A Comparison of Visualisation Methods for Disambiguating Verbal Requests in Human-Robot Interaction

Picking up objects requested by a human user is a common task in human-robot interaction. When multiple objects match the user's verbal description, the robot needs to clarify which object the user is referring to before executing the action. Previous research has focused on perceiving user's multimodal behaviour to complement verbal commands or minimising the number of follow up questions to reduce task time. In this paper, we propose a system for reference disambiguation based on visualisation and compare three methods to disambiguate natural language instructions. In a controlled experiment with a YuMi robot, we investigated real-time augmentations of the workspace in three conditions -- mixed reality, augmented reality, and a monitor as the baseline -- using objective measures such as time and accuracy, and subjective measures like engagement, immersion, and display interference. Significant differences were found in accuracy and engagement between the conditions, but no differences were found in task time. Despite the higher error rates in the mixed reality condition, participants found that modality more engaging than the other two, but overall showed preference for the augmented reality condition over the monitor and mixed reality conditions

Spatial representation for planning and executing robot behaviors in complex environments

Robots are already improving our well-being and productivity in different applications such as industry, health-care and indoor service applications. However, we are still far from developing (and releasing) a fully functional robotic agent that can autonomously survive in tasks that require human-level cognitive capabilities. Robotic systems on the market, in fact, are designed to address specific applications, and can only run pre-defined behaviors to robustly repeat few tasks (e.g., assembling objects parts, vacuum cleaning). They internal representation of the world is usually constrained to the task they are performing, and does not allows for generalization to other scenarios. Unfortunately, such a paradigm only apply to a very limited set of domains, where the environment can be assumed to be static, and its dynamics can be handled before deployment. Additionally, robots configured in this way will eventually fail if their "handcrafted'' representation of the environment does not match the external world. Hence, to enable more sophisticated cognitive skills, we investigate how to design robots to properly represent the environment and behave accordingly. To this end, we formalize a representation of the environment that enhances the robot spatial knowledge to explicitly include a representation of its own actions. Spatial knowledge constitutes the core of the robot understanding of the environment, however it is not sufficient to represent what the robot is capable to do in it. To overcome such a limitation, we formalize SK4R, a spatial knowledge representation for robots which enhances spatial knowledge with a novel and "functional" point of view that explicitly models robot actions. To this end, we exploit the concept of affordances, introduced to express opportunities (actions) that objects offer to an agent. To encode affordances within SK4R, we define the "affordance semantics" of actions that is used to annotate an environment, and to represent to which extent robot actions support goal-oriented behaviors. We demonstrate the benefits of a functional representation of the environment in multiple robotic scenarios that traverse and contribute different research topics relating to: robot knowledge representations, social robotics, multi-robot systems and robot learning and planning. We show how a domain-specific representation, that explicitly encodes affordance semantics, provides the robot with a more concrete understanding of the environment and of the effects that its actions have on it. The goal of our work is to design an agent that will no longer execute an action, because of mere pre-defined routine, rather, it will execute an actions because it "knows'' that the resulting state leads one step closer to success in its task