Bio-mimetic Adaptive Force/Position Control Using Fractal Impedance

The ability of animals to interact with complex dynamics is unmatched in robots. Especially important to the interaction performances is the online adaptation of body dynamics, which can be modeled as an impedance behaviour. However, the variable impedance controller still possesses a challenge in the current control frameworks due to the difficulties of retaining stability when adapting the controller gains. The fractal impedance controller has been recently proposed to solve this issue. However, it still has limitations such as sudden jumps in force when it starts to converge to the desired position and the lack of a force feedback loop. In this manuscript, two improvements are made to the control framework to solve these limitations. The force discontinuity has been addressed introducing a modulation of the impedance via a virtual antagonist that modulates the output force. The force tracking has been modeled after the parallel force/position controller architecture. In contrast to traditional methods, the fractal impedance controller enables the implementation of a search algorithm on the force feedback to adapt its behaviour on the external environment instead of on relying on \textit{a priori} knowledge of the external dynamics. Preliminary simulation results presented in this paper show the feasibility of the proposed approach, and it allows to evaluate the trade-off that needs to be made when relying on the proposed controller for interaction. In conclusion, the proposed method mimics the behaviour of an agonist/antagonist system adapting to unknown external dynamics, and it may find application in computational neuroscience, haptics, and interaction control.Comment: \c{opyright} 2020 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other work

Robust impedance control for dexterous interaction using fractal impedance controller with IK-optimisation

Robust dynamic interactions are required to move robots in daily environments alongside humans. Optimisation and learning methods have been used to mimic and reproduce human movements. However, they are often not robust and their generalisation is limited. This work proposed a hierarchical control architecture for robot manipulators and provided capabilities of reproducing human-like motions during unknown interaction dynamics. Our results show that the reproduced end-effector trajectories can preserve the main characteristics of the initial human motion recorded via a motion capture system, and are robust against external perturbations. The data indicate that some detailed movements are hard to reproduce due to the physical limits of the hardware that cannot reach the same velocity recorded in human movements. Nevertheless, these technical problems can be addressed by using better hardware and our proposed algorithms can still be applied to produce imitated motion

Rich periodic motor skills on humanoid robots: Riding the pedal racer

Just as their discrete counterparts, periodic or rhythmic dynamic motion primitives allow easily modulated and robust motion generation, but for periodic tasks. In this paper we present an approach for modulating periodic dynamic movement primitives based on force feedback, allowing for rich motor behavior and skills. We propose and evaluate the combination of feedback and learned feed-forward terms to fully adapt the motions of a robot in order to achieve a desired force interaction with the environment. For the learning we employ the notion of repetitive control, which can effectively minimize the error of behavior towards a given reference. To demonstrate the approach, we show results of simulated and real world experiments on a compliant humanoid robot COMAN. We show the initial results of utilizing the approach to control a pedal-racer, a demanding balance toy best described as a hybrid between a skateboard and a bicycle. © 2014 IEEE

The design, validation, and performance evaluation of an untethered ankle exoskeleton

Individuals with neuromuscular impairment from conditions like cerebral palsy face reduced quality of life due to diminishing mobility and independence. Lower-limb exoskeletons, particularly ankle exoskeletons, have potential to aid mobility in impaired populations and augment performance in unimpaired populations and have been extensively researched for the past decade. Few untethered ankle exoskeletons exist due to the difficulty of providing enough mechanical power to offset the weight of the exoskeleton on top of improving human biomechanics and metabolic efficiency. Short battery life is also an obstacle to widespread adoption of untethered ankle exoskeletons in the clinic and at home. In this work, we assess the efficacy of our prototype devices during over-ground walking, design new exoskeleton controllers, develop a new ankle exoskeleton device from the ground up, and evaluate the potential for parallel elasticity to improve the performance of our refined exoskeleton platform. In the first study, we observed that our ankle exoskeleton prototype improved metabolic economy, increased walking speed, and lowered plantarflexor muscle activity in a small cohort of individuals with cerebral palsy during over-ground walking – a significant obstacle to the adoption of exoskeletons in free-living settings. In the second study, we presented a framework for developing adaptive, torque sensor-less open-loop controllers that were competitive with our standard closed-loop controllers in mechanical terms while reducing motor energy consumption and noise. The shortcomings of our prototypes in the first and second chapters inspired a third study to develop new lightweight and modular ankle exoskeleton design with a significantly higher torque and power output and joint-level sensing that improved metabolic economy in both unimpaired and impaired cohorts – our device is the second ever to improve metabolic economy in unimpaired adults. We also presented the first-ever lower-limb exoskeleton usability study. In the final study, we use our new hardware platform to design, validate, and demonstrate that a simple parallel elastic element can significantly improve the performance and battery life of our device. Together, these studies establish our untethered ankle exoskeletons as effective and versatile tools for rehabilitation and human augmentation and support the continued research of exoskeletons in clinical and at-home settings

Neuro-musculoskeletal Models: A Tool to Study the Contribution of Muscle Dynamics to Biological Motor Control

