A Component-Based and Aspect-Oriented Model for Software Evolution

International audienceComponent-Based Software Development (CBSD) and Aspect-Oriented Software Development (AOSD) are solutions to support software evolution by decomposing a software system into concerns. In this article, we propose Fractal Aspect Component (FAC), a general and symmetrical model for components and aspects. FAC decomposes a software system into regular components and aspect components which embody crosscutting concerns. We reify the relationship between an aspect component and a component, called an aspect binding, as a first-class runtime entity. The evolution of the system can be expressed by adding or removing components (aspect or regular) and by setting bindings (regular or crosscutting)

TOWARDS CHANGE VALIDATION IN DYNAMIC SYSTEM UPDATING FRAMEWORKS

Dynamic Software Updating (DSU) provides mechanisms to update a program without stopping its execution. An indiscriminate update that does not consider the current state of the computation, potentially undermines the stability of the running application. Determining automatically a safe moment, the time that the updating process could be started, is still an open crux that usually neglected from the existing DSU systems. The program developer is the best one who knows the program semantics and the logical relations between two successive versions as well as the constraints which should be respected in order to proceed with the update. Therefore, a set of meta-data has been introduced that could be exploited to explain the constraints of the update. These constraints should be considered at the dynamic update time. Thus, a runtime validator has been designed and implemented to verify these constraints before starting the update process. The validator is independent of existing DSU systems and can be plugged into DSUs as a pre-update component. An architecture for validation has been proposed that includes the DSU, the running program, the validator, and their communications. Along with the ability to describe the restrictions by using meta-data, a method has been presented to extract some constraints automatically. The gradual transition from the old version to the new version requires that the running application frequently switches between executing old and new code for a transient period. Although this swinging execution phenomenon is inevitable, its beginning can be selected. Considering this issue, an automatic method has been proposed to determine which part of the code is unsafe to participate in the swinging execution. The method has been implemented as a static analyzer which can annotate the unsafe part of the code as constraints. This approach is demonstrated in the evolution of the various versions of three different long-running software systems and compared to other approaches. Although the approach has been evaluated by evolving various programs, the impact of different changes in the dynamic update is not entirely clear. In addition, the study of the effect of these changes can identify code smells on the program, regarding the dynamic update issue. For the first time, the code smells have been introduced that may cause a run-time or syntax error on the dynamic update process. A set of candidate error-prone patterns has been developed based on programming language features and possible changes for each item. This set of 75 patterns is inspected by three distinct DSUs to identify problematic cases as code smells. Additionally, error- prone patterns set can be exploited as a reference set by other DSUs to measure own flexibility

DYNAMIC LANGUAGE UPDATING

With respect to traditional systems, language interpreters are hard to evolve and the adoption of evolved languages is slow. Language evolution is hindered by the fact that their implementations often overlook design principles, especially those related to modularity. Consequently, language implementations and their updates are monolithic. Language evolution often breaks the backward compatibility and requires developers to rewrite their applications. Furthermore, there is little or no support to evolve language interpreters at runtime. This would be useful for systems that cannot be shut down and to support context-aware interpreters. To tackle these issues, we designed the concept of open interpreters which provide support for language evolution through reflection. Open interpreters allow one to partially update a language to maintain the backward compatibility. Furthermore, they allow one to dynamically update a language without stopping the overlying application. Open interpreters can be dynamically tailored on the task to be solved. The peculiarity of this approach is that the evolution code is completely separated from the application or the original interpreter code. In this dissertation we define the concept of open interpreters, we design a possible implementation model, we describe a prototype implantation and provide the proof-of-concept examples applied to various domains

How To Touch a Running System

The increasing importance of distributed and decentralized software architectures entails more and more attention for adaptive software. Obtaining adaptiveness, however, is a difficult task as the software design needs to foresee and cope with a variety of situations. Using reconfiguration of components facilitates this task, as the adaptivity is conducted on an architecture level instead of directly in the code. This results in a separation of concerns; the appropriate reconfiguration can be devised on a coarse level, while the implementation of the components can remain largely unaware of reconfiguration scenarios. We study reconfiguration in component frameworks based on formal theory. We first discuss programming with components, exemplified with the development of the cmc model checker. This highly efficient model checker is made of C++ components and serves as an example for component-based software development practice in general, and also provides insights into the principles of adaptivity. However, the component model focuses on high performance and is not geared towards using the structuring principle of components for controlled reconfiguration. We thus complement this highly optimized model by a message passing-based component model which takes reconfigurability to be its central principle. Supporting reconfiguration in a framework is about alleviating the programmer from caring about the peculiarities as much as possible. We utilize the formal description of the component model to provide an algorithm for reconfiguration that retains as much flexibility as possible, while avoiding most problems that arise due to concurrency. This algorithm is embedded in a general four-stage adaptivity model inspired by physical control loops. The reconfiguration is devised to work with stateful components, retaining their data and unprocessed messages. Reconfiguration plans, which are provided with a formal semantics, form the input of the reconfiguration algorithm. We show that the algorithm achieves perceived atomicity of the reconfiguration process for an important class of plans, i.e., the whole process of reconfiguration is perceived as one atomic step, while minimizing the use of blocking of components. We illustrate the applicability of our approach to reconfiguration by providing several examples like fault-tolerance and automated resource control

Pitfalls in unanticipated dynamic software evolution

The authors of this paper have all developed a framework that allows runtime adaptation of software systems. Based on our experiences, we wish to summarize common pitfalls concerning dynamic software evolution. Systems for dynamic adaptation typically follow a certain process which is used as a starting point in this paper. The problems that occur in the different steps of this evolution process are given and a suggestion is made on how these problems can be tackled. The reader will notice that the solution to most of the pitfalls lies in the use of reflection, meta-data and meta-object protocols. We conclude that reflection or meta-object protocol manipulations are indispensable in the process of dynamic software evolution and that better language support is needed