25 research outputs found
Comment on `Strong coupling in extended Horava-Lifshitz gravity'
We show that, contrary to the claim made in arXiv:0911.1299, the extended
Horava gravity model proposed in arXiv:0909.3525 does not suffer from a strong
coupling problem. By studying the observational constraints on the model we
determine the bounds on the scale of the ultraviolet modification for which the
proposal yields a phenomenologically viable, renormalizable and weakly coupled
model of quantum gravity.Comment: A footnote discussing the absence of fine-tuning is adde
Cosmological constraints on Lorentz violating dark energy
The role of Lorentz invariance as a fundamental symmetry of nature has been
lately reconsidered in different approaches to quantum gravity. It is thus
natural to study whether other puzzles of physics may be solved within these
proposals. This may be the case for the cosmological constant problem. Indeed,
it has been shown that breaking Lorentz invariance provides Lagrangians that
can drive the current acceleration of the universe without experiencing large
corrections from ultraviolet physics. In this work, we focus on the simplest
model of this type, called ThetaCDM, and study its cosmological implications in
detail. At the background level, this model cannot be distinguished from
LambdaCDM. The differences appear at the level of perturbations. We show that
in ThetaCDM, the spectrum of CMB anisotropies and matter fluctuations may be
affected by a rescaling of the gravitational constant in the Poisson equation,
by the presence of extra contributions to the anisotropic stress, and finally
by the existence of extra clustering degrees of freedom. To explore these
modifications accurately, we modify the Boltzmann code CLASS. We then use the
parameter inference code Monte Python to confront ThetaCDM with data from
WMAP-7, SPT and WiggleZ. We obtain strong bounds on the parameters accounting
for deviations from LambdaCDM. In particular, we find that the discrepancy
between the gravitational constants appearing in the Poisson and Friedmann
equations is constrained at the level 1.8%.Comment: 17 pages, 5 figure
Cosmological constraints on deviations from Lorentz invariance in gravity and dark matter
We consider a scenario where local Lorentz invariance is violated by the
existence of a preferred time direction at every space-time point. This
scenario can arise in the context of quantum gravity and its description at low
energies contains a unit time-like vector field which parameterizes the
preferred direction. The particle physics tests of Lorentz invariance preclude
a direct coupling of this vector to the fields of the Standard Model, but do
not bear implications for dark matter. We discuss how the presence of this
vector and its possible coupling to dark matter affect the evolution of the
Universe. At the level of homogeneous cosmology the only effect of Lorentz
invariance violation is a rescaling of the expansion rate. The physics is
richer at the level of perturbations. We identify three effects crucial for
observations: the rescaling of the matter contribution to the Poisson equation,
the appearance of an extra contribution to the anisotropic stress and the
scale-dependent enhancement of dark matter clustering. These effects result in
distinctive features in the power spectra of the CMB and density fluctuations.
Making use of the data from Planck and WiggleZ we obtain the most stringent
cosmological constraints to date on departures from Lorentz symmetry. Our
analysis provides the first direct bounds on deviations from Lorentz invariance
in the dark matter sector.Comment: 10 pages, 3 figures, revtex; footnote on isocurvature modes added,
discussion on the decoupling of the Standard Model fields from the aether
extended, a reference added; version to be published in JCA
Experimental assessment of the speed of light perturbation in free-fall absolute gravimeters
Precision absolute gravity measurements are growing in importance, especially
in the context of the new definition of the kilogram. For the case of free-fall
absolute gravimeters with a Michelson-type interferometer tracking the position
of a free falling body, one of the effects that needs to be taken into account
is the speed of light perturbation due to the finite speed of propagation of
light. This effect has been extensively discussed in the past, and there is at
present a disagreement between different studies. In this work, we present the
analysis of new data and confirm the result expected from the theoretical
analysis applied nowadays in free-fall gravimeters. We also review the standard
derivations of this effect (by using phase shift or Doppler effect arguments)
and show their equivalence
Horava gravity vs. thermodynamics: the black hole case
Under broad assumptions breaking of Lorentz invariance in gravitational
theories leads to tension with unitarity because it allows for processes that
apparently violate the second law of thermodynamics. The crucial ingredient of
this argument is the existence of black hole solutions with the interior
shielded from infinity by a causal horizon. We study how the paradox can be
resolved in the healthy extension of Horava gravity. To this aim we analyze
classical solutions describing large black holes in this theory with the
emphasis on their causal structure. The notion of causality is subtle in this
theory due to the presence of instantaneous interactions. Despite this fact, we
find that within exact spherical symmetry a black hole solution contains a
space-time region causally disconnected from infinity by a surface of finite
area -- the `universal horizon'. We then consider small perturbations of
arbitrary angular dependence in the black hole background. We argue that
