Fencing Programs with Self-Invalidation and Self-Downgrade

International audienceCache coherence protocols using self-invalidation and self-downgrade have recently seen increased popularity due to their simplicity, potential performance efficiency, and low energy consumption. However, such protocols result in memory instruction reordering, thus causing extra program behaviors that are often not intended by the programmer. We propose a novel formal model that captures the semantics of programs running under such protocols, and employs a set of fences that interact with the coherence layer. Using the model, we perfform a reachability analysis that can check whether a program satisfies a given safety property with the current set of fences. Based on an algorithm in [19], we describe a method for insertion of optimal sets of fences that ensure correctness of the program under such protocols. The method relies on a counter-example guided fence insertion procedure. One feature of our method is that it can handle a variety of fences (with different costs). This diversity makes optimization more difficult since one has to optimize the total cost of the inserted fences, rather than just their number. To demonstrate the strength of our approach, we have implemented a prototype and run it on a wide range of examples and benchmarks. We have also, using simulation, evaluated the performance of the resulting fenced programs

Efficient coherence and consistency for specialized memory hierarchies

As the benefits from transistor scaling slow down, specialization is becoming increasingly important for a wide range of applications. Although traditional heterogeneous systems work well for streaming, data parallel applications, they are inefficient for emerging applications, like graph analytics workloads, with fine-grained synchronization, relaxed atomics, and more general sharing patterns. Heterogeneous systems are also difficult to program, which makes it harder for programmers to take advantage of the potential benefits of specialization. This thesis redesigns the memory hierarchy of heterogeneous systems to make heterogeneous systems more efficient and easier to use. In particular, we focus on three key sources of inefficiency in the memory hierarchy of modern heterogeneous systems: (1) a unified global address space, (2) the cache coherence protocol, and (3) the memory consistency model. A unified global address space makes it easier to write programs for heterogeneous systems. Although industry has recently begun to provide a unified global address space across CPUs and accelerators (primarily GPUs), there are many inefficiencies. For example, emerging applications with fine-grained synchronization need better support for coherence and consistency. We find that simple coherence and complex consistency are key sources of inefficiency. To resolve this problem, we adjust the division of complexity between the cache coherence protocol and memory consistency model: we introduce DeNovo for accelerators (DeNovoA), which extends DeNovo’s hybrid, software-driven hardware coherence protocol to heterogeneous systems. Unlike current coherence protocols for heterogeneous systems, DeNovoA obtains ownership for written data, enables heterogeneous systems to use the simpler sequentially consistent for data-race-free (SC-for-DRF, or DRF) memory consistency model, and provides both efficiency and programmability. Across a wide variety of applications, DeNovoA with a DRF memory consistency model either outperforms or provides comparable efficiency to a the state-of-the-art approach. Although DRF is easier to use and works well for most applications, there are some corner cases where its overheads are unnecessary and hurt performance. This led to the introduction of relaxed atomics in the memory consistency models for multi-core CPUs and heterogeneous systems. Although relaxed atomics can significantly improve performance, they are very difficult to use correctly. We address the impact of relaxed atomics on memory consistency models for heterogeneous systems by creating a new memory consistency model, Data-Race-Free-Relaxed or DRFrlx. DRFrlx extends the existing DRF memory consistency models to provide SC-centric semantics for all common uses of relaxed atomics in heterogeneous systems while retaining their efficiency benefits. Thus, DRFrlx makes it easier for programmers to safely use relaxed atomics. Although current heterogeneous systems are adopting unified global address spaces, specialized memories such as scratchpads still exist in disjoint, private address spaces. This increases programming complexity and causes inefficiencies that negate some of the benefits of specialization. We introduce a new memory organization, stash, that mitigates the inefficiencies of specialized memories by integrating them into the coherent, globally visible address space. Stash makes it easier for programmers to use specialized memories and retains their efficiency benefits. Finally, to better understand the tradeoffs and scalability of different coherence protocols and consistency models, we created a suite of synchronization microbenchmarks, HeteroSync. HeteroSync contains various fine-grained synchronization and relaxed atomics algorithms. Moreover, HeteroSync is highly configurable and provides a standard set of fine-grained synchronization microbenchmarks to compare the efficiency of different approaches. In summary, this thesis questions the state-of-the-art approaches for designing memory hierarchies of heterogeneous systems, and shows that the current techniques provide neither efficiency nor programmability for emerging workloads. We demonstrate how DeNovoA with a DRFrlx memory consistency model improves efficiency and programmability for many heterogeneous applications and makes it easier for programmers to use heterogeneous systems