On Maximum Weight Clique Algorithms, and How They Are Evaluated

Maximum weight clique and maximum weight independent set solvers are often benchmarked using maximum clique problem instances, with weights allocated to vertices by taking the vertex number mod 200 plus 1. For constraint programming approaches, this rule has clear implications, favouring weight-based rather than degree-based heuristics. We show that similar implications hold for dedicated algorithms, and that additionally, weight distributions affect whether certain inference rules are cost-effective. We look at other families of benchmark instances for the maximum weight clique problem, coming from winner determination problems, graph colouring, and error-correcting codes, and introduce two new families of instances, based upon kidney exchange and the Research Excellence Framework. In each case the weights carry much more interesting structure, and do not in any way resemble the 200 rule. We make these instances available in the hopes of improving the quality of future experiments

Empirical evaluation of Soft Arc Consistency algorithms for solving Constraint Optimization Problems

A large number of problems in Artificial Intelligence and other areas of science can be viewed as special cases of constraint satisfaction or optimization problems. Various approaches have been widely studied, including search, propagation, and heuristics. There are still challenging real-world COPs that cannot be solved using current methods. We implemented and compared several consistency propagation algorithms, which include W-AC*2001, EDAC, VAC, and xAC. Consistency propagation is a classical method to reduce the search space in CSPs, and has been adapted to COPs. We compared several consistency propagation algorithms, based on the resemblance between the optimal value ordering and the approximate value ordering generated by them. The results showed that xAC generated value orderings of higher quality than W-AC*2001 and EDAC. We evaluated some novel hybrid methods for solving COPs. Hybrid methods combine consistency propagation and search in order to reach a good solution as soon as possible and prune the search space as much as possible. We showed that the hybrid method which combines the variant TP+OnOff and branch-and-bound search performed fewer constraint checks and searched fewer nodes than others in solving random and real-world COPs

Models and Solution Techniques for Frequency Assignment Problems

Wireless communication is used in many different situations such as mobile telephony, radio and TV broadcasting, satellite communication, and military operations. In each of these situations a frequency assignment problem arises with application specific characteristics. Researchers have developed different modeling ideas for each of the features of the problem, such as the handling of interference among radio signals, the availability of frequencies, and the optimization criterion. This survey gives an overview of the models and methods that the literature provides on the topic. We present a broad description of the practical settings in which frequency assignment is applied. We also present a classification of the different models and formulations described in the literature, such that the common features of the models are emphasized. The solution methods are divided in two parts. Optimization and lower bounding techniques on the one hand, and heuristic search techniques on the other hand. The literature is classified according to the used methods. Again, we emphasize the common features, used in the different papers. The quality of the solution methods is compared, whenever possible, on publicly available benchmark instances

Russian Doll Search for Solving Constraint Optimization Problems

If the Constraint Satisfaction framework has been extended to deal with Constraint Optimization problems, it appears that optimization is far more complex than satisfaction. One of the causes of the inefficiency of complete tree search methods, like Depth First Branch and Bound, lies in the poor quality of the lower bound on the global valuation of a partial assignment, even when using Forward Checking techniques. In this paper, we introduce the Russian Doll Search algorithm which replaces one search by n successive searches on nested subproblems (n being the number of problem variables), records the results of each search and uses them later, when solving larger subproblems, in order to improve the lower bound on the global valuation of any partial assignment. On small random problems and on large real scheduling problems, this algorithm yields surprisingly good results, which greatly improve as the problems get more constrained and the bandwidth of the used variable ordering diminish..