aspherical perturbations destabilize the universal horizon and, at non-linear
level, turn it into a finite-area singularity. The causal structure of the
region outside the singularity is trivial. If the higher-derivative terms in
the equations of motion smear the singularity while preserving the trivial
causal structure of the solutions, the thermodynamics paradox would be
obviated. As a byproduct of our analysis we prove that the black holes do not
have any non-standard long-range hair. We also comment on the relation with
Einstein-aether theory, where the solutions with universal horizon appear to be
stable.Comment: 36 pages, 3 figures, 1 table. v2 Small changes to agree with
published versio
A healthy extension of Horava gravity
We propose a natural extension of Horava's model for quantum gravity, which
is free from the notorious pathologies of the original proposal. The new model
endows the scalar graviton mode with a regular quadratic action and remains
power-counting renormalizable. At low energies, it reduces to a
Lorentz-violating scalar-tensor gravity theory. The deviations with respect to
general relativity can be made weak by an appropriate choice of parameters.Comment: 4 pages, no figure
Testing Lorentz invariance of dark matter
We study the possibility to constrain deviations from Lorentz invariance in
dark matter (DM) with cosmological observations. Breaking of Lorentz invariance
generically introduces new light gravitational degrees of freedom, which we
represent through a dynamical timelike vector field. If DM does not obey
Lorentz invariance, it couples to this vector field. We find that this coupling
affects the inertial mass of small DM halos which no longer satisfy the
equivalence principle. For large enough lumps of DM we identify a (chameleon)
mechanism that restores the inertial mass to its standard value. As a
consequence, the dynamics of gravitational clustering are modified. Two
prominent effects are a scale dependent enhancement in the growth of large
scale structure and a scale dependent bias between DM and baryon density
perturbations. The comparison with the measured linear matter power spectrum in
principle allows to bound the departure from Lorentz invariance of DM at the
per cent level.Comment: 42 pages, 9 figure
Technically natural dark energy from Lorentz breaking
We construct a model of dark energy with a technically natural small
contribution to cosmic acceleration, i.e. this contribution does not receive
corrections from other scales in the theory. The proposed acceleration
mechanism appears generically in the low-energy limit of gravity theories with
violation of Lorentz invariance that contain a derivatively coupled scalar
field Theta. The latter may be the Goldstone field of a broken global symmetry.
The model, that we call Theta-CDM, is a valid effective field theory up to a
high cutoff just a few orders of magnitude below the Planck scale. Furthermore,
it can be ultraviolet-completed in the context of Horava gravity. We discuss
the observational predictions of the model. Even in the absence of a
cosmological constant term, the expansion history of the Universe is
essentially indistinguishable from that of Lambda-CDM. The difference between
the two theories appears at the level of cosmological perturbations. We find
that in Theta-CDM the matter power spectrum is enhanced at subhorizon scales
compared to Lambda-CDM. This property can be used to discriminate the model
from Lambda-CDM with current cosmological data.Comment: A few equations in the Appendix correcte
On the Extra Mode and Inconsistency of Horava Gravity
We address the consistency of Horava's proposal for a theory of quantum
gravity from the low-energy perspective. We uncover the additional scalar
degree of freedom arising from the explicit breaking of the general covariance
and study its properties. The analysis is performed both in the original
formulation of the theory and in the Stueckelberg picture. A peculiarity of the
new mode is that it satisfies an equation of motion that is of first order in
time derivatives. At linear level the mode is manifest only around spatially
inhomogeneous and time-dependent backgrounds. We find two serious problems
associated with this mode. First, the mode develops very fast exponential
instabilities at short distances. Second, it becomes strongly coupled at an
extremely low cutoff scale. We also discuss the "projectable" version of
Horava's proposal and argue that this version can be understood as a certain
limit of the ghost condensate model. The theory is still problematic since the
additional field generically forms caustics and, again, has a very low strong
coupling scale. We clarify some subtleties that arise in the application of the
Stueckelberg formalism to Horava's model due to its non-relativistic nature.Comment: Discussion expanded; a figure added; accepted to JHE
Supersymmetric Aether
It has been suggested by Groot Nibbelink and Pospelov that Lorentz invariance
can be an emergent symmetry of low-energy physics provided the theory enjoys a
non-relativistic version of supersymmetry. We construct a model that realizes
the latter symmetry dynamically: it breaks Lorentz invariance but leaves the
supersymmetry generators intact. The model is a supersymmetric extension of the
dynamical aether theory of Jacobson and Mattingly. It shows rich dynamics and
possesses a family of inequivalent vacua realizing different symmetry breaking
patterns. In particular, we find stable vacua that break spontaneously spatial
isotropy. Supersymmetry breaking terms give masses to fermionic and bosonic
partners of the aether field. We comment on the coupling of the model to
supergravity and on the implications for Horava gravity.Comment: 21 pages, no figure