Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease: inquiry into the genesis of a disease name in the historical context of Switzerland and Japan

Purpose: To delineate the historical steps associated with the genesis of the name and the definition of Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada (VKH) disease. Methods: A bibliographical review of the major publications that were relevant to the original development of the name of the clinical entity known today as Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease, in the historical context of the early 20th century. Results: Three distinct time periods can be considered to be important in terms of providing a historical perspective on VKH disease. Given that the cutaneous manifestations of VKH disease are so characteristic, these could not have been missed even before the actual clinical entity of VKH was recognized in the early 20th century. Indeed, several authors, including the Arabic doctor Mohammad-al-Ghâfiqî in the 12th century as well as Jacobi, Nettelship and Tay in the 19th century, described poliosis, neuralgias and hearing disorders. Many of these cases were probably due to sympathetic ophthalmia, but some were clearly VKH cases. The second phase is characterized by the surge of articles that appeared early in the 20th century that defined the disease more precisely. A number of these authors subsequently became associated with the disease name, the first being Alfred Vogt from Switzerland, followed by Japanese researchers. Yoshizo Koyanagi was in fact not the first Japanese author to describe the disease; this honor goes to the first Japanese Professor of Ophthalmology at the University of Tokyo, Dr. Jujiro Komoto, who published in a German language journal, Klinische Monatsblätter für Augenheilkunde in 1911. Yoshizo Koyanagi published his first report in the Nippon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi 3 years later, in 1914, but it was a much later article, one published in 1929, that definitively associated his name with the disease. In this review article, Koyanagi reported 16 cases, of which six were his own cases, that beautifully illustrate the natural course of the disease. In this same time period, Einosuke Harada, in an article published in Nippon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi in 1926 that was based on several case studies, comprehensively described a syndrome that included (1) a prodromal phase of malaise and meningeal irritation; (2) bilateral uveitis of diverse intensity; (3) bilateral retinal detachments spontaneously resolving; (4) integumentary changes; (5) lymphocytosis of the spinal fluid; (6) dysacousia. It is now accepted that Vogt-Koyanagi disease and the syndrome described by Harada are one entity with a diverse clinical spectrum bearing the universally accepted name of Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease. The third phase and most recent phase is characterized by the rapid progress made in terms of knowledge of the physiopathology of the disease, primarily due to the development of immunological methods. The evidence accumulated to date clearly points towards an autoimmune Th1 disease directed against proteins associated with choroidal melanin. Other analytical techniques, such as indocyanine green angiography, have enabled researchers to monitor more closely the primary lesional process at the level of the choroid, and standardized diagnostic criteria have been generated in the recent past. Conclusion: Those who earn scientific merit in clinical medicine are the ones who are able to visualize an overview based on the synthesis of ‘new' medical facts that have been made available, usually reported singly by several, unassociated authors concomitantly. This is certainly the case for Yoshizo Koyanagi and Einosuke Harada. Conversely, Alfred Vogt was primarily lucky in that he encountered and subsequently precisely described the first case in the literatur

Fluorescein angiographic findings and clinical features in Fuchs' uveitis

Fuchs' uveitis is very often diagnosed with substantial delay, which is at the origin of deleterious effects such as unnecessary treatment and its consequences. The aim of this study was to analyse the type and frequency of posterior inflammatory and fluorescein angiographic signs in Fuchs' uveitis in conjunction with other clinical signs. Patients seen at the Centre for Ophthalmic Specialised Care (COS) in Lausanne and the Memorial A. de Rothschild, Clinique Générale-Beaulieu in Geneva between 1995 and 2008 with the diagnosis of Fuchs' uveitis and who had undergone a fundus fluorescein angiography (FFA) were analysed. In addition to FFA signs, the data collected included age, gender, initial and final visual acuities, clinical findings at presentation, mean diagnostic delay and ocular complications. Between 1995 and 2008, 105 patients seen in our centres in Lausanne and Geneva were diagnosed with Fuchs' uveitis. Forty of them (38.1%) had undergone at least one FFA. One patient was excluded because of a concomittant diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. In 28 of 39 patients (71.2%) diagnosis was not reached at presentation with a mean diagnosis delay of 3.67±4.86years (range: 1month-24years). The original erroneous diagnosis was intermediate uveitis in 16 patients (57.1%), posterior uveitis in two patients (7.1%), panuveitis in four patients (14.3%) and anterior granulomatous uveitis in six patients (21.4%). Fluorescein angiography demonstrated the presence of disc hyperfluorescence in 43/44 eyes (97.7%), sectorial peripheral retinal vascular leaking in 6/44 eyes (13.6%) and cystoid macular oedema in 4/44 eyes (9.1%), all of which were seen in eyes having undergone cataract surgery. Fuchs' uveitis was bilateral in 5/39 patients (12.8%). The most frequent clinical signs were vitritis in 42/44 eyes (95.5%), stellate keratic precipitates in 41 eyes (93.2%), posterior subcapsular opacities or cataract in 19 eyes (43.2%), and heterochromia in 19 eyes (43.2%). Fuchs' uveitis is a largely underdiagnosed uveitis, probably because the predominant vitreous involvement is ignored by many ophthalmologists. In addition, the nearly constant inflammatory fluorescein angiography findings reported here such as disc hyperfluorescence and, more rarely, peripheral retinal vascular leaking, are not well known and are not usually associated with Fuchs' uveitis but represent an additional factor leading to misdiagnosis. These findings need to be recognised in order to reduce diagnostic dela

