3,132 research outputs found
Using Rasch analysis to form plausible health states amenable to valuation: the development of CORE-6D from CORE-OM in order to elicit preferences for common mental health problems
Purpose: To describe a new approach for deriving a preference-based index from a condition specific measure that uses Rasch analysis to develop health states.
Methods: CORE-OM is a 34-item instrument monitoring clinical outcomes of people with common mental health problems. CORE-OM is characterised by high correlation across its domains. Rasch analysis was used to reduce the number of items and response levels in order to produce a set of unidimensionally-behaving items, and to generate a credible set of health states corresponding to different levels of symptom severity using the Rasch item threshold map.
Results: The proposed methodology resulted in the development of CORE-6D, a 2-dimensional health state description system consisting of a unidimensionally-behaving 5-item emotional component and a physical symptom item. Inspection of the Rasch item threshold map of the emotional component helped identify a set of 11 plausible health states, which, combined with the physical symptom item levels, will be used for the valuation of the instrument, resulting in the development of a preference-based index.
Conclusions: This is a useful new approach to develop preference-based measures where the domains of a measure are characterised by high correlation. The CORE-6D preference-based index will enable calculation of Quality Adjusted Life Years in people with common mental health problems
Impact of Service Sector Loads on Renewable Resource Integration
Urban areas consist of a mix of households and services, such as offices,
shops, schools, etc. Yet most urban energy models only consider household load
profiles, omitting the service sector. Realistic assessment of the potential
for renewable resource integration in cities requires models that include
detailed demand and generation profiles. Detailed generation profiles are
available for many resources. Detailed demand profiles, however, are currently
only available for households and not for the service sector. This paper
addresses this gap. The paper (1) proposes a novel approach to devise synthetic
service sector demand profiles based on a combination of a large number of
different data sources, and (2) uses these profiles to study the impact of the
service sector on the potential for renewable resource integration in urban
energy systems, using the Netherlands as a case study. The importance of the
service sector is addressed in a broad range of solar and wind generation
scenarios, and in specific time and weather conditions (in a single scenario).
Results show that including the service sector leads to statistically
significantly better estimations of the potential of renewable resource
integration in urban areas. In specific time and weather conditions, including
the service sector results in estimations that are up to 33% higher than if
only households are considered. The results can be used by researchers to
improve urban energy systems models, and by decision-makers and practitioners
for grid planning, operation and management}.Comment: 32 pages, 7 figures, 4 table
Using Rasch analysis to form plausible health states amenable to valuation: the development of CORE-6D from CORE-OM in order to elicit preferences for common mental health problems
Purpose: To describe a new approach for deriving a preference-based index from a condition specific measure that uses Rasch analysis to develop health states.
Methods: CORE-OM is a 34-item instrument monitoring clinical outcomes of people with common mental health problems. CORE-OM is characterised by high correlation across its domains. Rasch analysis was used to reduce the number of items and response levels in order to produce a set of unidimensionally-behaving items, and to generate a credible set of health states corresponding to different levels of symptom severity using the Rasch item threshold map.
Results: The proposed methodology resulted in the development of CORE-6D, a 2-dimensional health state description system consisting of a unidimensionally-behaving 5-item emotional component and a physical symptom item. Inspection of the Rasch item threshold map of the emotional component helped identify a set of 11 plausible health states, which, combined with the physical symptom item levels, will be used for the valuation of the instrument, resulting in the development of a preference-based index.
Conclusions: This is a useful new approach to develop preference-based measures where the domains of a measure are characterised by high correlation. The CORE-6D preference-based index will enable calculation of Quality Adjusted Life Years in people with common mental health problems
Common scale valuations across different preference-based measures: estimation using rank data
Background: Different preference-based measures (PBMs) used to estimate Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) provide di¤erent utility values for the same patient. Differences are expected since values have been obtained using different samples, valuation techniques and descriptive systems. Previous studies have estimated the relationship between pairs of PBMs using patient self-reported data. However, there is a need for an approach capable of generating values directly on a common scale for a range of PBMs using the same sample of general population respondents and valuation technique but keeping the advantages of the different descriptive systems.
Methods: General public survey data (n=501) where respondents ranked health states described using subsets of six PBMs were analysed. We develop a new model based on the mixed logit to overcome two key limitations of the standard rank ordered logit model, namely, the unrealistic choice pattern (Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives) and the independence of repeated observations.
Results: There are substantial differences in the estimated parameters between the two models (mean di¤erence 0.07) leading to di¤erent orderings across the measures. Estimated values for the best states described by di¤erent PBMs are substantially and significantly di¤erent using the standard model, unlike our approach which yields more consistent results.
