Scheduling for next generation WLANs: filling the gap between offered and observed data rates

In wireless networks, opportunistic scheduling is used to increase system throughput by exploiting multi-user diversity. Although recent advances have increased physical layer data rates supported in wireless local area networks (WLANs), actual throughput realized are significantly lower due to overhead. Accordingly, the frame aggregation concept is used in next generation WLANs to improve efficiency. However, with frame aggregation, traditional opportunistic schemes are no longer optimal. In this paper, we propose schedulers that take queue and channel conditions into account jointly, to maximize throughput observed at the users for next generation WLANs. We also extend this work to design two schedulers that perform block scheduling for maximizing network throughput over multiple transmission sequences. For these schedulers, which make decisions over long time durations, we model the system using queueing theory and determine users' temporal access proportions according to this model. Through detailed simulations, we show that all our proposed algorithms offer significant throughput improvement, better fairness, and much lower delay compared with traditional opportunistic schedulers, facilitating the practical use of the evolving standard for next generation wireless networks

Resource allocation in wireless access network : A queueing theoretic approach

To meet its performance targets, the future 5G networks need to greatly optimize the Radio Access Networks (RANs), which connect the end users to the core network. In this thesis, we develop mathematical models to study three aspects of the operation of the RAN in modern wireless systems. The models are analyzed using  the techniques borrowed mainly from queueing theory and stochastic control. Also, simulations are extensively used to gain further insights. First, we provide a detailed Markov model of the random access process in LTE. From this, we observe that the bottleneck in the signaling channel causes congestion in the  access  when a large number of M2M devices attempt to enter the network. Then, in the context of the so-called Heterogeneous networks (HetNets), we suggest  dynamic load balancing schemes that alleviate this congestion and reduce the overall access delay. We then use flow-level models for elastic data traffic to study the problem of coordinating the activities of the neighboring base stations.  We seek to minimize the flow-level delay when there are various classes of users. We classify the users based on their locations, or, in dynamic TDD systems, on the direction of service the network is providing to them. Using interacting queues and different operating policies of running such queues, we study the amount of gain the dynamic policies can provide over the static probabilistic policies. Our results show that simple dynamic policies can  provide very good performance in the cases considered. Finally, we consider the problem of opportunistically scheduling the flows of users with time-varying channels  taking into account   the size of data they need to transfer. Using flow-level models in a system with homogeneous channels, we provide the optimal scheduling policy when there are  no new job arrivals. We also suggest the method to implement such a policy in a time-slotted system. With heterogeneous channels, the problem is intractable for the flow-level techniques. Therefore, we utilize the framework of the restless-multi-armed-bandit (RMAB) problems employing the so-called Whittle index approach. The Whittle index approach, by relaxing the scheduling constraints, makes the problem separable, and thereby provides an exact solution to the modified problem. Our simulations suggest that when  this solution is applied as a heuristic to the original problem, it gives good performance, even with dynamic job arrivals

Opportunistic scheduling of flows with general size distribution in wireless time-varying channels

In this paper we study how to design an opportunistic scheduler when flow sizes have a general service time distribution with the objective of minimizing the expected holding cost. We allow the channel condition to have two states which in particular covers the important special case of ON/OFF channels. We formulate the problem as a multi-armed restless bandit problem, a particular class of Markov decision processes. Since an exact solution is out of reach, we characterize in closed-form the Whittle index, which allows us to define a heuristic scheduling rule for the problem. We then particularize the index to the important subclass of distributions with a decreasing hazard rate. We finally evaluate the performance of the proposed Whittle-index based scheduler by simulation of a wireless network. The numerical results show that the performance of the proposed scheduler is very satisfactory

Schedulers for next generation wireless networks : realizing QoE trade-offs for heterogeneous traffic mixes