Das Verständnis der Prinzipien, die menschlichen Bewegungen zugrunde liegen, ist die Basis für die Untersuchung der Entstehung gesunder Bewegungen und, was noch wichtiger ist, der Entstehung motorischer Störungen aufgrund neurodegenerativer Erkrankungen oder anderer pathologischer Zustände. Dieses Verständnis zu erlangen ist jedoch herausfordernd, da menschliche Bewegung das Ergebnis eines komplexen, dynamischen Zusammenspiels von biochemischen und biophysikalischen Prozessen im Bewegungsapparat und den hierarchisch organisierten neuronalen Kontrollstrukturen ist. Um die Wechselwirkungen dieser Strukturen zu untersuchen, bieten Computersimulationen, die mathematische Modelle des muskuloskelettalen Systems mit Modellen seiner neuronalen Kontrolle kombinieren, ein nützliches Werkzeug. In diesen Simulationen können einzelne Prozesse oder ganze Funktionseinheiten deaktiviert oder gestört werden, um die Auswirkungen dieser Veränderungen auf die vorhergesagten Bewegungen zu untersuchen. Die Plausibilität der zugrundeliegenden Modelle kann durch den Vergleich der Simulationen mit Daten aus Humanexperimenten und biologisch inspirierten Robotermodellen beurteilt werden. Das Ziel dieser Arbeit war es, neuro-muskuloskelettale Modelle als Hilfsmittel zur Untersuchung von Konzepten der biologischen Bewegungskontrolle zu verwenden. Von besonderem Interesse war der Beitrag der Muskeldynamik zur Kontrolle, d.h. wie die intrinsischen muskuloskelettalen Eigenschaften die motorische Kontrolle vereinfachen, ohne die motorische Genauigkeit zu beeinträchtigen. Zusätzlich wurde der Einfluss propriozeptiver Reflexmechanismen in verschiedenen Szenarien getestet. Die verwendeten neuro-muskuloskelettalen Modelle sind eine Kombination von Mehrkörpermodellen der Muskel-Skelett-Struktur des Armes oder des ganzen Körpers mit einem biologisch inspirierten hybriden Gleichgewichtspunkt-Kontrollmodell. In einer Simulationsstudie stellten wir fest, dass unser Armmodell realistische Reaktionen auf externe mechanische Störungen für zielgerichtete Bewegungen mit einem Freiheitsgrad vorhersagt. Auf dieser Grundlage simulierten wir die Anwendung von tragbaren Assistenzgeräten zur Kompensation unerwünschter Hypermetrie, d.h. einer überschießenden Reaktion bei zielgerichteten Bewegungen im Zusammenhang mit zerebellärer Ataxie und anderen neurodegenerativen Erkrankungen. Wir fanden heraus, dass einfache mechanische Hilfsmittel ausreichend sein können, um die Hypermetrien auf ein normales Niveau zu reduzieren. Wir stellten jedoch auch fest, dass die Größe des Drehmoments und der Kraft, die zur Kompensation der Störung erforderlich sind, möglicherweise deutlich unterschätzt wird, wenn die Muskel-Sehnen-Eigenschaften im Modell nicht berücksichtigt werden. Die Ergebnisse dieser beiden Studien bestätigten die Hypothese aus der Literatur, dass die Morphologie des Muskel-Skelett-Systems signifikant zur Bewegung beiträgt und somit deren Kontrolle vereinfacht. Deshalb haben wir einen informationstheoretischen Ansatz verwendet, um diesen Beitrag für zielgerichtete und oszillatorische Armbewegungen mit zwei Freiheitsgraden zu charakterisieren. Die Ergebnisse bestätigten, dass die unteren Kontrollebenen, einschließlich der Muskeln und ihrer Aktivierungsdynamik, wichtige Beiträge zur gesamten Kontrollhierarchie leisten. Beispielsweise führt ein einfaches, stückweise konstantes Muskelstimulationssignal, das nur wenig Information enthält, zu einer geschmeidigen Bewegung. Der physiologische Detailgrad, der in unseren Muskel-Skelett-Modellen enthalten ist, ermöglicht nicht nur die Untersuchung von Theorien zur motorischen Kontrolle, sondern auch die Untersuchung von Größen wie inneren Kräften in Muskeln und Gelenken, die experimentell normalerweise nicht zugänglich sind. Diese Größen sind zum Beispiel in der Ergonomie und für die Entwicklung von Assistenzgeräten von Bedeutung. In einer Ganzkörpersimulationsstudie untersuchten wir den Beitrag des Dehnungsreflexes zu den resultierenden Muskelkräften bei einer aktiven externen Repositionierung des Hüftgelenkes für einen großen Bereich von Bewegungsgeschwindigkeiten. Wir fanden heraus, dass der relative Kraftbeitrag des Feedback-Mechanismus vom modellierten kognitiven Zustand abhängig ist und einen nicht vernachlässigbaren Beitrag leistet, insbesondere bei hohen Repositionsgeschwindigkeiten. Die Gesamtheit unserer Ergebnisse zeigt, dass die Eigenschaften des Bewegungsapparates signifikant zur Erzeugung und Kontrolle von Bewegung beitragen und es daher wichtig ist, sie bei der Modellierung der menschlichen Bewegung zu berücksichtigen. Daher sprechen die Ergebnisse für die Kombination eines physiologisch fundierten biomechanischen und biochemischen Modells des Bewegungsapparates mit biologisch inspirierten Konzepten der motorischen Kontrolle. Diese Computersimulationen haben sich als ein nützliches Werkzeug zum Verständnis der Prozesse erwiesen, die der Erzeugung gesunder und pathologisch beeinträchtigter menschlicher Bewegungen zugrunde liegen.Understanding the principles underlying human movement is the basis for investigating the generation of healthy movements and, more importantly, the origins of motor disorders due to neurodegenerative diseases or other pathological conditions. However, gaining this understanding is challenging since human motion is the result of a complex, dynamic interplay of biochemical and biophysical processes in the musculoskeletal system and the hierarchically organized neuronal control structures. To study the interactions of these structures, computer simulations that combine mathematical models of the musculoskeletal system with models of its neuronal control provide a useful tool. In these simulations, single processes or whole functional units can be disabled or perturbed to study the effects of these changes on the predicted movements. The plausibility of the underlying models can be assessed by comparing the simulations with data from human experiments and biologically inspired robotic models. The purpose of this work was to use neuro-musculoskeletal models as tools to study concepts of biological motor control. Of particular interest was the contribution of muscle dynamics to the control, i.e. how the intrinsic musculoskeletal properties simplify motor control without compromising motor accuracy. Additionally, the influence of proprioceptive reflex mechanisms was tested in different scenarios. The neuro-musculoskeletal models that were used are a combination of multibody musculoskeletal models of the arm or the whole body with a biologically inspired hybrid equilibrium-point controller. In a simulation study, we found that our arm model predicts realistic reactions to external mechanical perturbations while performing one-degree-of-freedom goal-directed movements. Based on this, we simulated the application of wearable assistive devices to compensate for unwanted hypermetria, i.e. an overshooting response in goal-directed movements associated with cerebellar ataxia and other neurodegenerative disorders. We found that simple mechanical devices may be sufficient to reduce the hypermetria to a normal level. However, we also observed that the magnitude of torque and power that is required to compensate for the disorder may be significantly underestimated if muscle-tendon characteristics are not considered in the computational model. The results of these two studies confirmed the hypothesis from literature that the morphology of musculoskeletal systems significantly contributes to the movement and thus simplifies its control. Therefore, we made use of the information-theoretic approach of quantifying morphological computation to characterize this contribution for goal-directed and oscillatory arm movements with two degrees of freedom. The results asserted that the lower levels of control, including the muscles and their activation dynamics, make important contributions to the overall control hierarchy. For example, a simple piecewise constant muscle stimulation signal that contains only little information results in a smooth movement. The level of physiological detail that is included in our musculoskeletal models does not only allow for the examination of motor control theories but also makes it possible to study quantities like internal forces in muscles and joints, usually not experimentally accessible. These quantities are relevant, for example, in ergonomics and for the development of assistive devices. In a whole-body simulation study, we investigated the contribution of the stretch reflex to the resulting muscle forces during active external repositioning of the hip joint for a large range of movement velocities. We found that, depending on the modeled cognitive state, the relative force contribution of the feedback mechanism is not negligible, especially for high repositioning velocities. The entirety of our results shows that the properties of the musculoskeletal system significantly contribute to the generation and control of movement and, thus, it is important to take them into account when modeling human movement. Therefore, the results advocate the combination of a physiologically well-founded biomechanical and biochemical model of the musculoskeletal system with biologically inspired concepts of motor control. These computer simulations have proven to be a useful tool towards the comprehension of the processes underlying the generation of healthy and pathologically impaired human movements

