A Review of the Monitoring of Market Power The Possible Roles of TSOs in Monitoring for Market Power Issues in Congested Transmission Systems

The paper surveys the literature and publicly available information on market power monitoring in electricity wholesale markets. After briefly reviewing definitions, strategies and methods of mitigating market power we examine the various methods of detecting market power that have been employed by academics and market monitors/regulators. These techniques include structural and behavioural indices and analysis as well as various simulation approaches. The applications of these tools range from spot market mitigation and congestion management through to long-term market design assessment and merger decisions. Various market-power monitoring units already track market behaviour and produce indices. Our survey shows that these units collect a large amount of data from various market participants and we identify the crucial role of the transmission system operators with their access to dispatch and system information. Easily accessible and comprehensive data supports effective market power monitoring and facilitates market design evaluation. The discretion required for effective market monitoring is facilitated by institutional independence.Electricity, liberalisation, market power, regulation

Electricity market clearing price forecasting under a deregulated electricity market

Under deregulated electric market, electricity price is no longer set by the monopoly utility company rather it responds to the market and operating conditions. Offering the right amount of electricity at the right time with the right bidding price has become the key for utility companies pursuing maximum profits under deregulated electricity market. Therefore, electricity market clearing price (MCP) forecasting became essential for decision making, scheduling and bidding strategy planning purposes. However, forecasting electricity MCP is a very difficult problem due to uncertainties associated with input variables. Neural network based approach promises to be an effective forecasting tool in an environment with high degree of non-linearity and uncertainty. Although there are several techniques available for short-term MCP forecasting, very little has been done to do mid-term MCP forecasting. Two new artificial neural networks have been proposed and reported in this thesis that can be utilized to forecast mid-term daily peak and mid-term hourly electricity MCP. The proposed neural networks can simulate the electricity MCP with electricity hourly demand, electricity daily peak demand, natural gas price and precipitation as input variables. Two situations have been considered; electricity MCP forecasting under real deregulated electric market and electricity MCP forecasting under deregulated electric market with perfect competition. The PJM interconnect system has been utilized for numerical results. Techniques have been developed to overcome difficulties in training the neural network and improve the training results

Forecasting Mid-Term Electricity Market Clearing Price Using Support Vector Machines

In a deregulated electricity market, offering the appropriate amount of electricity at the right time with the right bidding price is of paramount importance. The forecasting of electricity market clearing price (MCP) is a prediction of future electricity price based on given forecast of electricity demand, temperature, sunshine, fuel cost, precipitation and other related factors. Currently, there are many techniques available for short-term electricity MCP forecasting, but very little has been done in the area of mid-term electricity MCP forecasting. The mid-term electricity MCP forecasting focuses electricity MCP on a time frame from one month to six months. Developing mid-term electricity MCP forecasting is essential for mid-term planning and decision making, such as generation plant expansion and maintenance schedule, reallocation of resources, bilateral contracts and hedging strategies. Six mid-term electricity MCP forecasting models are proposed and compared in this thesis: 1) a single support vector machine (SVM) forecasting model, 2) a single least squares support vector machine (LSSVM) forecasting model, 3) a hybrid SVM and auto-regression moving average with external input (ARMAX) forecasting model, 4) a hybrid LSSVM and ARMAX forecasting model, 5) a multiple SVM forecasting model and 6) a multiple LSSVM forecasting model. PJM interconnection data are used to test the proposed models. Cross-validation technique was used to optimize the control parameters and the selection of training data of the six proposed mid-term electricity MCP forecasting models. Three evaluation techniques, mean absolute error (MAE), mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) and mean square root error (MSRE), are used to analysis the system forecasting accuracy. According to the experimental results, the multiple SVM forecasting model worked the best among all six proposed forecasting models. The proposed multiple SVM based mid-term electricity MCP forecasting model contains a data classification module and a price forecasting module. The data classification module will first pre-process the input data into corresponding price zones and then the forecasting module will forecast the electricity price in four parallel designed SVMs. This proposed model can best improve the forecasting accuracy on both peak prices and overall system compared with other 5 forecasting models proposed in this thesis

Uniform Pricing or Pay-as-Bid Pricing: A Dilemma for California and Beyond

Any belief that a shift from uniform to as-bid pricing would provide power purchasers substantial relief from soaring prices is simply mistaken. The immediate consequence of its introduction would be a radical change in bidding behavior that would introduce new inefficiencies, weaken competition in new generation, and impede expansion of capacity.Auctions, Electricity Auctions, Multiple Item Auctions

Optimal Participation of Power Generating Companies in a Deregulated Electricity Market