Limitations: Data come from a exploratory study that is relatively small both in sample size and coverage of health states.
Conclusions: This study develops a new, �exible econometric model specifically designed to reflect appropriately the features of rank data. Results support the view that the standard model is not appropriate in this setting and will yield very different and apparently inconsistent results. PBMs can be compared using a common scale by implementation of this new approach
Estimating a preference-based index for a menopause specific health quality of life questionnaire
BACKGROUND: The aim of the study was to develop a menopause-specific, preference-based healthrelated
quality-of-life (HRQoL) index reflecting both menopausal symptoms and potential sideeffects
of Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT).
METHODS: The study had three phases: the development of a health state classification, a
prospective valuation survey and the estimation of a model to interpolate HRQoL indices for all
remaining health states as defined by the classification. A menopausal health state classification was
developed with seven dimensions: hot flushes, aching joints/muscles, anxious/frightened feelings,
breast tenderness, bleeding, vaginal dryness and undesirable androgenic signs. Each dimension
contains between three and five levels and defines a total of 6,075 health states. A sample of 96
health states was selected for the valuation survey. These states were valued by a sample of 229
women aged 45 to 60, randomly selected from 6 general practice lists in Sheffield, UK. Respondents
were asked to complete a time trade-off (TTO) task for nine health states, resulting in an average
of 16.5 values for each health state.
RESULTS: Mean health states valued range from 0.48 to 0.98 (where 1.0 is full health and zero is for
states regarded as equivalent to death). Symptoms, as described by the classification system, can be
rank-ordered in terms of their impact (from high to low) on menopausal HRQoL as follows: aching
joints and muscles, bleeding, breast tenderness, anxious or frightened feelings, vaginal dryness,
androgenic signs. Hot flushes did not significantly contribute to model fit. The preferred model
produced a mean absolute error of 0.053, but suffered from bias at both ends of the scale.
CONCLUSION: This article presents an attempt to directly value a condition specific health state
classification. The overall fit was disappointing, but the results demonstrate that menopausal symptoms are perceived by patients to have a significant impact on utility. The overall effect is modest compared to the more generic health state descriptions such as the EQ-5D. The resultant
algorithm generates a preference-based index that can be used economic evaluation and that reflects the impact of this condition
Estimation of a preference based single index from the sexual quality of life questionnaire (SQOL) using ordinal data
There is increasing interest in using ordinal methods to estimate cardinal values for health states to calculate quality adjusted life years. This paper reports the estimation of models of rank data and discrete choice experiment (DCE) data to derive a preference-based index from a condition specific measure relating to sexual health and to compare the results to values generated from time trade-off valuation (TTO). The DCE data were analysed using a random effects probit model and the DCE predicted values were rescaled according to the highest and lowest predicted TTO values corresponding to the best and worst SQOL health states respectively. The rank data were analysed using a rank ordered logit model and re-scaled using two alternative methods. Firstly, re-scaling the rank predicted values using identical methods to those employed for DCE and secondly, re-scaling the rank model coefficients by dividing each level coefficient by the coefficient relating to death. The study raises some important issues about the use of ordinal data to produce cardinal health state valuations
Estimating a preference-based index from the Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation - Outcome Measure (CORE-OM): valuation of CORE-6D
Background: The Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation - Outcome Measure (CORE-OM) is used to evaluate the effectiveness of psychological therapies in people with common mental disorders. The objective of this study was to estimate a preference-based index for this population using CORE-6D, a health state classification system derived from CORE-OM consisting of a 5-item emotional component and a physical item, and to demonstrate a novel method for generating states that are not orthogonal.
Methods: Rasch analysis was used to identify 11 plausible ‘emotional’ health states from CORE-6D (rather than conventional statistical design that would generate implausible states). By combining these with the 3 response levels of the physical item of CORE-6D, 33 plausible health states can be described, of which 18 were selected for valuation. An interview valuation survey of 220 members of public in South Yorkshire, UK, was undertaken using the time-trade-off method to value the 18 health states; regression analysis was subsequently used to predict values for all possible states described by CORE-6D.
Results: A number of multivariate regression models were built to predict values for the 33 plausible health states of CORE-6D, using the Rasch logit value of the emotional health state and the response level of the physical item as independent variables. A cubic model with high predictive value (adjusted R squared 0.990) was finally selected, which can be used to predict utility values for all 927 states described by CORE-6D.
Conclusion: The CORE-6D preference-based index will enable the assessment of cost-effectiveness of interventions for people with common mental disorders using existing and prospective CORE-OM datasets. The new method for generating states may be useful for other instruments with highly correlated dimensions
- …