Dynamic Primitives in the Control of Locomotion

Humans achieve locomotor dexterity that far exceeds the capability of modern robots, yet this is achieved despite slower actuators, imprecise sensors and vastly slower communication. We propose that this spectacular performance arises from encoding motor commands in terms of dynamic primitives. We propose three primitives as a foundation for a comprehensive theoretical framework that can embrace a wide range of upper- and lower-limb behaviors. Building on previous work that suggested discrete and rhythmic movements as elementary dynamic behaviors, we define submovements and oscillations: As discrete movements cannot be combined with sufficient flexibility, we argue that suitably-defined submovements are primitives. As the term rhythmic may be ambiguous, we define oscillations as the corresponding class of primitives. We further propose mechanical impedances as a third class of dynamic primitives, necessary for interaction with the physical environment. Combination of these three classes of primitive requires care. One approach is through a generalized equivalent network: a virtual trajectory composed of simultaneous and/or sequential submovements and/or oscillations that interacts with mechanical impedances to produce observable forces and motions. Reliable experimental identification of these dynamic primitives presents challenges: Identification of mechanical impedances is exquisitely sensitive to assumptions about their dynamic structure; identification of submovements and oscillations is sensitive to their assumed form and to details of the algorithm used to extract them. Some methods to address these challenges are presented. Some implications of this theoretical framework for locomotor rehabilitation are considered