Knowledge-Context in search systems: Toward information-literate actions

In this perspectives paper we define knowledge-context as meta information that searchers use when making sense of information displayed in and accessible from a search engine results page (SERP). We argue that enriching the knowledge-context in SERPs has great potential for facilitating human learning, critical thinking, and creativity by expanding searchers’ information-literate actions such as comparing, evaluating, and differentiating between information sources. Thus it supports the development of learning-centric search systems. Using theories and empirical findings from psychology and the learning sciences, we first discuss general effects of Web search on memory and learning. After reviewing selected research addressing metacognition and self-regulated learning, we discuss design goals for search systems that support metacognitive skills required for long-term learning, creativity, and critical thinking. We then propose that SERPs make both bibliographic and inferential knowledge-context readily accessible to motivate and facilitate information-literate actions for learning and creative endeavors. A brief discussion of related ideas, designs, and prototypes found in prior work follows. We conclude the paper by presenting future research directions and questions on knowledge-context, information-literate actions, and learning-centric search systems.Peer Reviewedhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/148270/1/Smith and Rieh Knowledge-Context in Search Systems CHIIR2019.pd

Topic-independent modeling of user knowledge in informational search sessions

Web search is among the most frequent online activities. In this context, widespread informational queries entail user intentions to obtain knowledge with respect to a particular topic or domain. To serve learning needs better, recent research in the field of interactive information retrieval has advocated the importance of moving beyond relevance ranking of search results and considering a user’s knowledge state within learning oriented search sessions. Prior work has investigated the use of supervised models to predict a user’s knowledge gain and knowledge state from user interactions during a search session. However, the characteristics of the resources that a user interacts with have neither been sufficiently explored, nor exploited in this task. In this work, we introduce a novel set of resource-centric features and demonstrate their capacity to significantly improve supervised models for the task of predicting knowledge gain and knowledge state of users in Web search sessions. We make important contributions, given that reliable training data for such tasks is sparse and costly to obtain. We introduce various feature selection strategies geared towards selecting a limited subset of effective and generalizable features. © 2021, The Author(s)

The Search as Learning Spaceship: Toward a Comprehensive Model of Psychological and Technological Facets of Search as Learning

Using a Web search engine is one of today’s most frequent activities. Exploratory search activities which are carried out in order to gain knowledge are conceptualized and denoted as Search as Learning (SAL). In this paper, we introduce a novel framework model which incorporates the perspective of both psychology and computer science to describe the search as learning process by reviewing recent literature. The main entities of the model are the learner who is surrounded by a specific learning context, the interface that mediates between the learner and the information environment, the information retrieval (IR) backend which manages the processes between the interface and the set of Web resources, that is, the collective Web knowledge represented in resources of different modalities. At first, we provide an overview of the current state of the art with regard to the five main entities of our model, before we outline areas of future research to improve our understanding of search as learning processes

The Search as Learning Spaceship: Toward a Comprehensive Model of Psychological and Technological Facets of Search as Learning

Using a Web search engine is one of today’s most frequent activities. Exploratory search activities which are carried out in order to gain knowledge are conceptualized and denoted as Search as Learning (SAL). In this paper, we introduce a novel framework model which incorporates the perspective of both psychology and computer science to describe the search as learning process by reviewing recent literature. The main entities of the model are the learner who is surrounded by a specific learning context, the interface that mediates between the learner and the information environment, the information retrieval (IR) backend which manages the processes between the interface and the set of Web resources, that is, the collective Web knowledge represented in resources of different modalities. At first, we provide an overview of the current state of the art with regard to the five main entities of our model, before we outline areas of future research to improve our understanding of search as learning processes. Copyright © 2022 von Hoyer, Hoppe, Kammerer, Otto, Pardi, Rokicki, Yu, Dietze, Ewerth and Holtz

Models and Algorithms for Understanding and Supporting Learning Goals in Information Retrieval

While search technology is widely used for learning-oriented information needs, the results provided by popular services such as Web search engines are optimized primarily for generic relevance, not effective learning outcomes. As a result, the typical information trail that a user must follow while searching to achieve a learning goal may be an inefficient one, possibly involving unnecessarily difficult content, or material that is irrelevant to actual learning progress relative to a user's existing knowledge. My work addresses these problems through multiple studies where various models and frameworks are developed and tested to support particular dimensions of search as learning. Empirical analysis of these studies through user studies demonstrate promising results and provide a solid foundation for further work. The earliest work we focused on centered on developing a framework and algorithms to support vocabulary learning objectives in a Web document context. The proposed framework incorporates user information, topic information and effort constraints to provide a desirable combination of personalized and efficient (by word length) learning experience. Our user studies demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework against a strong commercial baseline's (Google search) results in both short- and long-term assessment. While topic-specific content features (such as frequency of subtopic occurrences) naturally play a role in influencing learning outcomes, stylistic and structural features of the documents themselves may also play a role. Using such features we construct robust regression models that show strong predictive strength for multiple measures of learning outcomes. We also show early evidence that regression models trained on one dataset of search as learning can show strong test-set predictions on an independent dataset of search as learning, suggesting a certain degree of generalizability of stylistic content features. The models developed in my work are designed to be as generalizable, scalable and efficient as possible to make it easier for practitioners in the field to improve how people use search engines for learning. Finally, we investigate how gaze-tracking and automatic question generation could be used to scale a form of active learning to arbitrary text material. Our results show promising potential for incorporating interactive learning experiences in arbitrary text documents on the Web. A major theme in these studies centers on understanding and improving how people learn when using Web search engines. We also put specific emphasis on long-term learning outcomes and demonstrate that our models and frameworks actually yield sustainable knowledge gains, both for passive and interactive learning. Taken together, these research studies provide a solid foundation for multiple promising directions in exploring search as learning.PHDInformationUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/155065/1/rmsyed_1.pd