A survey of FPGA-based LDPC decoders

Low-Density Parity Check (LDPC) error correction decoders have become popular in communications systems, as a benefit of their strong error correction performance and their suitability to parallel hardware implementation. A great deal of research effort has been invested into LDPC decoder designs that exploit the flexibility, the high processing speed and the parallelism of Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) devices. FPGAs are ideal for design prototyping and for the manufacturing of small-production-run devices, where their in-system programmability makes them far more cost-effective than Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs). However, the FPGA-based LDPC decoder designs published in the open literature vary greatly in terms of design choices and performance criteria, making them a challenge to compare. This paper explores the key factors involved in FPGA-based LDPC decoder design and presents an extensive review of the current literature. In-depth comparisons are drawn amongst 140 published designs (both academic and industrial) and the associated performance trade-offs are characterised, discussed and illustrated. Seven key performance characteristics are described, namely their processing throughput, latency, hardware resource requirements, error correction capability, processing energy efficiency, bandwidth efficiency and flexibility. We offer recommendations that will facilitate fairer comparisons of future designs, as well as opportunities for improving the design of FPGA-based LDPC decoder

Low-Density Parity-Check Code Decoder Design and Error Characterization on an FPGA Based Framework

Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC) codes have gained popularity in communication systems and standards due to their capacity approaching error correction performance. Among all the hard-decision based LDPC decoders, Gallager B (GaB), due to simplicity of its operations, poses as the most hardware friendly algorithm and an attractive solution for meeting the high-throughput demand in communication systems. However, GaB sufferers from poor error correction performance. In this work, we first propose a resource efficient GaB hardware architecture that delivers the best throughput while using fewest Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) resources with respect to the state of the art comparable LDPC decoding algorithms. We then introduce a Probabilistic GaB (PGaB) algorithm that disturbs the decisions made during the decoding iterations randomly with a probability value determined based on experimental studies. We achieve up to four orders of magnitude better error correction performance than the GaB with a 3.4% improvement in normalized throughput performance. PGaB requires around 40% less energy than GaB as the probabilistic execution results with reducing the average iteration count by up to 62% compared to the GaB. We also show that our PGaB consistently results with an improvement in maximum operational clock rate compared to the state of the art implementations. In this dissertation, we also present a high throughput FPGA based framework to accelerate error characterization of the LDPC codes. Our flexible framework allows the end user adjust the simulation parameters and rapidly study various LDPC codes and decoders. We first show that the connection intensive bipartite graph based LDPC decoder hardware architecture creates routing stress for longer codewords that are utilized in today's communications systems and standards. We address this problem by partitioning each processing element (PE) in the bipartite graph in such a way that the inputs of a PE are evenly distributed over its partitions. This allows depopulating the Loo Up Table (LUT) resources utilized for the decoder architecture by spreading the logic across the FPGA. We show that even though LUT usage increases, critical path delay reduces with the depopulation. More importantly, with the depopulation technique an unroutable design becomes routable, which allows longer codewords to be mapped on the FPGA. We then conduct two experiments on error correction performance analysis for the GaB and PGaB algorithms, demonstrate our framework's ability to reach a resolution level that is not attainable with general purpose processor (GPP) based simulations, which reduces the time scale of simulations to 24 hours from an estimated 199 years. We finally conduct the first study on identifying all possible codewords that are not correctable by the GaB for the case where a codeword has four errors. We reduce the time scale of this simulation that requires processing 117 billion codewords to 4 hours and 38 minutes with our framework from an estimated 7800 days on a single GPP

Improve the Usability of Polar Codes: Code Construction, Performance Enhancement and Configurable Hardware

Error-correcting codes (ECC) have been widely used for forward error correction (FEC) in modern communication systems to dramatically reduce the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) needed to achieve a given bit error rate (BER). Newly invented polar codes have attracted much interest because of their capacity-achieving potential, efficient encoder and decoder implementation, and flexible architecture design space.This dissertation is aimed at improving the usability of polar codes by providing a practical code design method, new approaches to improve the performance of polar code, and a configurable hardware design that adapts to various specifications. State-of-the-art polar codes are used to achieve extremely low error rates. In this work, high-performance FPGA is used in prototyping polar decoders to catch rare-case errors for error-correcting performance verification and error analysis. To discover the polarization characteristics and error patterns of polar codes, an FPGA emulation platform for belief-propagation (BP) decoding is built by a semi-automated construction flow. The FPGA-based emulation achieves significant speedup in large-scale experiments involving trillions of data frames. The platform is a key enabler of this work. The frozen set selection of polar codes, known as bit selection, is critical to the error-correcting performance of polar codes. A simulation-based in-order bit selection method is developed to evaluate the error rate of each bit using Monte Carlo simulations. The frozen set is selected based on the bit reliability ranking. The resulting code construction exhibits up to 1 dB coding gain with respect to the conventional bit selection. To further improve the coding gain of BP decoder for low-error-rate applications, the decoding error mechanisms are studied and analyzed, and the errors are classified based on their distinct signatures. Error detection is enabled by low-cost CRC concatenation, and post-processing algorithms targeting at each type of the error is designed to mitigate the vast majority of the decoding errors. The post-processor incurs only a small implementation overhead, but it provides more than an order of magnitude improvement of the error-correcting performance. The regularity of the BP decoder structure offers many hardware architecture choices. Silicon area, power consumption, throughput and latency can be traded to reach the optimal design points for practical use cases. A comprehensive design space exploration reveals several practical architectures at different design points. The scalability of each architecture is also evaluated based on the implementation candidates. For dynamic communication channels, such as wireless channels in the upcoming 5G applications, multiple codes of different lengths and code rates are needed to t varying channel conditions. To minimize implementation cost, a universal decoder architecture is proposed to support multiple codes through hardware reuse. A 40nm length- and rate-configurable polar decoder ASIC is demonstrated to fit various communication environments and service requirements.PHDElectrical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/140817/1/shuangsh_1.pd