400 research outputs found
Well structured program equivalence is highly undecidable
We show that strict deterministic propositional dynamic logic with
intersection is highly undecidable, solving a problem in the Stanford
Encyclopedia of Philosophy. In fact we show something quite a bit stronger. We
introduce the construction of program equivalence, which returns the value
precisely when two given programs are equivalent on halting
computations. We show that virtually any variant of propositional dynamic logic
has -hard validity problem if it can express even just the equivalence
of well-structured programs with the empty program \texttt{skip}. We also show,
in these cases, that the set of propositional statements valid over finite
models is not recursively enumerable, so there is not even an axiomatisation
for finitely valid propositions.Comment: 8 page
Relative Expressive Power of Navigational Querying on Graphs
Motivated by both established and new applications, we study navigational
query languages for graphs (binary relations). The simplest language has only
the two operators union and composition, together with the identity relation.
We make more powerful languages by adding any of the following operators:
intersection; set difference; projection; coprojection; converse; and the
diversity relation. All these operators map binary relations to binary
relations. We compare the expressive power of all resulting languages. We do
this not only for general path queries (queries where the result may be any
binary relation) but also for boolean or yes/no queries (expressed by the
nonemptiness of an expression). For both cases, we present the complete Hasse
diagram of relative expressiveness. In particular the Hasse diagram for boolean
queries contains some nontrivial separations and a few surprising collapses.Comment: An extended abstract announcing the results of this paper was
presented at the 14th International Conference on Database Theory, Uppsala,
Sweden, March 201
Modal Logics of Topological Relations
Logical formalisms for reasoning about relations between spatial regions play
a fundamental role in geographical information systems, spatial and constraint
databases, and spatial reasoning in AI. In analogy with Halpern and Shoham's
modal logic of time intervals based on the Allen relations, we introduce a
family of modal logics equipped with eight modal operators that are interpreted
by the Egenhofer-Franzosa (or RCC8) relations between regions in topological
spaces such as the real plane. We investigate the expressive power and
computational complexity of logics obtained in this way. It turns out that our
modal logics have the same expressive power as the two-variable fragment of
first-order logic, but are exponentially less succinct. The complexity ranges
from (undecidable and) recursively enumerable to highly undecidable, where the
recursively enumerable logics are obtained by considering substructures of
structures induced by topological spaces. As our undecidability results also
capture logics based on the real line, they improve upon undecidability results
for interval temporal logics by Halpern and Shoham. We also analyze modal
logics based on the five RCC5 relations, with similar results regarding the
expressive power, but weaker results regarding the complexity
Decidability of equational theories for subsignatures of relation algebra
Let S be a subset of the signature of relation algebra. Let R(S) be the closure under isomorphism of the class of proper S-structures and let F(S) be the closure under isomorphism of the class of proper S-structures over finite bases. Based on previous work, we prove that membership of R(S) is undecidable when (Formula presented), and for any of these signatures S if converse is excluded from S then membership of F(S) is also undecidable, for finite S-structures. We prove that the equational theories of F(S) and R(S) are undecidable when S includes composition and the signature of boolean algebra. If all operators in S are positive and it does not include negation, or if it can define neither domain, range nor composition, then the equational theory of either class is decidable. Open cases for decidability of the equational theory of R(S) are when S can define negation but not meet (or join) and either domain, range or composition. Open cases for the decidability of the equational theory of F(S) are (i) when S can define negation, converse and either domain, range or composition, and (ii) when S contains negation but not meet (or join) and either domain, range or composition
Investigation of the tradeoff between expressiveness and complexity in description logics with spatial operators
Le Logiche Descrittive sono una famiglia di formalismi molto espressivi per la rappresentazione della conoscenza. Questi formalismi sono stati investigati a fondo dalla comunit\ue0 scientifica, ma, nonostante questo grosso interesse, sono state definite poche Description Logics con operatori spaziali e tutte centrate sul Region Connection Calculus. Nella mia tesi considero tutti i pi\uf9 importanti formalismi di Qualitative Spatial Reasoning per mereologie, mereo-topologie e informazioni sulla direzione e studio alcune tecniche generali di ibridazione. Nella tesi presento un\u2019introduzione ai principali formalismi di Qualitative Spatial Reasoning e le principali famiglie di Description Logics. Nel mio lavoro, introduco anche le tecniche di ibridazione per estendere le Description Logics al ragionamento su conoscenza spaziale e presento il potere espressivo dei linguaggi ibridi ottenuti. Vengono presentati infine un risultato generale di para-decidibilit\ue0 per logiche descrittive estese da composition-based role axioms e l\u2019analisi del tradeoff tra espressivit\ue0 e propriet\ue0 computazionali delle logiche descrittive spaziali.Description Logics are a family of expressive Knowledge-Representation formalisms that have been deeply
investigated. Nevertheless the few examples of DLs with spatial operators in the current literature are
defined to include only the spatial reasoning capabilities corresponding to the Region Connection Calculus.
