Lossless Differential Compression for Synchronizing Arbitrary Single-Dimensional Strings

Differential compression allows expressing a modified document as differences relative to another version of the document. A compressed string requires space relative to amount of changes, irrespective of original document sizes. The purpose of this study was to answer what algorithms are suitable for universal lossless differential compression for synchronizing two arbitrary documents either locally or remotely. Two main problems in differential compression are finding the differences (differencing), and compactly communicating the differences (encoding). We discussed local differencing algorithms based on subsequence searching, hashtable lookups, suffix searching, and projection. We also discussed probabilistic remote algorithms based on both recursive comparison and characteristic polynomial interpolation of hashes computed from variable-length content-defined substrings. We described various heuristics for approximating optimal algorithms as arbitrary long strings and memory limitations force discarding information. Discussion also included compact delta encoding and in-place reconstruction. We presented results from empirical testing using discussed algorithms. The conclusions were that multiple algorithms need to be integrated into a hybrid implementation, which heuristically chooses algorithms based on evaluation of the input data. Algorithms based on hashtable lookups are faster on average and require less memory, but algorithms based on suffix searching find least differences. Interpolating characteristic polynomials was found to be too slow for general use. With remote hash comparison, content-defined chunks and recursive comparison can reduce protocol overhead. A differential compressor should be merged with a state-of-art non-differential compressor to enable more compact delta encoding. Input should be processed multiple times to allow constant a space bound without significant reduction in compression efficiency. Compression efficiently of current popular synchronizers could be improved, as our empiral testing showed that a non-differential compressor produced smaller files without having access to one of the two strings