The function of an electric utility is to make stable electric power available to consumers in an efficient manner. This would include power generation, transmission, distribution and retail sales. Since the early nineties however, many utilities have had to change from the vertically integrated structure to a deregulated system where the services were unbundled due to a rapid demand growth and need for better economic benefits. With the unbundling of services came competition which pushed innovation and led to the improvement of efficiency. In a deregulated power system, power generators submit offers to sell energy and operating reserve in the electricity market. The market can be described more as oligopolistic with a System Operator in-charge of the power grid, matching the offers to supply with the bid in demands to determine the market clearing price for each interval. This price is what is paid to all generators. Energy is sold in the day-ahead market where offers are submitted hours prior to when it is needed. The spot energy market caters to unforeseen rise in load demand and thus commands a higher price for electrical energy than the day-ahead market. A generating company can improve its profit by using an appropriate bidding strategy. This improvement is affected by the nature of bids from competitors and uncertainty in demand. In a sealed bid auction, bids are submitted simultaneously within a timeframe and are confidential, thus a generator has no information on rivals’ bids. There have been studies on methods used by generators to build optimal offers considering competition. However, many of these studies base estimations of rivals’ behaviour on analysis with sufficient bidding history data from the market. Historical data on bidding behaviour may not be readily available in practical systems. The work reported in this thesis explores ways a generator can make security-constrained offers in different markets considering incomplete market information. It also incorporates possible uncertainty in load forecasts. The research methodology used in this thesis is based on forecasting and optimization. Forecasts of market clearing price for each market interval are calculated and used in the objective function of profit maximization to get maximum benefit at the interval. Making these forecasts includes competition into the bid process. Results show that with information on historical data available, a generator can make adequate short-term analysis on market behaviour and thus optimize its benefits for the period. This thesis provides new insights into power generators’ approach in making optimal bids to maximize market benefits

Feature selection and parameter optimization with GA-LSSVM in electricity price forecasting

Forecasting price has now become essential task in the operation of electrical power system. Power producers and customers use short term price forecasts to manage and plan for bidding approaches, and hence increasing the utility’s profit and energy efficiency as well. The main challenge in forecasting electricity price is when dealing with non-stationary and high volatile price series. Some of the factors influencing this volatility are load behavior, weather, fuel price and transaction of import and export due to long term contract. This paper proposes the use of Least Square Support Vector Machine (LSSVM) with Genetic Algorithm (GA) optimization technique to predict daily electricity prices in Ontario. The selection of input data and LSSVM’s parameter held by GA are proven to improve accuracy as well as efficiency of prediction. A comparative study of proposed approach with other techniques and previous research was conducted in term of forecast accuracy, where the results indicate that (1) the LSSVM with GA outperforms other methods of LSSVM and Neural Network (NN), (2) the optimization algorithm of GA gives better accuracy than Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) and cross validation. However, future study should emphasize on improving forecast accuracy during spike event since Ontario power market is reported as among the most volatile market worldwide

Application of Core Vector Machine for Prediction of Day-Ahead Electricity Prices

This paper presents Core Vector Machine (CVM) applied for short term electricity price forecasting in an Indian energy market. The accuracy in electricity price forecasting is very crucial for the power producers and consumers. With the accurate price forecasting, power producers can maximize their profit and manage short term operation. Meanwhile, consumers can maximize their utilities efficiently. The objective of this research is to develop models for day-ahead price forecasting using CVM during various seasons. A feature selection technique is used along with the CVM to reduce the variables for accurate price forecasting. Simulation results reveal that the CVM along with feature selection gives better results when compared with other machine learning techniques

Forecasting Italian Electricity Zonal Prices with Exogenous Variables

In the last few years we have observed deregulation in electricity markets and an increasing interest of price dynamics has been developed especially to consider all stylized facts shown by spot prices. Only few papers have considered the Italian Electricity Spot market since it has been deregulated recently. Therefore, this contribution is an investigation with emphasis on price dynamics accounting for technologies, market concentration and congestions. We aim to understand how technologies, concentration and congestions affect the zonal prices since these ones combine to bring about the single national price (prezzo unico d’acquisto, PUN). Hence, understanding its features is important for drawing policy indications referred to production planning and selection of generation sources, pricing and risk–hedging problems, monitoring of market power positions and finally to motivate investment strategies in new power plants and grid interconnections. Implementing Reg–ARFIMA–GARCH models, we assess the forecasting performance of selected models showing that they perform better when these factors are considered.Electricity prices, Production technologies, Market power (HHI, RSI), Congestions, Fractional Integration, Forecasting