RC Trough Bridges: A Parametric Study using FEM and an Analysis of their Current State

There are approximately 4000 railway bridges in Sweden managed by the Swedish Administration of Transport (Trafikverket), of which a common construction type is the reinforced concrete (RC) trough bridge, which is a structure that consists of a slab carried by two longitudinal main beams which transfer loads towards the supports. A substantial amount of the RC trough bridge population is approaching the end of their service lives which consequently implies that the replacement of some of these bridges can be expected in the near future. Extending their service lives can yield positive effects from a financial- as well as an environmental perspective, and therefore it is highly beneficial to evaluate their capacities as realistically as possible. One factor that may help improve accuracy during the determination of their capacities is an evaluation of how it is affected by the location of the railway track on the bridge.  In current design codes defined by Trafikverket, consideration is taken to horizontal track displacement for a minimum displacement of 0.1 m if there doesn’t exist data suggesting that a larger displacement is prevalent on the bridge. However, Trafikverket has received data which suggest that a considerable number of bridges could experience load eccentricities which exceed the standard minimum value. This raises the question whether or not 0.1m is the most optimal limit value for load eccentricity on railway bridges. For RC trough bridges, a larger load eccentricity may result in one main beam carrying a larger portion of the load which will decrease the axle load which the bridge can carry. It is therefore important to evaluate the influence of larger horizontal displacements than what is currently is considered as a preventive action.   In addition, several studies on Swedish concrete bridges constructed during the 20th century have pointed to a significant increase in concrete compressive- and tensile strength over time. This suggests that it is possible that a considerable amount of RC trough bridges have a higher capacity than what was originally intended, and further research is required in order to understand the behaviour of these bridges when key material parameters are altered.        There are three main tasks which this master thesis seeks to complete. The first part is a detailed analysis of a database named BaTMan (Bridge and Tunnel Management) that belongs to Trafikverket. In this analysis parameters such as span length, age, material type and damages for every identified railway bridge is extracted and further processed in Microsoft Excel in order to gain a clear overview of the RC trough bridge population. The second task regards the development of a non-linear finite element model of a typical RC trough bridge named Lautajokki. The model is analysed using ATENA Science and its behaviour is verified against test results obtained during a full-scale test of the bridge performed by Paulsson et al. (1996). The last task is to use the devolved model to perform a parametric study where the effects of changes in load eccentricity, compressive strength as well as tensile strength is studied.

A Parametric Study of an old Concrete Trough Bridge using non-linear Finite Element analysis

At least 20% of existing railway bridges in Sweden are reinforced concrete (RC) trough bridge that consist in a slab carried by two longitudinal main beams. As these bridges are getting old, there is an urging need to assess their remaining capacity with the aim of prolonging their service lives. The limited literature on the topic has pointed out that there is a significant difference between the capacity predicted by available codes and that obtained experimentally. In this paper, a review of the Bridge and Tunnel Management database (BaTMan) of railway infrastructure in Sweden, is carried out to gain an overview of the current state of the Swedish railway bridge, with focus on trough bridges. Then, a non-linear finite element model is calibrated using the experimental results of the previous testing of a decommissioned trough bridge. The model is used in a parametric study where the effect of key mechanical parameters on the capacity of trough bridges is studied. ISBN for host publication: 978-385748183-3</p

Pressure Distribution Patterns Between the Ballast and the Concrete Slab in Railway Trough Bridges

In Sweden, a substantial amount of railway bridges is approaching their intended lifespans and are planned to be replaced. However, it is not sustainable neither from a financial nor an environmental perspective to replace these bridges if they are still sound and safe. Thus, an evaluation of their actual capacity is required with the aim of extending their lifespans. A way to obtain a more accurate capacity is to determine the loads that are acting on them. Available literature points out the lack of experimental investigations on sleeper-ballast contact pressure, as well as on the stress distribution along and across the ballast. Consequently, railway bridge design has been based on traditional rather than rational assumptions, which can be quite conservative. In this paper, a review of models is carried out for evaluating stress patterns on the surface of the slab on ballasted concrete bridges. Then, a simplified finite element model of a concrete trough bridge, a common type of structure in Sweden, is used in a parametric analysis aimed to understand how the identified pressure distribution patterns affect the performance of this type of structure. Finally, with the purpose of studying how some parameters influence the bridge safety, a probabilistic reliability analysis is used. The reliability index beta (b) is obtained using the polynomial response surface method and its value is compared for different boundary condition scenarios. Also, the sensitivity factors for the considered random variables are compared and analyzed. Results show that the assumption of support condition and pressure pattern has a significant impact on the capacity, failure mode and probability of failure of this type of structure.ISBN för värdpublikation: 978-981-18-2016-8</p