In this thesis we will focus on the design of schedulers for next generation wireless networks which support application mixes, characterized by different, possibly complex, application/user Quality of Experience (QoE) metrics. The central problem underlying resource allocation for such systems is realizing QoE trade-offs among various applications/users given the dynamic loads and capacity variability they would typically see. In the first part of the thesis our focus is on applications where QoE depends on flow-level delay-based metrics. We consider system-wide metrics which directly capture both users' QoE metrics and appropriate QoE trade-offs among various applications for a wide range of system loads. This approach is different from the traditional wireless scheduler designs which have been driven by rate-based criteria, e.g., utility maximizing/proportionally fair, and/or queue-based packet schedulers which do not directly reflect the link between flow-level delays and users' QoE. In the second part of this thesis we address the key design challenges in networks supporting Ultra Reliable Low Latency Communications (URLLC) traffic which requires extremely high reliability (99.999%) and very low delays (1 msec). We will explore three different types flow delay-based metrics in this proposal, based on 1) overall mean delay; 2) functions of mean delays; and, 3) mean of functions of delays. We begin by considering minimization of mean flow delay for an M/GI/1 queuing model for a wireless Base Station (BS) where the flow size distributions are of the New Better than Used in Expectation + Decreasing Hazard Rate (NBUE +DHZ) type. Such a flow size distribution have been observed in real systems and we too validate this model based on collected data. Using a combination of analysis and simulation we show that our scheduler achieves good performance for users that might correspond to interactive applications like web browsing and/or stored video streaming and is robust to variations in system loads. Next we consider a generalization of this approach where we minimize a metric based on cost functions of the mean flow delays in a multi-class system where users/flows are classified based on their respective QoE requirements and each class's QoE requirement is modeled by its respective cost function. This approach helps us model QoE more accurately and gives us more flexibility in considering QoE trade-offs among heterogeneous user classes. We optimize two different metrics based on how we average the cost functions of delays, namely, functions of mean delays; and mean of functions of delays. The former can be used when users' experiences are sensitive to mean delays and while the latter can be used when user's experience is also sensitive to higher moments of delays, e.g., variance or soft thresholds on delay. Extensive simulations confirm the effectiveness of our proposed approaches at realizing various QoE trade-offs and performance. In 5G wireless networks URLLC traffic is expected to support many applications like industrial automation, mission critical traffic, virtual traffic etc, where the wireless network has to reliability transport small packets with very high reliability and low delays. We address the following aspects related to the system design for URLLC traffic, 1) quantifying the impact of various system parameters like system bandwidth, link SINR, delay and latency constraints on URLLC 'capacity'; 2) provisioning wireless system appropriately to meet URLLC Quality of Service (QoS) requirements; and, 3) designing efficient Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) schemes for transmitting small packets. Further, due the heterogeneity in delay requirements between URLLC and other types of traffic, sharing radio resources between them creates its own unique challenges. We develop efficient multiplexing schemes between URLLC traffic and other mobile broadband traffic based on preemptive puncturing/superposition of the mobile broadband transmissions by URLLC transmissions.Electrical and Computer Engineerin

Hybrid, Job-Aware, and Preemptive Datacenter Scheduling

Scheduling in datacenters is an important, yet challenging problem. Datacenters are composed of a large number, typically tens of thousands, of commodity computers running a variety of data-parallel jobs. The role of the scheduler is to assign cluster resources to jobs, which is not trivial due to the large scale of the cluster, as well as the high scheduling load (tens of thousands of scheduling decisions per second). Additionally to scalability, modern datacenters face increasingly heterogeneous workloads composed of long batch jobs, e.g., data analytics, and latency-sensitive short jobs, e.g., operations of user-facing services. In such workloads, and especially if the cluster is highly utilized, it is challenging to avoid short running jobs getting stuck behind long running jobs, i.e. head-of-line blocking. Schedulers have evolved from being centralized (one single scheduler for the entire cluster) to distributed (many schedulers that take scheduling decisions in parallel). Although distributed schedulers can handle the large-scale nature of datacenters, they trade scheduling latency for accuracy. The complexity of scheduling in datacenters is exacerbated by the data-parallel nature of the jobs. That is, a job is composed of multiple tasks and the job completes only when all of its tasks complete. A scheduler that takes into account this fact, i.e. job-aware, could use this information to provide better scheduling decisions. Furthermore, to improve the quality of their scheduling decisions, most of datacenter schedulers use job runtime estimates. Obtaining accurate runtime estimates is, however, far from trivial, and erroneous estimates may lead to sub-optimal scheduling decisions. Considering these challenges, in this dissertation we argue the following: (i) that a hybrid centralized/distributed design can get the best of both worlds by scheduling long jobs in a centralized way and short jobs in a distributed way; (ii) such a hybrid scheduler can avoid head-of-line blocking and provide job-awareness by dynamically partitioning the cluster for short and long jobs and by executing a job to completion once it started; (iii) a scheduler can dispense with runtime estimates by sharing the resources of a node with preemption, and load balancing jobs among the nodes

