Beyond generic lifecycles : reusable modeling of custom-fit management workflows for cloud applications

Automated management and orchestration of cloud applications have become increasingly important, partly due to the large skills shortage in IT operations and the increasing complexity of cloud applications. Cloud modeling languages play an important role in this, both for describing the structure of a cloud application and specifying the management actions around it. The TOSCA cloud model standard recently defined declarative workflows as the preferred way to specify these management actions but, as noted in the standard itself, this is far from ideal. This paper draws lessons from six years of using declarative workflows in Juju for deploying and managing complex platforms such as OpenStack and Kubernetes in production. This confirms the limitations: declarative workflows are inflexible, hard to reuse, and allow for related components to become silently incompatible. This paper proposes the reactive pattern to solve these issues by enabling the creation of emergent workflows using declarative flags and handlers, which can be easily grouped into reusable layers. After more than two years of using this pattern in production as part of our charms. reactive framework, it is clear that it enables reusability and ensures compatibility: 67% of reactive charms share parts of the management workflow and 73% of reactive charms share a relationship workflow