154 research outputs found
Can we avoid dark energy?
The idea that we live near the centre of a large, nonlinear void has
attracted attention recently as an alternative to dark energy or modified
gravity. We show that an appropriate void profile can fit both the latest
cosmic microwave background and supernova data. However, this requires either a
fine-tuned primordial spectrum or a Hubble rate so low as to rule these models
out. We also show that measurements of the radial baryon acoustic scale can
provide very strong constraints. Our results present a serious challenge to
void models of acceleration.Comment: 5 pages, 4 figures; minor changes; version published in Phys. Rev.
Let
Can decaying modes save void models for acceleration?
The unexpected dimness of Type Ia supernovae (SNe), apparently due to
accelerated expansion driven by some form of dark energy or modified gravity,
has led to attempts to explain the observations using only general relativity
with baryonic and cold dark matter, but by dropping the standard assumption of
homogeneity on Hubble scales. In particular, the SN data can be explained if we
live near the centre of a Hubble-scale void. However, such void models have
been shown to be inconsistent with various observations, assuming the void
consists of a pure growing mode. Here it is shown that models with significant
decaying mode contribution today can be ruled out on the basis of the expected
cosmic microwave background spectral distortion. This essentially closes one of
the very few remaining loopholes in attempts to rule out void models, and
strengthens the evidence for Hubble-scale homogeneity.Comment: 11 pages, 3 figures; discussion expanded, appendix added; version
accepted to Phys. Rev.
Precision cosmology defeats void models for acceleration
The suggestion that we occupy a privileged position near the centre of a
large, nonlinear, and nearly spherical void has recently attracted much
attention as an alternative to dark energy. Putting aside the philosophical
problems with this scenario, we perform the most complete and up-to-date
comparison with cosmological data. We use supernovae and the full cosmic
microwave background spectrum as the basis of our analysis. We also include
constraints from radial baryonic acoustic oscillations, the local Hubble rate,
age, big bang nucleosynthesis, the Compton y-distortion, and for the first time
include the local amplitude of matter fluctuations, \sigma_8. These all paint a
consistent picture in which voids are in severe tension with the data. In
particular, void models predict a very low local Hubble rate, suffer from an
"old age problem", and predict much less local structure than is observed.Comment: 22 pages, 12 figures; v2 adds models in closed backgrounds;
conclusions strengthened; version accepted to Phys. Rev.
The growth of structure in the Szekeres inhomogeneous cosmological models and the matter-dominated era
This study belongs to a series devoted to using Szekeres inhomogeneous models
to develop a theoretical framework where observations can be investigated with
a wider range of possible interpretations. We look here into the growth of
large-scale structure in the models. The Szekeres models are exact solutions to
Einstein's equations that were originally derived with no symmetries. We use a
formulation of the models that is due to Goode and Wainwright, who considered
the models as exact perturbations of an FLRW background. Using the Raychaudhuri
equation, we write for the two classes of the models, exact growth equations in
terms of the under/overdensity and measurable cosmological parameters. The new
equations in the overdensity split into two informative parts. The first part,
while exact, is identical to the growth equation in the usual linearly
perturbed FLRW models, while the second part constitutes exact non-linear
perturbations. We integrate numerically the full exact growth rate equations
for the flat and curved cases. We find that for the matter-dominated era, the
Szekeres growth rate is up to a factor of three to five stronger than the usual
linearly perturbed FLRW cases, reflecting the effect of exact Szekeres
non-linear perturbations. The growth is also stronger than that of the
non-linear spherical collapse model, and the difference between the two
increases with time. This highlights the distinction when we use general
inhomogeneous models where shear and a tidal gravitational field are present
and contribute to the gravitational clustering. Additionally, it is worth
observing that the enhancement of the growth found in the Szekeres models
during the matter-dominated era could suggest a substitute to the argument that
dark matter is needed when using FLRW models to explain the enhanced growth and
resulting large-scale structures that we observe today (abridged)Comment: 18 pages, 4 figures, matches PRD accepted versio
Gauging the cosmic microwave background
We provide a new derivation of the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave
background (CMB), and find an exact expression that can be readily expanded
perturbatively. Close attention is paid to gauge issues, with the motivation to
examine the effect of super-Hubble modes on the CMB. We calculate a transfer
function that encodes the behaviour of the dipole, and examine its
long-wavelength behaviour. We show that contributions to the dipole from
adiabatic super-Hubble modes are strongly suppressed, even in the presence of a
cosmological constant, contrary to claims in the literature. We also introduce
a naturally defined CMB monopole, which exhibits closely analogous
long-wavelength behaviour. We discuss the geometrical origin of this
super-Hubble suppression, pointing out that it is a simple reflection of
adiabaticity, and hence argue that it will occur regardless of the matter
content.Comment: 17 pages, 5 figures; minor changes; version accepted to Phys. Rev.
