Questionable Arguments for the Correctness of Perturbation Theory in Non-Abelian Models

We analyze the arguments put forward recently by Niedermayer et al in favor of the correctness of conventional perturbation theory in non-Abelian models and supposedly showing that our super-instanton counterexample was sick. We point out that within their own set of assumptions, the proof of Niedermayer et al regarding the correctness of perturbation theory is incorrect and provide a correct proof under more restrictive assumptions. We reply also to their claim that the S-matrix bootstrap approach of Balog et al supports the existence of asymptotic freedom in the O(3) model.Comment: 9 page

Discrete Symmetry Enhancement in Nonabelian Models and the Existence of Asymptotic Freedom

We study the universality between a discrete spin model with icosahedral symmetry and the O(3) model in two dimensions. For this purpose we study numerically the renormalized two-point functions of the spin field and the four point coupling constant. We find that those quantities seem to have the same continuum limits in the two models. This has far reaching consequences, because the icosahedron model is not asymptotically free in the sense that the coupling constant proposed by L"uscher, Weisz and Wolff [1] does not approach zero in the short distance limit. By universality this then also applies to the O(3) model, contrary to the predictions of perturbation theory.Comment: 18 pages, 8 figures Color coding in Fig. 5 changed to improve visibilit

Comment on "Superinstantons and the Reliability of Perturbation Theory in Non-Abelian Models"

In a recent letter (hep-lat/9311019) A. Patrascioiu and E. Seiler argued that when taking into account "superinstantons configurations" the perturbative expansion and the beta-function of the two-dimensional non-linear sigma-model are modified at two loops order. I point out that: (1) perturbation theory in a superinstanton background is infra-red singular beyond three loops; (2) the new infra-red singular terms, which change the two loop terms, come from singular operators - describing superinstanton insertions - in the OPE; (3) taking into account these operators, the beta-function is not modified. Therefore the results of Patrascioiu and Seiler do not contradict perturbation theory.Comment: 1 page, REVTeX, no figure

Quasi-asymptotic freedom in the two dimensional O(3) model

The behaviour of the renormalized spin 2-point function in the O(3) and dodecahedron spin model are investigated numerically. The Monte Carlo data show excellent agreement between the two models. The short distance behavior comes very close to standard theoretical expectations, yet it differs significantly from it. A possible explanation of this situation is offered.Comment: 4 pages, 4 figure

Super-Instantons, Perfect Actions, Finite Size Scaling and the Continuum Limit

We discuss some aspects of the continuum limit of some lattice models, in particular the $2D$ $O(N)$ models. The continuum limit is taken either in an infinite volume or in a box whose size is a fixed fraction of the infinite volume correlation length. We point out that in this limit the fluctuations of the lattice variables must be $O(1)$ and thus restore the symmetry which may have been broken by the boundary conditions (b.c.). This is true in particular for the so-called super-instanton b.c. introduced earlier by us. This observation leads to a criterion to assess how close a certain lattice simulation is to the continuum limit and can be applied to uncover the true lattice artefacts, present even in the so-called 'perfect actions'. It also shows that David's recent claim that super-instanton b.c. require a different renormalization must either be incorrect or an artefact of perturbation theory.Comment: 14 pages, latex, no figure

Super-Instantons and the Reliability of Perturbation Theory in Non-Abelian Models

In dimension $D\leq 2$ the low temperature behavior of systems enjoying a continuous symmetry is dominated by super-instantons: classical configurations of arbitrarily low energy. Perturbation theory in the background of a super-instanton produces thermodynamic answers for the invariant Green's functions that differ from the standard ones, but only in non-Abelian models and only starting at $O(1/\beta^2)$. This effect modifies the $\beta$-function of the $O(N)$ models and persists in the large $N$ limit of the $O(N)$ models.Comment: 8 pages, plain LaTeX, MPI-Ph/93-87 and AZPH-TH/93-3

Lattice artefacts and the running of the coupling constant

We study the running of the L\"uscher-Weisz-Wolff (LWW) coupling constant in the two dimensional O(3) nonlinear $\sigma$ model. To investigate the continuum limit we refine the lattice spacing from the $1\over 16$ value used by LWW up to $1\over 160$. We find that the lattice artefacts are much larger than estimated by LWW and that most likely the coupling constant runs slower than predicted by perturbation theory. A precise determination of the running in the continuum limit would require a controlled ansatz of extrapolation, which, we argue, is not presently available.Comment: 4 pages, 4 figures. To address the criticism that we are studying a different quantitiy than Luscher, Weisz and Wolff originally did, we introduced a new equation (2), a new paragraph discussing this issue and a new figure comparing the results obtained with our prescription to that obtained with the original one of Luscher, Weisz and Wolf