Reappraisal of birdshot retinochoroiditis (BRC): a global approach

Background: This study aimed to readjust the appraisal of birdshot retinochoroiditis (BRC) in light of a global approach, including the full array of investigational procedures. Patients and methods: This retrospective study reviewed charts of BRC cases treated in the uveitis clinic of our center between 1995 and 2011. We identified 25 patients with BRC; of these, 19 had sufficient data for inclusion in the study. Patients were examined with a standard clinical approach for inflammatory disorders, including dual fluorescence angiography with fluorescein and indocyanine green, perimetry, and laser flare photometry, both at presentation and during follow-up. Spectral optical coherence tomography (OCT) was performed when available. Disease characteristics and evolutionary patterns were reported. Results: Human leucocyte antigen was positive for the A29 allele in all patients. The mean age at presentation was 49.6 ± 10.0years, the mean diagnostic delay was 21.5 ± 18months, and the mean follow-up was 85 ± 60months. Out of 19 patients, three presented with mutton-fat keratic precipitates (KPs), three had no depigmented lesions at presentation, and eight did not fulfill the recommended criterion of three depigmented peripapillar lesions. Cystoid macular edema (CMO) at entry was present in 8/19 cases. Perimetric anomalies were noted in all patients at presentation. In 92% of cases, fluorescein findings included disc hyperfluorescence, retinal vasculitis of large vessels, and leakage from medium-sized and small vessels. In all patients, a (pseudo)-delay was noted in the arterio-venous circulation time (mean venous dye appearance = 42.1 ± 13.1s), which reflected massive capillary leakage. At presentation, all patients exhibited indocyanine green angiographic signs, including hypofluorescent dark dots, vessel fuzziness, and areas of diffuse late hyperfluorescence. This allowed early diagnosis in 3/19 patients (16%) without birdshot fundus lesions at presentation. Conclusions: BRC is a granulomatous uveitis, and mutton-fat KPs do not exclude the disease. When BRC is suspected, indocyanine green angiography is crucial to allow early diagnosis and to monitor the evolution of choroiditis. Perimetry is an obligate investigation for diagnosis and follow-up. CMO is less frequent than stated earlier. Scores of fluorescein and indocyanine green angiographic signs indicated that choroiditis responded readily to therapy, but retinitis was relatively resistant to therap

Central Serous Chorioretinopathy Mistaken for Tuberculous Choroiditis

Purpose: To report a patient erroneously diagnosed with tuberculous choroiditis who was accordingly treated with long term steroids which in turn, worsened the actual disease process that turned out to be central serous chorioretinopathy (CSC). Case Report: A 59-year-old Caucasian man developed a chorioretinal disease in his right eye in 1997. Having a positive tuberculin skin test, tuberculous chorioretinitis was suspected and antituberculous therapy was administered for 4 months. In 2005, visual symptoms in the same eye recurred and despite negative interferon gamma release assay, tuberculous choroiditis was considered as the diagnosis and the patient further received massive corticosteroid therapy along with antituberculous agents. Despite a deteriorating clinical picture, therapy was continued. Upon initial examination at our center, no sign of inflammation was observed and a diagnosis of CSC was made, consequently steroid therapy was terminated. Conclusion: In some chorioretinopathies, it is difficult to differentiate inflammatory from non-inflammatory causes. One should observe the course of the disease and question the initial diagnosis when no improvement or deterioration occurs despite therapy