Using Intervention Mapping to Develop an Efficacious Multicomponent Systems-Based Intervention to Increase Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccination in a Large Urban Pediatric Clinic Network

Background: The CDC recommends HPV vaccine for all adolescents to prevent cervical, anal, oropharyngeal, vaginal, vulvar, and penile cancers, and genital warts. HPV vaccine rates currently fall short of national vaccination goals. Despite evidence-based strategies with demonstrated efficacy to increase HPV vaccination rates, adoption and implementation of these strategies within clinics is lacking. The Adolescent Vaccination Program (AVP) is a multicomponent systems-based intervention designed to implement five evidence-based strategies within primary care pediatric practices. The AVP has demonstrated efficacy in increasing HPV vaccine initiation and completion among adolescents 10-17 years of age. The purpose of this paper is to describe the application of Intervention Mapping (IM) toward the development, implementation, and formative evaluation of the clinic-based AVP prototype. Methods: Intervention Mapping (IM) guided the development of the Adolescent Vaccination Program (AVP). Deliverables comprised: a logic model of the problem (IM Step 1); matrices of behavior change objectives (IM Step 2); a program planning document comprising scope, sequence, theory-based methods, and practical strategies (IM Step 3); functional AVP component prototypes (IM Step 4); and plans for implementation (IM Step 5) and evaluation (IM Step 6). Results: The AVP consists of six evidence-based strategies implemented in a successful sequenced roll-out that (1) established immunization champions in each clinic, (2) disseminated provider assessment and feedback reports with data-informed vaccination goals, (3) provided continued medical and nursing education (with ethics credit) on HPV, HPV vaccination, message bundling, and responding to parent hesitancy, (4) electronic health record cues to providers on patient eligibility, and (5) patient reminders for HPV vaccine initiation and completion. Conclusions: IM provided a logical and systematic approach to developing and evaluating a multicomponent systems-based intervention to increase HPV vaccination rates among adolescents in pediatric clinics

Impact of Booster Breaks and Computer Prompts on Physical Activity and Sedentary Behavior Among Desk-Based Workers: A Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial

Introduction The 15-minute work break provides an opportunity to promote health, yet few studies have examined this part of the workday. We studied physical activity and sedentary behavior among office workers and compared the results of the Booster Break program with those of a second intervention and a control group to determine whether the Booster Break program improved physical and behavioral health outcomes. Methods We conducted a 3-arm, cluster-randomized controlled trial at 4 worksites in Texas from 2010 through 2013 to compare a group-based, structured Booster Break program to an individual-based computer-prompt intervention and a usual-break control group; we analyzed physiologic, behavioral, and employee measures such as work social support, quality of life, and perceived stress. We also identified consistent and inconsistent attendees of the Booster Break sessions. Results We obtained data from 175 participants (mean age, 43 y; 67% racial/ethnic minority). Compared with the other groups, the consistent Booster Break attendees had greater weekly pedometer counts (P \u3c .001), significant decreases in sedentary behavior and self-reported leisure-time physical activity (P \u3c .001), and a significant increase in triglyceride concentrations (P = .02) (levels remained within the normal range). Usual-break participants significantly increased their body mass index, whereas Booster Break participants maintained body mass index status during the 6 months. Overall, Booster Break participants were 6.8 and 4.3 times more likely to have decreases in BMI and weekend sedentary time, respectively, than usual-break participants. Conclusion Findings varied among the 3 study groups; however, results indicate the potential for consistent attendees of the Booster Break intervention to achieve significant, positive changes related to physical activity, sedentary behavior, and body mass index

Parents\u27 Stigmatizing Beliefs About the HPV Vaccine and Their Association With Information Seeking Behavior and Vaccination Communication Behaviors

Parents\u27 stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine, such as beliefs that it promotes adolescent sexual activity, constitute a notable barrier to vaccine uptake. The purpose of this study is to describe the associations between parents\u27 stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine, psychosocial antecedents to vaccination, and parents\u27 intentions to vaccinate their children. Parents of vaccine-eligible children

Increasing HPV Vaccination in a Network of Pediatric Clinics using a Multi-component Approach

Background: Despite continued public health efforts to increase human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination among adolescents, initiation remains below the level needed to reach the Healthy People 2020 goal of 80% series completion by age 13. Methods: We developed, implemented, and evaluated a multi-component program that used evidence-based strategies to increase HPV vaccine initiation in a network of 51 pediatric clinics in Houston, Texas. Our target populations were the clinic network, healthcare providers, male and female patients ages 11-17, and their parents. The program, called the Adolescent Vaccination Program (AVP), was conducted from March 2016 through March 2019 and contained strategies to increase vaccination including: HPV immunization champions; provider assessment and feedback; provider continuing education; provider reminders; and patient reminders. We used a single group pre/post design with an external comparison – NIS-Teen. Our primary outcome was initiation of the HPV vaccine based on the electronic health record. We used interrupted time series analysis (ITSA) to measure change in initiation over time. We calculated monthly, quarterly, and annual rates of initiation for each physician, clinic, and the network. We examined patterns of initiation by patient age, sex, race/ethnicity, and type of insurance. Results: By the end of the project, the 51 clinics averaged 77.4% initiation. Rates increased annually from September 2015 through March 2019. ITSA analysis over 75 months showed an increase in vaccine initiation of 0.396% per month from the introduction of the program in March 2016. Average individual clinic improvement was 0.37% per month ranging from -0.04% to 0.68% through March 2019. Data for the 11-12 year olds, the target age group for initiating the vaccine, showed a greater percentage increase (54.2%) compared with the 13-17 year olds (29.6%). Hispanics and African Americans had the highest initiation rates in all years while non-Hispanic whites had the lowest. Families without insurance had the lowest rates while those with Medicaid/Medicare had the highest. Conclusions: We observed a secular trend upward in both the network and NIS-Teen data; however, the network showed a steeper increase. The AVP is a promising program of strategies to increase HPV vaccination in a clinic setting

