9 research outputs found
Rare Probability Estimation under Regularly Varying Heavy Tails
This paper studies the problem of estimating the probability of symbols that have occurred very rarely, in samples drawn independently from an unknown, possibly infinite, discrete distribution. In particular, we study the multiplicative consistency of estimators, defined as the ratio of the estimate to the true quantity converging to one. We first show that the classical Good-Turing estimator is not universally consistent in this sense, despite enjoying favorable additive properties. We then use Karamata's theory of regular variation to prove that regularly varying heavy tails are sufficient for consistency. At the core of this result is a multiplicative concentration that we establish both by extending the McAllester-Ortiz additive concentration for the missing mass to all rare probabilities and by exploiting regular variation. We also derive a family of estimators which, in addition to being consistent, address some of the shortcomings of the Good-Turing estimator. For example, they perform smoothing implicitly and have the absolute discounting structure of many heuristic algorithms. This also establishes a discrete parallel to extreme value theory, and many of the techniques therein can be adapted to the framework that we set forth.National Science Foundation (U.S.) (Grant 6922470)United States. Office of Naval Research (Grant 6918937
On inference about rare events
Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2012.This electronic version was submitted by the student author. The certified thesis is available in the Institute Archives and Special Collections.Cataloged from student submitted PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 75-77).Despite the increasing volume of data in modern statistical applications, critical patterns and events have often little, if any, representation. This is not unreasonable, given that such variables are critical precisely because they are rare. We then have to raise the natural question: when can we infer something meaningful in such contexts? The focal point of this thesis is the archetypal problem of estimating the probability of symbols that have occurred very rarely, in samples drawn independently from an unknown discrete distribution. Our first contribution is to show that the classical Good-Turing estimator that is used in this problem has performance guarantees that are asymptotically non-trivial only in a heavy-tail setting. This explains the success of this method in natural language modeling, where one often has Zipf law behavior. We then study the strong consistency of estimators, in the sense of ratios converging to one. We first show that the Good-Turing estimator is not universally consistent. We then use Karamata's theory of regular variation to prove that regularly varying heavy tails are sufficient for consistency. At the core of this result is a multiplicative concentration that we establish both by extending the McAllester-Ortiz additive concentration for the missing mass to all rare probabilities and by exploiting regular variation. We also derive a family of estimators which, in addition to being strongly consistent, address some of the shortcomings of the Good-Turing estimator. For example, they perform smoothing implicitly. This framework is a close parallel to extreme value theory, and many of the techniques therein can be adopted into the model set forth in this thesis. Lastly, we consider a different model that captures situations of data scarcity and large alphabets, and which was recently suggested by Wagner, Viswanath and Kulkarni. In their rare-events regime, one scales the finite support of the distribution with the number of samples, in a manner akin to high-dimensional statistics. In that context, we propose an approach that allows us to easily establish consistent estimators for a large class of canonical estimation problems. These include estimating entropy, the size of the alphabet, and the range of the probabilities.by Mesrob I. Ohannessian.Ph.D
Missing -mass: Investigating the Missing Parts of Distributions
Estimating the underlying distribution from \textit{iid} samples is a
classical and important problem in statistics. When the alphabet size is large
compared to number of samples, a portion of the distribution is highly likely
to be unobserved or sparsely observed. The missing mass, defined as the sum of
probabilities over the missing letters , and the Good-Turing
estimator for missing mass have been important tools in large-alphabet
distribution estimation. In this article, given a positive function from
to the reals, the missing -mass, defined as the sum of
over the missing letters , is introduced and studied. The
missing -mass can be used to investigate the structure of the missing part
of the distribution. Specific applications for special cases such as
order- missing mass () and the missing Shannon entropy
() include estimating distance from uniformity of the missing
distribution and its partial estimation. Minimax estimation is studied for
order- missing mass for integer values of and exact minimax
convergence rates are obtained. Concentration is studied for a class of
functions and specific results are derived for order- missing mass
and missing Shannon entropy. Sub-Gaussian tail bounds with near-optimal
worst-case variance factors are derived. Two new notions of concentration,
named strongly sub-Gamma and filtered sub-Gaussian concentration, are
introduced and shown to result in right tail bounds that are better than those
obtained from sub-Gaussian concentration