In my thesis I consider all the most important Qualitative Spatial Reasoning formalisms for mereological,
mereo-topological and directional information and investigate some general hybridization techniques.
I will present a short overview of the main formalisms of Qualitative Spatial Reasoning and the principal
families of DLs. I introduce the hybridization techniques to extend DLs to QSR and present the
expressiveness of the resulting hybrid languages. I also present a general paradecidability result for
undecidable languages equipped with composition-based role axioms and the tradeoff analysis of
expressiveness and computational properties for the spatial DLs
Computabilities of Validity and Satisfiability in Probability Logics over Finite and Countable Models
The -logic (which is called E-logic in this paper) of
Kuyper and Terwijn is a variant of first order logic with the same syntax, in
which the models are equipped with probability measures and in which the
quantifier is interpreted as "there exists a set of measure
such that for each , ...." Previously, Kuyper and
Terwijn proved that the general satisfiability and validity problems for this
logic are, i) for rational , respectively
-complete and -hard, and ii) for ,
respectively decidable and -complete. The adjective "general" here
means "uniformly over all languages."
We extend these results in the scenario of finite models. In particular, we
show that the problems of satisfiability by and validity over finite models in
E-logic are, i) for rational , respectively
- and -complete, and ii) for , respectively
decidable and -complete. Although partial results toward the countable
case are also achieved, the computability of E-logic over countable
models still remains largely unsolved. In addition, most of the results, of
this paper and of Kuyper and Terwijn, do not apply to individual languages with
a finite number of unary predicates. Reducing this requirement continues to be
a major point of research.
On the positive side, we derive the decidability of the corresponding
problems for monadic relational languages --- equality- and function-free
languages with finitely many unary and zero other predicates. This result holds
for all three of the unrestricted, the countable, and the finite model cases.
Applications in computational learning theory, weighted graphs, and neural
networks are discussed in the context of these decidability and undecidability
results.Comment: 47 pages, 4 tables. Comments welcome. Fixed errors found by Rutger
Kuype
Generalized Satisfiability Problems via Operator Assignments
Schaefer introduced a framework for generalized satisfiability problems on
the Boolean domain and characterized the computational complexity of such
problems. We investigate an algebraization of Schaefer's framework in which the
Fourier transform is used to represent constraints by multilinear polynomials
in a unique way. The polynomial representation of constraints gives rise to a
relaxation of the notion of satisfiability in which the values to variables are
linear operators on some Hilbert space. For the case of constraints given by a
system of linear equations over the two-element field, this relaxation has
received considerable attention in the foundations of quantum mechanics, where
such constructions as the Mermin-Peres magic square show that there are systems
that have no solutions in the Boolean domain, but have solutions via operator
assignments on some finite-dimensional Hilbert space. We obtain a complete
characterization of the classes of Boolean relations for which there is a gap
between satisfiability in the Boolean domain and the relaxation of
satisfiability via operator assignments. To establish our main result, we adapt
the notion of primitive-positive definability (pp-definability) to our setting,
a notion that has been used extensively in the study of constraint satisfaction
problems. Here, we show that pp-definability gives rise to gadget reductions
that preserve satisfiability gaps. We also present several additional
applications of this method. In particular and perhaps surprisingly, we show
that the relaxed notion of pp-definability in which the quantified variables
are allowed to range over operator assignments gives no additional expressive
power in defining Boolean relations
- …