Test–Retest Reliability of Self-Reported Mammography in Women Veterans

Background. Mammography self-report is used to monitor screening and evaluate intervention trends; however, few studies have examined reliability. Methods. Reliability of self-reported lifetime number of mammograms, most recent mammogram date, and predictors of reliability were assessed using data from Project H.O.M.E. The study population was 2494 women 52 years and over, listed in the U.S. National Registry of Women Veterans, with no history of breast cancer, who completed both baseline (2000–2002) and year 1 (2002–2003) surveys. Results. Reliability of lifetime number of mammograms was 60.9% for exact consistency and 79.9% for consistency within one mammogram. Thirty-five percent was exactly consistent in reporting mammogram date; 55.6% was consistent within 3 months. Completing both surveys by mail and reporting fewer lifetime mammograms at baseline were positively associated with consistency of reporting lifetime number. White race/ethnicity, having a Bachelor\u27s degree, reporting a healthcare provider\u27s recommendation for a mammogram, having a screening mammogram, completing both surveys by mail, and being in the maintenance or action stages of change were associated with consistency in reporting date. Conclusions. Reliability varies with the measure of self-reported mammography. Likewise, predictors show different patterns of association with different definitions. Our findings call attention to the need for explicit definitions and measures of mammography use

The Lifetime Cost of Bipolar Disorder in the US: An Estimate for New Cases in 1998

Objective: To develop a cost model that estimates the total and per case lifetime cost of bipolar disorder for 1998 incident cases in the US. Study design: Lifetime cost simulation model. Perspective: Societal. Methods: Age- and gender-specific incidence of bipolar disorder in 1998 was estimated by simulation based on existing prevalence data. The course of illness and mental health service cost of 6 clinically defined prognostic groups was estimated based on the research literature and the judgement of panels of experts. Excess cost of general medical care was estimated based on claims data from a large insurer. Indirect cost was projected including excess unemployment and reduced earnings reported in the National Comorbidity Survey. Comorbidity treatment and indirect cost related to alcohol (ethanol) and drug abuse was added based on a National Institute on Drug Abuse study. Results: The present value of the lifetime cost of persons with onset of bipolar disorder in 1998 was estimated at 24 billion US dollars ($US). Average cost per case ranged from$US11 720 for persons with a single manic episode to $US624 785 for persons with nonresponsive/chronic episodes. Conclusion: The model indicates the potential cost savings of preventing a case of bipolar disorder and underscores the importance of achieving a stable outcome in new cases to limit the economic consequences of the disorder.Bipolar disorders, Cost of illness, Pharmacoeconomics

Parents’ stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine and their association with information seeking behavior and vaccination communication behaviors

Parents’ stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine, such as beliefs that it promotes adolescent sexual activity, constitute a notable barrier to vaccine uptake. The purpose of this study is to describe the associations between parents’ stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine, psychosocial antecedents to vaccination, and parents’ intentions to vaccinate their children. Parents of vaccine-eligible children (n = 512) were surveyed in a large urban clinical network. Results indicate that two stigmatizing beliefs were significantly associated with self-efficacy in talking with a doctor about the HPV vaccine. Believing that the vaccine would make a child more likely to have sex was associated with citing social media as a source of information about the vaccine. Other stigmatizing beliefs were either associated with citing healthcare professionals as sources of information about the vaccine, or they were not significantly associated with any information source. This finding suggests that stigmatizing beliefs might discourage parents from seeking out information about the vaccine. This study is significant because it further highlights the importance of doctor recommendations to all patients at recommended ages; doctor visits may represent one of the few opportunities to normalize HPV vaccination and address parents’ stigmatizing beliefs about the HPV vaccine

AVPCancerFree: Impact of a digital behavior change intervention on parental HPV vaccine –related perceptions and behaviors

Parent hesitancy contributes to reduced HPV vaccination rates. The HPVcancerfree app (HPVCF) was designed to assist parents in making evidence-based decisions regarding HPV vaccination. This study examined if parents of vaccine-eligible youth (11–12 yrs.) who use HPVCF in addition to usual care demonstrate significantly more positive intentions and attitudes toward HPV vaccination and greater HPV vaccination rates compared to those not using HPVCF. Clinics (n = 51) within a large urban pediatric network were randomly assigned to treatment (HPVCF + usual care) or comparison (usual care only) conditions in a RCT conducted between September 2017 and February 2019. Parents completed baseline and 5-month follow-up surveys. Participant-level analysis determined 1) change in HPV vaccination initiation behavior and related psychosocial determinants and 2) predictors of HPV vaccine initiation. Parents (n = 375) who completed baseline and 5-month follow-up surveys were female (95.2%), 40.8 (±5.8) yrs. married (83.7%), employed (68.3%), college educated (61.9%), and privately insured (76.5%). Between-group analysis of HPVCF efficacy demonstrated that parents assigned to receive HPVCF significantly increased knowledge about HPV and HPV vaccination (p < .05). Parents who accessed content within HPVCF significantly increased knowledge about HPV & HPV vaccine (p < .01) and perceived effectiveness of HPV vaccine (p < .05). Change in HPV vaccine initiation was not significant. A multivariate model to describe predictors of HPV vaccine initiation demonstrated an association with Tdap and MCV vaccination adoption, positive change in perceived effectiveness of the HPV vaccine, and reduction in perceived barriers against HPV vaccination. HPVCF appears to be a feasible adjunct to the education received in usual care visits and reinforces the value of apps to support the important persuasive voice of the health-care provider in overcoming parent HPV vaccine hesitancy