A lower bound for linear approximate compaction

The {\em $\lambda$-approximate compaction} problem is: given an input array of $n$ values, each either 0 or 1, place each value in an output array so that all the 1's are in the first $(1+\lambda)k$ array locations, where $k$ is the number of 1's in the input. $\lambda$ is an accuracy parameter. This problem is of fundamental importance in parallel computation because of its applications to processor allocation and approximate counting. When $\lambda$ is a constant, the problem is called {\em Linear Approximate Compaction} (LAC). On the CRCW PRAM model, %there is an algorithm that solves approximate compaction in \order{(\log\log n)^3} time for $\lambda = \frac{1}{\log\log n}$, using $\frac{n}{(\log\log n)^3}$ processors. Our main result shows that this is close to the best possible. Specifically, we prove that LAC requires %$\Omega(\log\log n)$ time using \order{n} processors. We also give a tradeoff between $\lambda$ and the processing time. For $\epsilon < 1$, and $\lambda = n^{\epsilon}$, the time required is $\Omega(\log \frac{1}{\epsilon})$