correlates of schizotypal traits (paranoia, dissociation, cognitive failures, fantasy proneness, and unusual sleep experiences) and examining which (if any) predicted optimal performance on an insight problem-solving task. One hundred and twenty-one participants were recruited online from the general population and completed the number reduction task. The discovery of the hidden rule (HR) was used as a measure of insight. Multivariate logistic regression analyses highlighted persecutory ideation to best predict the discovery of the HR (OR = 1.05; 95% CI 1.01–1.10, p = 0.017), with a one-point increase in persecutory ideas corresponding to the participant being 5% more likely to discover the HR. This result suggests that persecutory ideation, above other schizotypy correlates, may be involved in insight problem solving

Out-of-body experience in virtual reality induces acute dissociation

An established challenge in studying dissociation is developing effective methodologies to induce dissociative symptomatology in the laboratory. The primary aim of this study was to pilot the efficacy of virtual reality (VR) in inducing dissociative states in healthy subjects by simulating out-of-body experiences. Healthy participants (N = 25) were asked to wear an Oculus Rift (Menlo Park, CA) VR head-mounted display, which was connected to a wide-angle GoPro (San Mateo, CA) video camera placed in front of participants so they could view themselves, the experimenter, and the surrounding environment. They were asked to partake in a number of exercises while wearing the Oculus Rift and completed a questionnaire on sleep quality (the Sleep Condition Indicator; Espie et al., 2014) and the Clinician-Administered Dissociative States Scale (CADSS; Bremner et al., 1998) both before and after the perceptual experience. Findings highlight a significant increase in acute dissociation after VR exposure, particularly with respect to the endorsement of depersonalization on the CADSS. This is-to the best of our knowledge-the first study to implement VR in inducing acute dissociation, and it offers preliminary support for the application of VR as a viable method to induce dissociative states in healthy participants. Our research paves the way for the investigation and use of these new technologies in the assessment and treatment of dissociative symptomatology, providing a valuable and fruitful path to understanding dissociation in the future

Revisiting nocturnal heart rate and heart rate variability in insomnia : A polysomnography-based comparison of young self-reported good and poor sleepers

Primary insomnia is often considered a disorder of 24-hr hyperarousal. Numerous attempts have been made to investigate nocturnal heart rate (HR) and its variability (HRV) as potential pathophysiological hallmarks of altered arousal levels in insomnia, with mixed results. We have aimed to overcome some of the pitfalls of previous studies by using a young, medication-free, age- and gender-matched population consisting of 43 students aged 18–30 years half with a subthreshold insomnia complaint. We employed at-home ambulatory polysomnography and compared this attenuated insomnia group to a good sleeping group. The poor sleepers had significantly higher wake after sleep onset, arousal count, mean HR in all sleep stages (with the exception of Stage 1) and lower sleep efficiency. Consistent with previous research, we also found a significant group-by-sleep stage interaction in the prediction of nocturnal HR, highlighting the insomnia group to have a lower wake–sleep HR reduction compared to good sleepers. When restricting our analyses to insomnia with objectively determined short sleep duration, we found significantly lower standard deviation of RR intervals (SDNN; a measure of HRV) compared to good sleepers. Taken together, this lends credence to the hyperarousal model of insomnia and may at least partially explain the increased prevalence of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality observed in patients with insomnia

Phenotypic divergence in sleep and circadian cycles linked by affective state and environmental risk related to psychosis

Study Objectives: Environmental cues influence circadian rhythm timing and neurochemicals involved in the regulation of affective behavior. How this interplay makes them a probable nonspecific risk factor for psychosis is unclear. We aimed to identify the relationship between environmental risk for psychosis and circadian timing phenotypes sampled from the general population. Methods: Using an online survey, we devised a cumulative risk exposure score for each of the 1898 survey respondents based on 23 empirically verified transdiagnostic risks for psychosis, three dimensions of affect severity, psychotic-like experiences, and help-seeking behavior. Quantitative phenotyping of sleep and circadian rhythms was undertaken using at-home polysomnography, melatonin and cortisol profiles, and 3-week rest-activity behavior in individuals with a high-risk exposure load (top 15% of survey respondents, n = 22) and low-risk exposure load (bottom 15% of respondents, n = 22). Results: Psychiatric symptoms were present in 100% of the high-load participants and 14% of the low-load participants. Compared to those with a low-load, high-load participants showed a later melatonin phase which was reflected by a greater degree of dispersion in circadian timing. Phase relationships between later circadian melatonin phase and later actigraphic sleep onsets were maintained and these were strongly correlated with self-reported sleep mid-points. No differences were identified from polysomnography during sleep between groups. Conclusion: Distinguishing circadian timing from other sleep phenotypes will allow adaptation for dosage of time-directed intervention, useful in stabilizing circadian timekeeping physiology and potentially reducing the multisystemic disruption in mental health disorders