Dynamics of a lattice Universe
We find a solution to Einstein field equations for a regular toroidal lattice
of size L with equal masses M at the centre of each cell; this solution is
exact at order M/L. Such a solution is convenient to study the dynamics of an
assembly of galaxy-like objects. We find that the solution is expanding (or
contracting) in exactly the same way as the solution of a
Friedman-Lema\^itre-Robertson-Walker Universe with dust having the same average
density as our model. This points towards the absence of backreaction in a
Universe filled with an infinite number of objects, and this validates the
fluid approximation, as far as dynamics is concerned, and at the level of
approximation considered in this work.Comment: 14 pages. No figure. Accepted version for Classical and Quantum
Gravit
Local Void vs Dark Energy: Confrontation with WMAP and Type Ia Supernovae
It is now a known fact that if we happen to be living in the middle of a
large underdense region, then we will observe an "apparent acceleration", even
when any form of dark energy is absent. In this paper, we present a "Minimal
Void" scenario, i.e. a "void" with minimal underdensity contrast (of about
-0.4) and radius (~ 200-250 Mpc/h) that can, not only explain the supernovae
data, but also be consistent with the 3-yr WMAP data. We also discuss
consistency of our model with various other measurements such as Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis, Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and local measurements of the
Hubble parameter, and also point out possible observable signatures.Comment: Minor numerical errors and typos corrected, references adde
Light Propagation and Large-Scale Inhomogeneities
We consider the effect on the propagation of light of inhomogeneities with
sizes of order 10 Mpc or larger. The Universe is approximated through a
variation of the Swiss-cheese model. The spherical inhomogeneities are
void-like, with central underdensities surrounded by compensating overdense
shells. We study the propagation of light in this background, assuming that the
source and the observer occupy random positions, so that each beam travels
through several inhomogeneities at random angles. The distribution of
luminosity distances for sources with the same redshift is asymmetric, with a
peak at a value larger than the average one. The width of the distribution and
the location of the maximum increase with increasing redshift and length scale
of the inhomogeneities. We compute the induced dispersion and bias on
cosmological parameters derived from the supernova data. They are too small to
explain the perceived acceleration without dark energy, even when the length
scale of the inhomogeneities is comparable to the horizon distance. Moreover,
the dispersion and bias induced by gravitational lensing at the scales of
galaxies or clusters of galaxies are larger by at least an order of magnitude.Comment: 27 pages, 9 figures, revised version to appear in JCAP, analytical
estimate included, typos correcte
A parametrization of the growth index of matter perturbations in various Dark Energy models and observational prospects using a Euclid-like survey
We provide exact solutions to the cosmological matter perturbation equation
in a homogeneous FLRW universe with a vacuum energy that can be parametrized by
a constant equation of state parameter and a very accurate approximation
for the Ansatz . We compute the growth index \gamma=\log
f(a)/\log\Om_m(a), and its redshift dependence, using the exact and
approximate solutions in terms of Legendre polynomials and show that it can be
parametrized as in most cases. We then
compare four different types of dark energy (DE) models: CDM, DGP,
and a LTB-large-void model, which have very different behaviors at
z\gsim1. This allows us to study the possibility to differentiate between
different DE alternatives using wide and deep surveys like Euclid, which will
measure both photometric and spectroscopic redshifts for several hundreds of
millions of galaxies up to redshift . We do a Fisher matrix analysis
for the prospects of differentiating among the different DE models in terms of
the growth index, taken as a given function of redshift or with a principal
component analysis, with a value for each redshift bin for a Euclid-like
survey. We use as observables the complete and marginalized power spectrum of
galaxies and the Weak Lensing (WL) power spectrum. We find that, using
, one can reach (2%, 5%) errors in , and (4%, 12%) errors in
, while using WL we get errors at least twice as large.
These estimates allow us to differentiate easily between DGP, models and
CDM, while it would be more difficult to distinguish the latter from a
variable equation of state parameter or LTB models using only the growth
index.}Comment: 29 pages, 7 figures, 6 table
- …