Scheduling for today’s computer systems: bridging theory and practice

Scheduling is a fundamental technique for improving performance in computer systems. From web servers to routers to operating systems, how the bottleneck device is scheduled has an enormous impact on the performance of the system as a whole. Given the immense literature studying scheduling, it is easy to think that we already understand enough about scheduling. But, modern computer system designs have highlighted a number of disconnects between traditional analytic results and the needs of system designers. In particular, the idealized policies, metrics, and models used by analytic researchers do not match the policies, metrics, and scenarios that appear in real systems. The goal of this thesis is to take a step towards modernizing the theory of scheduling in order to provide results that apply to today’s computer systems, and thus ease the burden on system designers. To accomplish this goal, we provide new results that help to bridge each of the disconnects mentioned above. We will move beyond the study of idealized policies by introducing a new analytic framework where the focus is on scheduling heuristics and techniques rather than individual policies. By moving beyond the study of individual policies, our results apply to the complex hybrid policies that are often used in practice. For example, our results enable designers to understand how the policies that favor small job sizes are affected by the fact that real systems only have estimates of job sizes. In addition, we move beyond the study of mean response time and provide results characterizing the distribution of response time and the fairness of scheduling policies. These results allow us to understand how scheduling affects QoS guarantees and whether favoring small job sizes results in large job sizes being treated unfairly. Finally, we move beyond the simplified models traditionally used in scheduling research and provide results characterizing the effectiveness of scheduling in multiserver systems and when users are interactive. These results allow us to answer questions about the how to design multiserver systems and how to choose a workload generator when evaluating new scheduling designs

Scheduling of users with Markovian time-varying transmission rates

We address the problem of developing a well-performing and implementable scheduler of users with wireless connection to the base station. The main feature of such real-life systems is that the quality conditions of the user channels are time-varying, which turn into the time-varying transmission rate due to different modulation and coding schemes. We assume that this phenomenon follows a Markovian law and most of the discussion is dedicated to the case of three quality conditions of each user, for which we characterize an optimal index policy and show that threshold policies (of giving higher priority to users with higher transmission rate) are not necessarily optimal. For the general case of arbitrary number of quality conditions we design a scheduler and propose its two practical approximations, and illustrate the performance of the proposed index-based schedulers and existing alternatives in a variety of simulation scenarios

Voice Capacity and Data Response Time in Cognitive Radio Networks

The growing interest towards wireless communication services over the recent years has increased the demand for radio spectrum. Inefficient spectrum management together with the scarcity of the radio spectrum is a limiting factor for the development of modern wireless networks. As a solution, the idea of cognitive radio networks (CRNs) is introduced to use licensed spectrum for the benefit of the unlicensed secondary users. However, the preemptive priority of the licensed users results in random resource availabilities at the secondary networks, which makes the quality-of-service (QoS) support challenging. With the increasing demand for elastic/interactive data services (internet based services) and wireless multimedia services, QoS support becomes essential for CRNs. This research investigates the voice and elastic/interactive data service support over CRNs, in terms of their delay requirements. The packet level requirements of the voice service and session level delay requirements of the elastic/interactive data services are studied. In particular, constant-rate and on-off voice traffic capacities are analyzed over CRNs with centralized and distributed network coordination. Some generic channel access schemes are considered as the coordination mechanism, and call admission control algorithms are developed for non-fully-connected CRNs. Advantage of supporting voice traffic flows with different delay requirements in the same network is also discussed. The mean response time of the elastic data traffic over a centralized CRN is studied, considering the shortest processor time with and without preemption and shortest remaining processor time service disciplines, in comparison with the processor sharing service discipline. Effects of the traffic load at the base station and file length (service time requirement) distribution on the mean response time are discussed. Finally, the relationship between the mean response times of interactive and elastic data traffic is studied