Deterministic Calibration and Nash Equilibrium

We provide a natural learning process in which the joint frequency of empirical play converges into the set of convex combinations of Nash equilibria. In this process, all players rationally choose their actions using a public prediction made by a deterministic, weakly calibrated algorithm. Furthermore, the public predictions used in any given round play are frequently close to some Nash equilibrium of the game

Continuous and randomized defensive forecasting: unified view

Defensive forecasting is a method of transforming laws of probability (stated in game-theoretic terms as strategies for Sceptic) into forecasting algorithms. There are two known varieties of defensive forecasting: "continuous", in which Sceptic's moves are assumed to depend on the forecasts in a (semi)continuous manner and which produces deterministic forecasts, and "randomized", in which the dependence of Sceptic's moves on the forecasts is arbitrary and Forecaster's moves are allowed to be randomized. This note shows that the randomized variety can be obtained from the continuous variety by smearing Sceptic's moves to make them continuous.Comment: 10 pages. The new version: (1) relaxes the assumption that the outcome space is finite, and now it is only assumed to be compact; (2) shows that in the case where the outcome space is finite of cardinality C, the randomized forecasts can be chosen concentrated on a finite set of cardinality at most

A Geometric Proof of Calibration

We provide yet another proof of the existence of calibrated forecasters; it has two merits. First, it is valid for an arbitrary finite number of outcomes. Second, it is short and simple and it follows from a direct application of Blackwell's approachability theorem to carefully chosen vector-valued payoff function and convex target set. Our proof captures the essence of existing proofs based on approachability (e.g., the proof by Foster, 1999 in case of binary outcomes) and highlights the intrinsic connection between approachability and calibration

On impossibility of sequential algorithmic forecasting

The problem of prediction future event given an individual sequence of past events is considered. Predictions are given in form of real numbers $p_n$ which are computed by some algorithm $varphi$ using initial fragments $omega_1,dots, omega_{n-1}$ of an individual binary sequence $omega=omega_1,omega_2,dots$ and can be interpreted as probabilities of the event $omega_n=1$ given this fragment. According to Dawid\u27s {it prequential framework} %we do not consider %numbers $p_n$ as conditional probabilities generating by some %overall probability distribution on the set of all possible events. we consider partial forecasting algorithms $varphi$ which are defined on all initial fragments of $omega$ and can be undefined outside the given sequence of outcomes. We show that even for this large class of forecasting algorithms combining outcomes of coin-tossing and transducer algorithm it is possible to efficiently generate with probability close to one sequences for which any partial forecasting algorithm is failed by the method of verifying called {it calibration}

Stochastic uncoupled dynamics and Nash equilibrium

In this paper we consider dynamic processes, in repeated games, that are subject to the natural informational restriction of uncoupledness. We study the almost sure convergence to Nash equilibria, and present a number of possibility and impossibility results. Basically, we show that if in addition to random moves some recall is introduced, then successful search procedures that are uncoupled can be devised. In particular, to get almost sure convergence to pure Nash equilibria when these exist, it su±ces to recall the last two periods of play.Uncoupled, Nash equilibrium, stochastic dynamics, bounded recall

Channel Selection for Network-assisted D2D Communication via No-Regret Bandit Learning with Calibrated Forecasting

We consider the distributed channel selection problem in the context of device-to-device (D2D) communication as an underlay to a cellular network. Underlaid D2D users communicate directly by utilizing the cellular spectrum but their decisions are not governed by any centralized controller. Selfish D2D users that compete for access to the resources construct a distributed system, where the transmission performance depends on channel availability and quality. This information, however, is difficult to acquire. Moreover, the adverse effects of D2D users on cellular transmissions should be minimized. In order to overcome these limitations, we propose a network-assisted distributed channel selection approach in which D2D users are only allowed to use vacant cellular channels. This scenario is modeled as a multi-player multi-armed bandit game with side information, for which a distributed algorithmic solution is proposed. The solution is a combination of no-regret learning and calibrated forecasting, and can be applied to a broad class of multi-player stochastic learning problems, in addition to the formulated channel selection problem. Analytically, it is established that this approach not only yields vanishing regret (in comparison to the global optimal solution), but also guarantees that the empirical joint frequencies of the game converge to the set of correlated equilibria.Comment: 31 pages (one column), 9 figure

On-line regression competitive with reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces

We consider the problem of on-line prediction of real-valued labels, assumed bounded in absolute value by a known constant, of new objects from known labeled objects. The prediction algorithm's performance is measured by the squared deviation of the predictions from the actual labels. No stochastic assumptions are made about the way the labels and objects are generated. Instead, we are given a benchmark class of prediction rules some of which are hoped to produce good predictions. We show that for a wide range of infinite-dimensional benchmark classes one can construct a prediction algorithm whose cumulative loss over the first N examples does not exceed the cumulative loss of any prediction rule in the class plus O(sqrt(N)); the main differences from the known results are that we do not impose any upper bound on the norm of the considered prediction rules and that we achieve an optimal leading term in the excess loss of our algorithm. If the benchmark class is "universal" (dense in the class of continuous functions on each compact set), this provides an on-line non-stochastic analogue of universally consistent prediction in non-parametric statistics. We use two proof techniques: one is based on the Aggregating Algorithm and the other on the recently developed method of defensive forecasting.Comment: 37 pages, 1 figur